**you guys are completely missing the point. **
I agree. What startles me is that I subject my heart to more work than an elite marathoner, yet I eat a horrendous diet, juggle work/family, and drink like a fish.
**you guys are completely missing the point. **
I agree. What startles me is that I subject my heart to more work than an elite marathoner, yet I eat a horrendous diet, juggle work/family, and drink like a fish.
Most of the post seems like total shit to me - and for the second time this week Phidipedes did not die after running just a marathon, he died after running that marathon AFTER running like 150 mile just before it all.
Can’t tell you you are trolling or serious - serious I imagine since I can’t believe the effort put into the OP. Either way friggin weird place to post it.
Dude, you crack me up. You have this moral outrage about Phidipedes and the exact amount he ran before collapsing. It is impossile to confirm not only whether he did this, but also how far he ran. It’s called conjecture.
Relax and drop the arrogant moral outrage.
**What startles me is that I subject my heart to more work than an elite marathoner, yet I eat a horrendous diet, juggle work/family, and drink like a fish. **
I’m pretty sure at least 2-3 drinks a day cancels out most if not all of the 10 reasons, so you should be ok.
I like the idea of dropping dead one day from a marathon et al.
to hell with the slow rot that afflicts sedentary folks as they age well beyond what our genetics were designed for, propped up by medications that prolong life but not always the quality.
I’d be far more satisfied to go with a bang than to moulder away watching myself fall apart.
Do marathons at your own peril! That’s why I’m sticking to 5 kms and 10 kms.
Q. What do you call somebody who did marathons for 25 yrs.
A. A cyclist.
Nice research. Note that pretty much everything you list are either non-causative, or well described for any kind of prolonged, heavy exercise. The inflammatory markers are obviously elevated more than in most other activities, but after the marathon they are acute, therefore go away: all the reports here show various things elevated immediately post-marathon. What else would you expect? It’s hard exercise, that’s (part of) the point of it. If you couldn’t find things to indicate that you were systemically stressed, you wouldn’t be trying very hard.
There are important implications from elevated imflammatory markers when they are chronically elevated. You get this from sitting on your ass too much. It’s no secret that moderate levels are exercise are beneficial for health, and being drastically either side of this continuum is detrimental, so nothing new here.
The bit about the 4 Boston marathon runners and brain cancer? There are probably at least 4 runners over the years that have run the marathon and lived to 100 as well.
I’d agree that there are probably some good reasons why you shouldn’t run marathons, but you haven’t listed them.
wow! you don’t seem to bright with overtraining.
Umm, … neither do you.
Reasons 11-15 of why not to run a marathon, by Peter Griffin
i’m not a retard, i just play one on tv
actually, i really am a retard, it’s just that i don’t like admitting that about myself…the irony is that it feels so good to do it though.
i think i’m clever for posting some shit like this about marathons, even though some other a-hole came up with it, because it makes me look smart. looking smart is fun, and i like big league chew. have you ever said that fast 10 times? i like big league chew, big league chew, big league chew, big leak fu. that sounds like, hey man (bleep) you. ahahahahahahaha.
in the 80’s i had a thing for don johnson. long story short, we had a fling, but he dumped me and i still wear his white jacket.
i realize i’m supposed to be telling you about why you shouldn’t do marathons, except the original author of the original thread stopped at 10, and well, since i’ve never ran a day in my life and am totally uneducated and inexperienced about the sport that you crazy kids participate in, i decided to continue making up crap for this list because my favorite number is 15.
ahhh…15.
fi,fi,fi,fi,fi,fifteen.
that just feels good.
Thanks for listening. I’m Peter Griffin.
Top ten reason TO run a marathon
Nice!!! You might find yourself in trouble with Powercrankers with #3 though…
And the data that suggests that running increases the rate of development of osteoarthritis is where exactly?
There will be twice as many people needing knees and hips because the average person will be another 20 pounds heavier…
Dave
Top ten reason TO run a marathon
Marathon running damages the liver and gall bladder
When I decided to take up running I had my gal bladder removed as a precaution to avoid problems like these.
I did also have some gal stones, but I think that was inconsequential to the reason for gal bladder removal.
Anything done to excess is bad and that is why I absolutely refused to try to run 300 miles straight.
I have actually worked on this theory with amazing results… : ) == My current formula is pi = 12, so in a marathon setting that would mean you need to drink 12 beers. Alcohol may lead to an accelerated heartrate but there would be an increase in the pain threshold, thus equating to a faster split. Using this formula for shorter races, you just use the mean of one half case per race, divided by 1 Multiplied by sum of the mean.
Through my extensive studies I found that Smithwicks provides better top end speed, but can also lead to heartburn, a standard Coors Light or Budweiser will work fine on hot and humid days, but steer clear of Corona since the name is very similar to the the heart condition it may cause.
More studies are needed for the effects of other alcohols…
JD
The conclusion in #10 states “ultra-marathon running is associated with…” Are we talking marathons or ultra-marathons? What distance ultra-marathons?
The statement in #10 that “HDL is lowered, LDL is increased” is inconsistent with general observations for runners in which cholesterol levels are superior to non-runners. Observed measurements for HDL were reported at second and ninth day after the (ultramarathon) event. What about 30 days after or 90 days after?
i’m sure it’s out there, i really don’t feel like looking though.
i work in an operating room during the summer. I’m friends with a number of orthopedic guys, and ALL of them have said that running is NOT good for your joints.
but don’t listen to them, just make sure you don’t piss them off before your knee replacement at 45.
Maybe chronic marathoners have more resilient legs and feet than the rest of us. Otherwise, their leg and foot injuries would have (should have) stopped them from doing marathons by now. I decided after two marathons that they weren’t good for me. 10Ks are my marathons these days.
We’ve had a death at the Toronto Marathon the last couple of years (3 years out of 4 I think?). The interesting thing, though, is that each time the runner who died was running the half marathon, not the full. Obviously, not a scientific study, but still interesting given the OP.
This was written up by one of those fat doctors.
Q. What do you call somebody who did marathons for 25 yrs.
A. A cyclist.
I did my first marathon (of 30+) 30 years ago and no joint replacements on the horizon, although I am definitely cutting back on the number of long runs. I have done most of my running for the last 20+ years off road, which I think is smart.
I would like to be running another 25 years and I have had concerns about continuing triathlon cycling because of that desire. I think a serious cycling accident could be one thing that could end or seriously hinder my running because of any joint damage/arthritis that could result from an accident.
Is outdoor cycling really any better for the body than running when you include injuries resulting from accidents and damage to the heart, etc. resulting from long rides done over many years? I’d be interested in a long-term study that compared injuries/death rates in cyclists v. runners.