The mighty SEC

Well Penn State lined up against the fearsome Tennessee Volunteers(fearsome because, well the SEC is fearsome…they tell you so). Penn State, you’ll recall is the Top 20 team that Michigan didn’t play. Yes Michigan played them, and beat them, but because Michigan was too stupid to play them shortly after Ohio State and Notre Dame had played them, they dropped out of the polls. OSU and ND get a “vs Top 20 win”, but not Michigan, which obviously shows why Florida should be playing OSU. But I digress. Penn State faced down Tennessee, and when it came to crunch time, Tony Hunt just ran throuhg them like a wet paper bag. Florida beat tennessee, Michigan beat Penn State, Penn State beat Tennessee. Hmmm.

Meanwhile, Auburn, that pillar of strength who actually beat Florida, called forward a super human effort to win, 17-14, against a team who had their 5th defeat of the season. A superlative total of 177 yards of offense drove home the point the SEC is where it’s at.

Of course, Arkansas will show its mettle in the second half, because that 17-7 halftime lead for Wisconsin is nothing but smoke and mirrors. NO doubt 30-40 points will be seen.

In an act of charity, as everyone knows the Big Ten is slow, Troy Smith, who won the Heisman trophy, and LaMarr Woodley, Lombardi Award winner, were named Chevy players of the year. Crumbs for the little sister.

But TripleThreat said the SEC is the “best” conference in football?? I don’t understand.

By the way, Auburn was lucky to escape with the win, and Nebraska sucks. Hopefully the SEC comes through against ND, I can’t wait to see Brady Quinn cry again.

Im a Big 12 fan, but Ill readily admit the SEC is best from top to bottom…but Tenn folded and Auburn barely beat a VERY average Neb team…
As a Sooner, and with a relative who played for Bud Wilkenson and was the Tight End when ND ended OU’s 47 game winning streak…it is in my blood to hate ND…I cant wait for LSU to kill them tomorrow…

Ark is also losing to Wisc.

We’ll see how it plays out today…I love Jan 1 and all the Bowl games… Ran 1:20 this AM, and Ive gone throw a hefty bowl of queso and about a half bag of chips!

I’m with 'ya Big10 brethren. The Badgers just beat the second best team in the SEC (Arkansas) - actually, I’m a little surprised. Now go 'em Wolverines! BTW, Iowa also should have won that game. Regardless, all you will hear about from the SEC now is “top to bottom.” OK. We all want to see Northwestern play Vanderbilt in a bad way …

How bout them wolverines–hail to the… nevermind. : )

C’mon, 2 bowl games and we’re throwing out the year-after-year superiority of the SEC in terms of number of ranked teams, number of bowl teams, and bowl win-loss records? This is one of the few years where the Big 10’s smashmouth is countering the SEC’s speed. That doesn’t often happen.

As a big 10 fan in big 10 country, I’m just enbjoying the victories while they last.

If Florida happens to beat Ohio State (which might be possible given that USC thumped Michigan and Boise State is beating OU), does that mean the SEC is better than the Big 10, or should we just rationally look at it as one game?

THe SEC is to football what the ACC is to basketball (I hardly invented that idea/comparison). That doesn’t mean that in a given year that another conference won’t have a better head-to-head record against the ACC in the tournament.

No need to go to the other extreme based on 2-3 Bowl Games. The Big 10 teams haven’t made the mistakes in the 2 bowl games, the SEC teams have. In a rematch that stat could be reversed. That’s the excitement of playing the games versus deciding them on paper (or by voting).

End of Season Top 25 teams - Coach’s Poll – SEC(5), Big 10(3), Big East (3), Big 12 (4), PAC 10 (3), ACC (3). Media reflects essentially the same thing, except the ACC get GT in.

BCS Top 25, essentially the same thing except UCLA is in at 25.

