Wondering what you guys think about Rahm’s take on where the economy is at:
“White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel told The New York Times Obama intends to use the news conference as a “six-month report card,” to talk about “how we rescued the economy from the worst recession” and the legislative agenda moving forward, including health care and energy legislation.” http://www.breitbart.com/article.php?id=upiUPI-20090722-062929-3861&show_article=1
I think they took over an economy in peril and have only made it worse so far. Obama has had more coverage than any president in history, and has used the bully pulpit more frequently than any in memory; the message that he has gotten out so successfully is that we are in "the worst economy in 40 years", then changed to "worst economy since the depression". The combination of this message being so frequently funneled out of DC, his spending spree, and the strongly anti-business and anti-job creator(private sector, at least) legislation he is pushing so hard, has put the economy in a far more tenuous place than it would be with virtually anyone else in charge...even Hillary, I'd venture to say. Thoughts?
The infamous quote by Rahm about never waste a crisis is so damn telling. Initially they beat everybody down with how bad it was in order to push their agenda. The agenda was the most important part. Not the economy. They didn’t care that they were actually making things worse with all their doom and gloom. The agenda was more important. Now that enough time has passed since the election, they have to do an about face. Not only are they trying to convince people that they saved the economy, they want to make damn sure that people don’t start realizing its still in the shitter and start realizing the Obama is not helping, but actually hurting things.
Its all about managing perceptions. If done properly, perceptions can become reality regardless of the truth.
I’ll disagree because perception is a big part of the recovery. Under GW people were convinced that we were headed toward a depression. Now that the worst of the financial shocks appear to be over and GM and Ford are still in business I think the perception is we are better off. Again, it may not be “reality” but it is all about perception.
I’m not worried about the “Economy of today”, we’ve spent, are spending trillions of dollars to prop it up. I’m worried about the economy of 5,10 20 years from now when all the bills come due.
Wondering what you guys think about Rahm’s take on where the economy is at:
“White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel told The New York Times Obama intends to use the news conference as a “six-month report card,” to talk about “how we rescued the economy from the worst recession” and the legislative agenda moving forward, including health care and energy legislation.” http://www.breitbart.com/...1&show_article=1
I think they took over an economy in peril and have only made it worse so far. Obama has had more coverage than any president in history, and has used the bully pulpit more frequently than any in memory; the message that he has gotten out so successfully is that we are in “the worst economy in 40 years”, then changed to “worst economy since the depression”. The combination of this message being so frequently funneled out of DC, his spending spree, and the strongly anti-business and anti-job creator(private sector, at least) legislation he is pushing so hard, has put the economy in a far more tenuous place than it would be with virtually anyone else in charge…even Hillary, I’d venture to say. Thoughts?
To be fair, Dave, wasn’t Obama highly criticized for saying the economy was bad before the election (when it was definitely bad). All the right wingers jumped on his back about how a leader needs to instill confidence in the public to rescue the economy and that the gloom and doom was bad leadership.
So now he shouldn’t say that it has been rescued?
I’m only stating that from a politics standpoint. Clearly he said it was bad then and good now for personal political gain. In addition, the right wingers are saying that he shouldn’t say that then and shouldn’t say this now because…well…because he’s a Democrat and they beat him down for everything he says.
As for your actual question, I personally don’t know if its gotten better or worse.
“To be fair” and politics never seem to end up in the same sentence.
If you’re looking at a politician to tell you “How the economy is doing” you’re probably not getting a very good assessment
As far as Obama, hell or any major politician, no matter what they do or say their supporters will say he’s doing great and their detractors will say he sucks. Simple fact of politics today.
OTOH Obama used the fear tactic of “Worst economy…” blah blah to win. 6 months later things haven’t changed much and by many measures has gotten worse. I’m guessing he’s not using the “Worst economy in…” line anymore. All politics, nothing more nothing less, certainly not an accurate accounting of the economy.
As for your actual question, I personally don’t know if its gotten better or worse.
Definately worse in manufacturing, but of course we typically lag the actual economy by a few to several months. “Big orders”, consumer spending etc tanks and THEN we stop making stuff. We don’t stop making stuff when people are buying it.
As far as “Overall”, I’ve personally never seen it this bad, nothing even close. My partner who is significantly older than I am and has been working or in a similar business since the mid 60’s says the same. The closest was the early 80’s and he beleives this is worse than that by a fair margin.
Pretty much true, and you could say GWB did the opposite of Obama by mostly just saying "go out and buy stuff". Like Mjuric, I don't see much on the Obama agenda that will be good for the economy going forward, and that has mucho effect on investors. I was just wondering if most liberals here are, like jkal, good with Rahm's outlook.
I hope he does say that. In 6 months when there is 12% unemployment and people are remembering the good times of 6% unemployment, Obama will have his Mission Accomplished moment.
