The bad knee(s) crew....how do you cope?

Mine was from long time use then a skiing injury(MCL/ACL/Medial meniscus).

I have pretty good doggone days now and very little pain, but I still have some issues with the bone contusion on my tibial plateu/medial. That is slowly going away.

For those of you with ‘bad wheels’, are you running on soft surfaces exclusively? At this point in my life I just want to compete and the days of running fast are over and my goal is to just make sure I can get in some miles to finish respectably…

Any remedies or suggestions from my hobbled homies(or chikkies) on keeping the knees happy? 400mg of Advil Liqui Gels are ok, but I’m always up for learning new things to preserve this body!

Thanks

I lost a bunch of articular cartilage a few years ago after a long and happy running career so I know a bit about it. I hate to say it because I’ll get yelled at here but I train almost exclusively on an elliptical for running. That being said, I’ll do two to three hours at 85% HR on the thing with lots of resistance and a quick cadence but it’s worked for me. I did a couple of halves and a full IM with just 9 short outdoor 45-60 minute and the rest on the elliptical. I think it can be a good tool for those of us with irrepairable knee injuries if you use it the right way and I’m not talking about the lolly gagging that you see at most gyms. I’m not quick anymore (1:40 for a half, and 3:50 for a full) but it gets me to the finish line and I noticed suprisingly few actual problems and pains from the running. Good luck to ya.

An elliptical? Now that is something I hadn’t thought of at all. My ortho suggested starting out on a treadmill due to the soft nature and then gravitating to dirt a little after, but to stay off the pavement except for a scant few runs…to save it for races.

I’m up for anything that works…thanks!

I use the elliptical alot as well. I have been just working on doing shorter runs more often - b/c of the knee and b/c I am really needing to work on form and getting a better base for my (piss poor) run.
I have also gone over to the other dark side and begun adding more resistance / weight training to take some of the pounding off my joints. I know others complain about bulking up but I run much better when I feel strong but I have never, ever been a long, lanky runner type anyhow.
Also, when I was having some problems I did some aquajogging - yes, it did require I use a lane in the pool but it kicked my butt! It was not as boring as I thought it would be either.
As for soft surfaces, I hate the treadmill, I am convinced the only injuries I have have come from running on the treadmill. I will use a soft track occasionally, but running in a certain direction will aggravate my knee. As for trails, not so much, but that is mainly b/c of availability.

I make sure to pay attention to the incline to get something that’s a bit closer to running and I din’t use one with the arm movement as I think they’re a little silly. I just put a portable DVD player on the console, headphones on, and go like hell. Works for bricks too as I train late a night on a trainer and then just hop on the elliptical in my gear and go for an hour or two. I save my knees for racing as I have to worry about wearing out the remaining cartilage so I have limited miles left and I don’t want to use them up.

I have limited miles left and I don’t want to use them up.

That is me to a T. I know my running days are limited and want to save them and allocate mileage wisely. I’m also a bit torn on whether or not to just stay with cycling which gives me no problems…if I can find enough TT’s and road races down here in FL I might just bypass multi sport altogether.

In 05, I had an ACL replacement on my R knee. had some of my meniscus removed as well.

in general, things have been better than I hoped. (just knocked on wood desk). usually, when i take care of my knees, they take care of me. after any long or hard run, i ice my knees. i do much of my running on trails, but that has its own risks.
-charles

I drift in and out of multisport. I’ve done a bunch of road racing, some MTB racing, and even some track racing as well as rekindled my love for cross country skiing which probably isn’t an option for you. I like the bike racing but I get pulled back to multisport every now and then and I think I’ll do it every three or four years with other pursuits in the interim.

Advil, ice, and listen to your body. Acl etc in 2000. I know my days are numbered somewhat as well. Have issues on and off. Tried supplements, but did not feel any significant difference.

Don’t take any breaks. When I am running consistently I am fine. It is when I take time off and try to get back into it does my begin to start causing problems.

Don’t take any breaks. When I am running consistently I am fine. It is when I take time off and try to get back into it does my begin to start causing problems.

Worst pain I can feel is staying seated for long periods. Recently had to go to LA and it was unbearable…any drives over 2 hours and I’m dying. I actually stop every hour to walk and stretch now when there isn’t a time crunch…whouda thunk? I used to be the king of driving until I needed to refill!

x2! It’s tough to get restarted and it’s usually a quick downward spiral once I’ve stopped training for any length of time.

In 1996 I tore my ACL and shredded my medial meniscus in a ski accident. I recovered well from the ACL repair (using the patellar tendon) and partial menisectomy, but two years ago I had an MRI that showed mild to moderate degenerative joint disease. I still run, but much shorter distances, less speedwork, soft surfaces or treadmill only. I try and keep my weight at the lower end of normal for my height, take glucosamine/chondroitin, and see a chiropractor once a month to have my left leg and back adjusted. So far, so good. I’d love to run more, but I need to listen to my body on this one.

After my most recnt scope (menisectomy/debridment and microfracture), I had several localized full thickness AC defects in my lateral compartment.I have been having regular MRIs to keep an eye on the progress. The goal was at some point to perhaps have a cartilige and meniscal transplant.