So, when we look at “dominant conferences”, this is one thing to consider, and before the bowl games (i.e., head-to-head matchups) were played (and our previous discussions took place) the SEC was better than the other conferences, and they are year-after-year. The two head-to-head victories change the perspective of THIS year, but don’t replace the past … otherwise we’d be hailing the Colonial Conference as a basketball powerhouse. =)

Looking at this more … well, because that’s what I do. =)

#6 Wisconsin (12-1) beats #12 Arkansas (10-4) 17-14. Wisconsin goes under the radar all year because they played one ranked team … and lost. That HAS TO BE expected. The top teams in the Big East played more ranked teams. That has to be taken into consideration. As a comparison, Arkansas played 5 ranked teams (not including Wisconsin). Arkansas outrushed Wisconsin 232 to -5. I’m not saying that “stats” determine the game, but Arkansas had 12 penalties for 123 yards. That’s why they lost. Still handicapping themselves that poorly, they darn near won (as an underdog). I’m glad the Big 10 won, but I would prefer it be a team other than Wisconsin … their fans are too close (to me) and really annoying. =)

Going by the rankings, this game should’t have been a surprise.

Unranked Penn State (9-4) beats #17 Tennessee (9-4) 20-10. Penn State played 4 ranked teams (#4ND, #1OSU, #4Mich, and #17Wisc) and lost to them all. Not, that it’s as bad as it sounds, they played 3 games against top 5 teams. Tennesse lost to #7Flo, #13LSU, and #11Ark (2 of which ended the season in the top 5). Tennessee wins the “statistical game”, but has 3 turnovers, when Penn State has none (onlt time all year). It’s like Penn State finally figured out that if you take care of the ball, you usually win. =) I’m sure I’m not the only one that has been frustrated with Penn State under-performing for the past 5 years.

This game is pretty stunning. PSU wins because they don’t have any turnovers. Good for them, but that’s rare for the Nittany Lions.

I knew I could get at least 2 long posts out of you. Secretly I was hoping for 3 :slight_smile:

Oh well, all this chatter is what makes college football great. By the way, no chance in hell FL beats THE OSU :slight_smile:

I never pull for OSU, but Monday is an exception. Not only do I want them to win, I won’t be happy unless they hang about 70 on Florida. I want them to show Urban Meyer just exactly what he campaigned himself into.

Seeing what Troy Smith did to Michigan, I don’t see anything from Florida that suggests they will stop him either.

THe SEC is to football what the ACC is to basketball


TT, since you like looking this stuff up…lol…, but if I’m not mistaken, hasn’t the ACC only put 4 teams in the tourney the last few years? And they’ve beena 12 team conference for a while now. 34 at large bids and they can only get 3 of them? I think there is a lot more reputation than actual performance in both these sports and conferences.

I think the ACC has been destroyed by the NBA draft. Right about Vince Carter left early. He seemed to be one of the first guys from schools like Maryland, Duke, Carolina, Wake Forest, etc to leave early. I admit the ACC isn’t what it used to be … if anything the SEC has stepped up its basketball playing. BUt, that’s taking into consideration that the ACC used to be head and shoulders above everyone else, and now they’ve dropped a notch. BUt, admitting the ACC has dropped a bit in basketball, doesn’t mean the SEC has dropped in football. Year-in and year-out the SEC is deep with ranked teams. I’m hoping the big 10 follows thius thrend, and I don’t why they can’t. OSU and Michigan will always be good. Penn State and Wisconsin should continue to be good (and have been good for awhile now). If Purdue can get back to where it was, and Iowa can return to its high potential teams, the Big 10 could be a very strong force. Northwestern, Indiana, Illinois and (likely) Michigan State will always suck (except for the freak year where an over-achieving team meets a soft a schedule).

Basketball seems to be the strager of the two. I know as a Big 10 fan, it seems anytime we send 7 teams to the big dance, most of em are gone by the sweet 16. When we send 4 (or 5) and it’s a “down year” for the Big 10 … 2 of em go to the final four (and 1of the 2 always seems to be wisconsin). Weird.

I don’t necessarily dispute the “reputation” aspect versus performance. But, when I look at the SEC and specifrically the conference schedule I see a lot more games featuring ranked teams. We can debate whether the teams deserve the rankings they get … but we can’t debate the number of games versus ranked teams, or the number of teams that go to the bowls. I primarily look at the latter.

… That’s why they lost. Still handicapping themselves that poorly, they darn near won (as an underdog). I’m glad the Big 10 won, but I would prefer it be a team other than Wisconsin … their fans are too close (to me) and really annoying. =)

Hey, I’m one of those annoying Wisco fans… :slight_smile:

I think ARK was actually favored in that game, tho…so I wouldn’t call them an underdog. Not really sure how Wisconsin pulled that one out, but that was the way they played this year. They found a way to win.

