Top 10 Most Difficult Sports per Sporteology.com

I don’t agree with skiing being at #3 at all. Been a skier all my life started at the age of 2 and get in at least about 25 a days a year now. Moved to the Alps just for skiing and picked up triathlon along the way. It can be difficult to get very good at it, one analogy I’ve heard often is that snowboarding is harder to learn to do and then easier to become “good” at while skiing is easier to pick up and then much harder to master, which, although also arguable in itself, does tell the truth in that essentially anyone can ski.

The fact that they don’t define what “most difficult” means makes the list questionable off the bat and skiing being so high up totally undermines any credibility it had with me.

http://thechive.com/2014/10/21/take-a-ride-on-an-insane-motorcycle-race-through-streets-of-a-portugal-video/
.

Tennis should be on the list. It requires the full package: power, endurance, technical skills, mental toughness, and a good sense of strategy. Well, except it’s not dangerous.

Women’s gymnastics should not be on the list, and certainly not #1. It’s a highly idiosyncratic sport that is best done by people in a very narrow age range and with particular body types. Whatever it is rewarding, for some reason, is not possessed by any woman over the age of about 25.

Not sure about your logic here. Why does the fact that gymnastics is only done at the highest levels during a certain age range mean that it’s not difficult?

I got a good chuckle at this line about why swimming is hard…

“Staying underwater and flapping one’s legs and arms is a difficult task”

Tennis should be on the list. It requires the full package: power, endurance, technical skills, mental toughness, and a good sense of strategy. Well, except it’s not dangerous.

Women’s gymnastics should not be on the list, and certainly not #1. It’s a highly idiosyncratic sport that is best done by people in a very narrow age range and with particular body types. Whatever it is rewarding, for some reason, is not possessed by any woman over the age of about 25.

There are all sorts of body types, but strength to weight is critical. There are a few world class gymnasts over 25, but most are younger. It’s too hard for most people over 25. The men tend to be older. There is no doubt in my mind this is one of the toughest sports. My college baseball player son couldn’t hang for an hour of my daughters conditioning. The whole point of the article is difficulty and most people, no matter the age, aren’t capable of competing at the mid levels of gymnastics. Physicsl and mental strength, speed, balance, power, agility, got to have it all.

Their are very few really great QB’s because it requires more than just physical talent throwing the ball, but fast reflexes and snap judgments of a defense.

Doesn’t that describe every professional soccer player, except of course they’re doing it with every part of their body except arms and hands, and the situations they do it in are far less stereotyped?

I got a good chuckle at this line about why swimming is hard…

“Staying underwater and flapping one’s legs and arms is a difficult task”

That best describes how I used to swim before taking swim lessons. For many years I prided myself on my ability to stay in the water longer than anyone else during a triathlon. I was usually the last one out, while everyone else had quit early and had jumped on their bikes to escape the water.

Using proper grammar might be just as hard a task for them as some of the “sports” on their list. Some of those descriptions were painful to read.

I closed the page after seeing this: “It is one of two styles of wrestling besides the Greco-Roman Wrestling that is contested in the Olympic Games.”

It takes 4/10 of a second for a 95 MPH fastball to reach homeplate. Now add in the fact that the speeds change and are not straight.
Hitting a baseball is the hardest thing to do in sports…IMO
Does that mean it is the toughest sport?
I have seen guys go from never wrestling (very tough sport) and in four years winning a HS state championship and going on to wrestle for D-1 program.
Just saying that strength and endurance can be had with lots of hard work and with that one usually gains mental toughness.
Hand/Eye cordination might be something one is just born with.
I am not taking anything away from those other sports as they all seem tough to me or downright crazy…bull riding.

Hockey should be on the list.

And this is why journalism is dead. Because some bullshit list like this can get as much attention as anything written by the New York Times or the Wall Street Journal.

Their are very few really great QB’s because it requires more than just physical talent throwing the ball, but fast reflexes and snap judgments of a defense.

Doesn’t that describe every professional soccer player, except of course they’re doing it with every part of their body except arms and hands, and the situations they do it in are far less stereotyped?

Maybe if you were doing it with 300+ lb freaks of nature that can bench 400lbs and run 5 sec 40s bearing down on you and trying to drive you into the ground while you are trying to pass the ball…

Their are very few really great QB’s because it requires more than just physical talent throwing the ball, but fast reflexes and snap judgments of a defense.

Doesn’t that describe every professional soccer player, except of course they’re doing it with every part of their body except arms and hands, and the situations they do it in are far less stereotyped?

Soccer players are tremendously skilled and fit, but I’m not putting them on any list that positively ranks sports until they stop flopping around on the ground like babies every time they make any contact with another player.

Their are very few really great QB’s because it requires more than just physical talent throwing the ball, but fast reflexes and snap judgments of a defense.

Doesn’t that describe every professional soccer player, except of course they’re doing it with every part of their body except arms and hands, and the situations they do it in are far less stereotyped?

Maybe if you were doing it with 300+ lb freaks of nature that can bench 400lbs and run 5 sec 40s bearing down on you and trying to drive you into the ground while you are trying to pass the ball…

Most of the time they’re doing it under time and space constraints too which is what makes the task harder.