Welcome back to the majority in congress to the Republicans. Then we can get back to gridlock in DC.
and has used the bully pulpit more frequently than any in memory;
Then you have a very short memory…
Seriously? He’s out making public speeches and statements so often that networks complain about him taking too much prime-time, and even a fawning press has started to ignore him. You can look for some prime time Obama tonight, btw.
I can’t think of any more bullying than the prior administration. The fact they did it privately instead of in front of the media is just a different tactic with the same result.
I have no interest in watching Obama. He is full of rhetoric and I am tired of Presidents who make promises (Obama) or make threats (Bush and is axis of evil and war on terror) to further their own agendas.
Both Bush and Obama are doing exactly the same thing in different ways.
Both Bush and Obama are doing exactly the same thing in different ways.
Maybe, but that misses a major point of my post, that being that Obama is using his popularity and his position heavily, and that he probably has more direct influence on more people.
I suppose it depends on where you thought the economy was heading. There were plenty of talking heads talking about DOW 5,000, soup kitchens and bread lines, bank runs and massive failures, etc, etc.
The DOW has stabilized, the banks didn’t fail, GM is still making cars…
GWB gave us multiple AIG bailouts, Citi bailout, Fannie/Fredd bailout, TARP…Obama followed on with the stimulus and GM/Chrysler bailouts, etc…I don’t see much difference between them at this point.
I have a hard time getting a read on what is happening out there. Obama and his regime say everything is rosey since we did the bailout plan. Prior to that is was soupline time. Left wing media falls in line with the O regime. Right wings talks show accentuate that bad to make O look bad. Everyone has an agenda.
GWB gave us multiple AIG bailouts, Citi bailout, Fannie/Fredd bailout, TARP…Obama followed on with the stimulus and GM/Chrysler bailouts, etc…I don’t see much difference between them at this point.
GM will be a baby suckling at the govt tit for a loooong time. “GWB gave us multiple AIG bailouts, Citi bailout, Fannie/Fredd bailout, TARP”, it’s redundant to list those then list “TARP”, and remember, GWB made a point of not directing half the TARP funds so that Obama had that flexibility coming in. There’s no way of knowing if they are alike, as we’d have to be sure that GWB would add on trillions more in spending, than push hard for programs that would cost at least hundreds of billions more. No, I think Obama is probably the only pol in the country who, at this point, would have the “audacity” to act in such a manner.
Dave, Fannie/Freddie bailout, first rounds of AIG bailouts, parts of the CITI bailout all happened before TARP or were above and beyond TARP, so these were separate programs. There were also $168 billion in rebate checks sent out and various other smaller bailouts earlier in 2008.
Anyway, as far as I can see, what Obama has done is essentially an extension of what GWB was doing with various bailouts and stimulus programs. More of the same, IMHO.
Too bad you focus solely on unemployment. A few months ago the Dow was under 7,000 and now it is approaching 9,000, there was a lot of money to be made but most people were so convinced of armageddon, they missed out. Remember the posts here about the long lines of hungry etc.
It is the same pattern repeating itself. People focus too much on what the media is saying and ignore the really good deals out there. You can convince yourself of anything if you only read newspapers but when I reviewed the financials of a lot of companies, and noted they were fundamentally strong and their share prices were dropping due mainly to panic in the market, I bought heavily and for 2009, my average return so far is almost 40%.
I am planning an extended bike trip to the Philippines starting next summer and will be gone about 3 years and this market has made things so much better, I have made far more than I thought and will be investing it and leaving it for the duration of my trip.
It has nothing to do with Obama or Bush but the fear that is being spread is fueling some great buys so please keep it up.
“I can’t think of any more bullying than the prior administration. The fact they did it privately instead of in front of the media is just a different tactic with the same result.”
The term “bully pulpit” has nothing to do with “bullying” as you’re using the term. Here’s what wikipedia says:
A bully pulpit is a public office or other position of authority of sufficiently high rank that provides the holder with an opportunity to speak out and be listened to on any matter. The bully pulpit can bring issues to the forefront that were not initially in debate, due to the office’s stature and publicity.
** This term was coined by President Theodore Roosevelt, who referred to the White House as a “bully pulpit,” by which he meant a terrific platform from which to advocate an agenda. Roosevelt famously used the word bully as an adjective meaning “superb” or “wonderful” (a more common expression in his time than it is today); the term has no relationship to the noun bully, i.e. a harasser or someone who intimidates.
** Unfortunately, due to the archaic nature of the adjective “bully” and the religious symbolism of the word pulpit (the elevated platform used by a preacher), this phrase is often misunderstood as a pejorative. This misinterpretation implies intimidation and, possibly, an abuse of authority. An example of this would be the sentence: “He uses his job as a bully pulpit, regaling his subordinates with his political opinions as part of their morning meetings.”