My most recent MRI (thi summer) results showed that the arthritic wear was no longer localized and now encompasses the entire lateral compartment. What’s left of my meniscus (about 20-30%) is torn. I have bone spurring, bone marrow edema, and fissures in both femur and tibia. There is also arthritic changes in the patellar side/front, and the medial side. There is also a medial meniscal tear. Luckily, at this point my ligaments and tendons remain pristine. Unfortunately, the degenration has gotten to the point that I am no longer a candidate for either autologus transplants or donor transplants of cartilige or meniscus.

I am going in to have the last bit of mensicus removed, remove or repair the medial tear, and to even out some of the bone spurring and get rid of any loose crap fall after the season.

My orthopod hopes it buys me a couple more years with lesser pain. Next surgical step would be a distal femoral osteotomy to unload… my alignment is obviously creeping out of “normal” limits, but not drastic enough right now to justify major surgery. That’s maybe 5, 10 years down the road (I hope).

Eventually, it will be a knee replacement, but I hope to keep it a PKR…and I hope to keep it at LEAST 15+ years down the road.

As for what I do right now:

I run only 3 dpw, and keep mileage fairly low (max week is under 25). Keep to soft surfaces as much as possible…trails, grass, then blactop, last concrete. I always take advil before I run (yes, I know the risks). In season, I will sometimes supplement the actual run training with pool running and the eliptical trainer. I take glucosamine and chondroitin. I have a custom unloader brace for times when I’ll be doing a lot of standing, walking, heavy lifting, or when it is verfy agitated. I avoid sitting for long periods of time. And, unlike some people, I take time off–usually at least 2-3 months away from running. Sometimes I ET or pool run, but it’s usually no running.

It hurts whether I run or not…and I will need a replacement eventually whether I run or not, so I still run. Is that the smartest plan? Maybe not…even with advil, it certainly isn’t pain free running bone on bone. But then again, I had my first surgery when I was 12, so the vast majority of my life it has hurt anyway.

Nike Vomero running shoes seem to be head and shoulders above any shoe I’ve tried as far as dissapating shock. Also on all my training runs I try to make my 8 minute mile pace as walklike as possible. I don’t even think about fast running in training. I just try and make every run like a quick walk.

I’m about the same as mmrocker. I had microfracture done last year with the same problems as above. I’m lucky if I can run 10min/mi 2 times a week. I’ve held out from Advil until I started getting into some more mileage for my first IM but have tried to deal with the pain otherwise. Glad to hear some are having success with the eliptical and pool workouts. I’m going to take several months off from running and swim and bike. I’m sure my knee will need to be replaced in about 5 years or so. At 34, this sucks. Good luck to you.

Whenever your primary consideration becomes protecting a body part from the knee upward, you need to make the transition to forefoot striking. This removes most of the stress of impact from the upper leg. You will need to carefully adapt the foot,achilles, calf to this style of running but it works. Stay away from downhill running. Except for races where you’ve deemed it worth the impact, just turn around and slowly jog backwards down hills.

Also, keep the stride an inch or two shorter than normal.

Doing this, most marginal cases should be able to continue running.

The best advice I can give is to 1) run only in minimal flats that have no arch support and 2) integrate point #1 slowly over several months. In 6 mos you can be running 100% in flats and much less injury prone. The short explanation is that heels and cushioning promote many common running injuries. You don’t need to run totally barefoot to realize some key benefits from doing so.

People argue that this approach works only for a small minority. But that’s mostly because people don’t want to invest in the transition time and they fail. Your body needs time to adapt to these changes after 20-30 yrs in overbuilt shoes that weaken your feet. Success won’t come overnight and there will be soreness as you wake up formerly stagnant muscles, tendons, and nerve endings. But it’s a much better long-term approach than coughing up $300 for a sports doc every year and getting a list of muscle imbalance fixes and stretching exercises that you’ll stop doing after 2 months.

I’ve got knee problems and have had them since I was 15 (45 now). I first found orthotics helped a lot and proper shoes. Now I’ve changed my running from heel striker to mid-food to front foot strike. I’ve found that I can run comfortably farther by running much of the run on my toes and when something begins to hurt I switch to one of the other strikes. So far it works for me though it took a fair amount of time to build up fore foot striking (calfs became tired fast). I also ice a fair amount. I DO NOT DO ANY DRUGS (yes I am yelling). I just don’t think they are worth the long term unknown side effects. I think the elliptical might be a great way to train too though I don’t use that.

The only gotcha with switching between front/mid/heel is I have to use 2140 Asics which are kind of heavy. If it’s a short run I ran do it all calfs and use light trainers. Yesterday was 12 miles and I did the first 8ish on fore foot then went to mid the rest of the way.

Looks like lots of good ideas in the thread.

John

I would be remised if I didn’t mention my own little foray into orthotics and I know many of you will laugh at the ‘generic’ brand of GoodFeet, the one endorsed by Emmit Smith…but my ortho pod said they are every bit as good as the custom made orthotics for people with pronation issues which is what caused my disc degeneration initially…running ‘sideways’ for so many years. They have helped me immensely. Over the course of 2 weeks my sacrum suddenly stopped having spasms that I had lived with for 30+ years and my knees took a turn for the better. Just wanted to share that with those of you who may dismiss them as a waste…they have one sold customer here.

Thanks for all the advice and tips.