Because it means that a lot of what the sport is testing is body type, rather than other facets such as endurance, etc.
Every major sport has a body type that excels. You’ve gotta be tall to play basketball. You’ve gotta be big to play football. You’ve gotta have a certain body type to be elite in almost any sport. That doesn’t mean those sports don’t also require other aspects. If you think anyone who happens to be short could be an elite gymnast, you don’t know much about the sport.
The hardest sports should be those that can be done by a fairly wide range of ages, body types, etc.
Why?
That way, we know that the sport is testing talent, determination, etc., rather than just quirks of body types.
Again, just because a certain body type is required doesn’t mean the sport doesn’t also test those things.
The other reason is that, almost by definition, if the best people in a sport are teenagers, then experience is being undervalued or undertested in a sport. In most sports, people continue to improve for a long time, as they gain fitness, experience, and such. That does not happen with women’s gymnastics.
You sure about that? Elite female gymnasts have usually be doing gymnastics for a decade, and for several years at the top levels. Almost all sports have a relatively narrow age range during which people can be elite. If you can do a sport when you’re old just as well as when you’re young, then I’m not sure how you think that means the sport is harder.
The final reason is that if a sport draws from a very narrow segment of the population, then it’s easier to be the best at that sport. If you have those characteristics, you don’t have to compete against as many people to be the best.
It’s easier to be the best in comparison to others who can’t do the sport. That doesn’t mean it’s easier to be good at the sport.