It was interesting that these two teams were tied for #31 in the pre-season polls. I can’t stand these polls. During the USC-MI game, the announcers basically proclaimed USC the pre-season #1 – not that I disagree, but c’mon. The pre-season poll is given too much weight. Teams should play a few games before rankings come out.

Hey, I’m one of those annoying Wisco fans… :slight_smile:

By annoying, I mean “everything they wear is red and white” and “they are loyal to a fault” … and they’re located in Illinois. Keept eh red & white (and green & yellow) north of the border where it belongs. We’re an orange and blue state. =)

They found a way to win.

Same thing could be said about Florida … they played some close games that likely shouldn’t have been close. Only loss stemmed from a block punt returned for a TD. Not that I’m touting Florida, just sayin’.

The pre-season poll is given too much weight. Teams should play a few games before rankings come out.

Actually, in the computer formula, early season rankings are thrown out toward the end (which was one of my complaints about the computer formula). So, that means, Ohio State doesn’t get credit for beating a #2 team (Texas) even though all of us that watched the gamne clearly noticed OSU was ranked #1 and Texas was #2. Meanwhile, USC gets credit for beating a #5 Arkansas (before the SEC championship game) when Ark was unranked in week one. I won’;t even get started on my “with the computer formula and its use of rankings, winning games actually hurts your strength of schedule” rant.

I’m not sure what to do with pre/early season rankings. Either make them count or don’t have them. I support the team’s ranking at the time of the game counting (not the final ranking), and possibly not having the AP/Coach rankings come out until conference play starts … but even then you’re essentially having “pre-season” rankings since many teams will be 3-0 without playing much competition.

41-14

I guess that puts the Big 10 Vs. SEC argument to bed.

Enough said

The Big Ten is

OVERRATED



.

Only if over-rated means “better than the SEC”.

Which conferences, in total, are better than the Big 10? Let’s list and compare.

It means “better than the SEC” because all I’ve been hearing is how the Big Ten was the dominant conference in football.

Who has been telling you that?

I think the consensus was that Ohio State was dominating the current college season, but for most of this year the Big 10(11) has been deemed the “Big 2 and little 9” … and as it turns out the big surprise was the Big 10’s 3 and 4 were pretty good and the 1 and 2 weren’t as good as adertised.

I admit I’m surprised. I thought it was an insult to Michigan for them to have to play a USC team that had lost to 2 unranked teams. THat’s not to say USC and Michigan weren’;t comparable in terms of talent, just that one team didn’t seem to be the other team’s equal in actual performance. Of course, we all know how the head-to-head matchup played out.

and I thought OSU would beat Florida,although I predicted a 7-pt victory. I thought it would be close, with a posied Troy Smith making a big play or spinning out of a sack for a big play, etc. Wasn’t even close.

Really, I think a case could be made for LSU and Florida being the 2 most impressive teams of the season … I mean standing where we are now and looking back.

I think Florida and LSU are the 2 best teams in the country followed by USC and then Boise State.

I’ll give the Big Ten one team in the top 5 but still think, that Auburn would beat either Ohio State or Michigan.

I think the Big Ten teams are good in games involving other Big Ten teams but fast teams and ones with an explosive offense would beat them. I think LSU would beat both Ohio State and Michigan relatively easily.

Even a Florida player said they have played 4 or 5 teams that could do what they did against Ohio State.

When SC tried the Big 10 style running game of pounding it between the tackles they got stuffed every time, granted it was primarily a true frosh carrying the ball. Against each other, a team in that conference that can move the ball and stop the run looks like a real threat to win it all. Unfortunately, the Big 10 is one-dimensional, relying on statues for linemen and typically one speed guy that’s cake for a decent secondary to over/under. Look for a decent secondary in the Big 10 and prepare for disappointment. Put athletes on the field against them and they will run around them or “baffle” them with blitz packages.
The Buckeyes have compiled a 15-19 bowl record, including a 3-9 mark in their past 12 appearances. Ouch.
Michigan is 1-5 in their last 6.
I’m not much of a sports bettor, but I’m seeing some easy money next year.
The only thing I’m convinced of, though, is the need for a playoff system.