Not sure about your logic here. Why does the fact that gymnastics is only done at the highest levels during a certain age range mean that it’s not difficult?

Because it means that a lot of what the sport is testing is body type, rather than other facets such as endurance, etc. The hardest sports should be those that can be done by a fairly wide range of ages, body types, etc. That way, we know that the sport is testing talent, determination, etc., rather than just quirks of body types. So, if the sport can only be done by very skinny young women, that means it is heavily testing something other than experience, determination, etc.

The other reason is that, almost by definition, if the best people in a sport are teenagers, then experience is being undervalued or undertested in a sport. In most sports, people continue to improve for a long time, as they gain fitness, experience, and such. That does not happen with women’s gymnastics. That does not happen with women’s gymnastics.

The final reason is that if a sport draws from a very narrow segment of the population, then it’s easier to be the best at that sport. If you have those characteristics, you don’t have to compete against as many people to be the best.

You list both strength and power. How much strength and power do women’s gymnasts really have? They’re tiny, so the power to weight ratio is decent. But, do you really think one of those tiny women’s gymnasts could do well at cycling, or weight lifting or other activities that test power more directly?

Also, athletic women don’t get weaker when they turn 25. The reason that women generally can’t compete in gymnastics beyond age 25 is not because they are getting weaker. It’s because the sport tests a rather idiosyncratic set of abilities. If you take any reasonably healthy 10 year old kid and any reasonably fit 40 year-old and have them hang from a monkey bar, the 10-year old will win by a lot. It’s not because the kid is fitter or tougher or anything like. It’s just one of the quirks of youth.

Suppose a world class female tennis player and a world class female gymnast competed in a decathlon, which tests a fairly wide range of strength, power and speed. Do you really think the gymnast would have much of a chance?

Because it means that a lot of what the sport is testing is body type, rather than other facets such as endurance, etc.

Every major sport has a body type that excels. You’ve gotta be tall to play basketball. You’ve gotta be big to play football. You’ve gotta have a certain body type to be elite in almost any sport. That doesn’t mean those sports don’t also require other aspects. If you think anyone who happens to be short could be an elite gymnast, you don’t know much about the sport.

The hardest sports should be those that can be done by a fairly wide range of ages, body types, etc.

Why?

That way, we know that the sport is testing talent, determination, etc., rather than just quirks of body types.

Again, just because a certain body type is required doesn’t mean the sport doesn’t also test those things.

The other reason is that, almost by definition, if the best people in a sport are teenagers, then experience is being undervalued or undertested in a sport. In most sports, people continue to improve for a long time, as they gain fitness, experience, and such. That does not happen with women’s gymnastics.

You sure about that? Elite female gymnasts have usually be doing gymnastics for a decade, and for several years at the top levels. Almost all sports have a relatively narrow age range during which people can be elite. If you can do a sport when you’re old just as well as when you’re young, then I’m not sure how you think that means the sport is harder.

The final reason is that if a sport draws from a very narrow segment of the population, then it’s easier to be the best at that sport. If you have those characteristics, you don’t have to compete against as many people to be the best.

It’s easier to be the best in comparison to others who can’t do the sport. That doesn’t mean it’s easier to be good at the sport.


I’m going to assume you’ve never done it.

Motor Cross? Never, but I have raced Moto-Cross, Cross Country, and Enduros pretty much my entire life, dabbled a little in Flat Track, and picked up a motorcycle Road Racing State Championship along the way.

Well, that’s one way to make Duffy disappear from a thread.

Please don’t make a charicature of my argument. I never said anyone who is young can be an elite gymnast. Equally, it takes more than height to be a good basketball player.

And, of course, you have to be dedicated and serious and talented to be a world class gymnast. You have to have those qualities to be world class at just about anything. If there was a sport in which the goal was to dunk on the highest possible rim, the winner would be a serious, dedicated athlete. It wouldn’t just be some couch potato who happened to be tall. But, I would not say that the sport was the hardest in the world, precisely because 99% of the population can’t possibly even compete in the sport.

The point is: when you single out a particular sport, out of all the other sports, and say it’s the hardest or one of the hardest, you need to explain why it is harder than the other sports. Every sport is hard at the elite level. You can find lots of sports – like my dunking example – where the sport tests for a very narrow and specialized talent. That’s fine. But, why would you say that’s the hardest sport?

Yes, of course, the best female gymnasts have been practicing for quite a few years. The best female tennis players, too, have been practicing for many years before they reach the elite level. The difference is that a female can be a top tennis player at roughly age 16 and can stay at or near the top until their mid-30s. The sport tests experience, so that gets rewarded. The sport doesn’t elude you once you hit puberty. Female gymnastics has a much narrower window.

Sure, every sport rewards some body type, but they don’t all do so in the radical way that women’s gymnastics does. There is probably a 10-12" height differential between the shortest great tennis player (Chang or Rosewall?) and the tallest (not sure who, but there were some tall ones). There is a fairly wide range of body types from Serena Williams to some who are quite skinny.