Terrorism - are we really winning?

You will get no argument from me about home. I think we have taken our eye off the ball there in many ways and my home senator Tom Tancredo seems to be the only one talking any sense about borders. Both of them have their head buried when it comes to the borders. I haven’t heard any “expert” say we have done all we could here or even close. You heard about the report that Chechen terrorist recently made it across in AZ from Mexico? That will make sleep tight at night huh?

I do think, however, that we still need to act outside our borders to disrupt them. There is plenty of room for debate on where and how we should do it but I don’t think we can play just defense either. There needs to be offense too and not just soldiers but intel, covert ops, banking and finance “warfare”, and cooperation with other countries and their infastructure of the same things. Calling this just military or just law enforcement is a huge mistake.

The thing that is so strange about this is that most people all want the same thing (safety), many people disagree on how to get there, but the one thing that many people agree on is that they don’t believe either presidential candidate can really do it with their current plans.

“If we really want to be safe shouldn’t we be trying to decrease the level of hatred towards us?”

This assumes that the US is the reason for UBL and related friends. It further assumes that the US could modify its behavior sufficiently to remove the incentive for further acts.

Both assumptions are incorrect in my estimation. Take UBL at face value, rather than as an out of power elite seeking power, and you will find that there is nothing short of becoming an islamic theocracy that will suffice.

The US is the focus of recent attacks because it is perceived as the epitome of western civilization which is at odds with islamic fundamentalism.

The polling I have seen indicates that there is not an increase in hatred against Americans, but the Administration. The problem with the Administration is related to the belief that the US is acting alone. My thought on that point is: so what? The US has acted in similar fashion in the past and history has approved in time. I see no reason why the same would not happen here. I could be wrong, but only time will tell.

According to this article, even much of the military is doubting whether or not what we are doing over there is making us any safer.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6284431/site/newsweek/

Brian:

"The only way to truly fight terrorism is to spread freedom and democracy around the world. "

When is Bush going to come out and admit that we are going to place a democratic government in place of every hostile government in the middle east in order to “stop” terrorism?

Also the thing about 30 countries joining us in the war with Iraq. Did anyone else catch when Kerry mentioned that if you counted the state of Missouri as a country it would be the second largest contributor to the war? I challenge you to post the list of the 30 countries and say with a straight face we had strong international support to FIGHT the war.

– When is Bush going to come out and admit that we are going to place a democratic government in place of every hostile government in the middle east in order to “stop” terrorism?

According to their current reasoning this would have to happen if they are going to battle terror in this way. The problem is freedom is going to do nothing to stop Islamic fundamentalists who despise our presence in that part of the world. It will only bring more terror upon us.

“Did anyone else catch when Kerry mentioned that if you counted the state of Missouri as a country it would be the second largest contributor to the war? I challenge you to post the list of the 30 countries and say with a straight face we had strong international support to FIGHT the war.”

OK.

 ‘91 coalition: Afghanistan, Argentina, Australia, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Canada, Czechoslovakia,
Denmark, Egypt, France, Germany, Greece, Hungary, Honduras, Italy, Kuwait, Morocco, The Netherlands, Niger, Norway, Oman, Pakistan, Poland, Portugal, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Senegal, South Korea, Spain, Syria, Turkey, the United Arab Emirates, the United Kingdom and the United States.

As of 3/'04 Coalition: United Kingdom, Spain, Portugal, Denmark, Netherlands, Iceland, Italy, Estonia, Latvia , Lithuania, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary, Albania, Macedonia, Romania, Bulgaria, Turkey, Croatia, Slovenia, Ukraine, Japan, South Korea, Singapore, Philippines, Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan, Georgia, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Solomon Islands, Mongolia, Palau, Tonga, United States of America, El Salvador, Colombia, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Honduras, Australia, Kuwait, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Uganda, Rwanda, Angola.

Want to know who is missing? France, Germany, Belgium, Russia, Belarus, Greece. Know what the percentage of US troops was in '91? 74%

Claiming that the US is “going it alone” in this round because we don’t have our good friends France, Germany and Russia on board is a bit disingenuous. The truth is that the US is doing the heavy lifting whenever we do what needs doing.

“As soon as you stop jumping to conclusions and making asinine statements like this I’m sure he’ll consider the issue.”

asinine ? must have hit it’s mark since you won’t respond to it with a real answer.

We already went into Iraq and removed their government “as part of the war on terror” and you don’t think Bush is ready to do that again in another country?

Explain to me why I’m supposed to trust that that won’t happen?

I’m waiting for that list of powerful nations that backed us in this war by the way.

“We were the ones attacked after all. Why wasn’t it someone else?”

You’re not serious. Are you unaware of all the attacks on other nations? Spain, France, England, Russia… Terrorists have kidnapped and murdered citizens of Japan, England, Italy, S. Korea and others.

Terrorism didn’t start on 9/11/01. It’s been around for as long as Islam has existed.

Terrorism does not stem from Islam. Some terrorists are islamic, but that’s all.

The Prophet Muhammad was born appx 570 AD

Terrorism by Zealots was first recorded in the 1st centruy AD http://encarta.msn.com/encyclopedia_761564344_3/Terrorism.html

Therefore terrorism has been around for longer than Islam.

The only way to truly fight terrorism is to spread freedom and democracy around the world.

This is the Bush/Blair mantra but it doesn’t stand up. Terrorism happens in free democracies anyway.

“Terrorism does not stem from Islam. Some terrorists are islamic, but that’s all.”

I stand corrected. Other terrorist groups would include the ancient Romans and the Catholics. Aside from that, who’s beheading people and using suicide bombers in shopping malls these days?

100 out of the last 100 terrorist attacks were perpetrated in the name of Islam. The fact that the Quran doesn’t support it doesn’t do much to defend the religion. Anyone who thinks terrorist acts of violence are not a part of Islam needs to study Mohammad more closely. He was a peaceful muslim compared to the Ishmaelis, who were pussies when compared to the wahabis. For there to be peace for those who respect their fellow man, there should be a bounty on all wahabists.

Those who wish to follow Islam in peace need to do some serious work to weed out and eliminate those who would use it as a tool for terror. However, a great many muslims celebrate acts of terror against America, and nearly all celebrate acts of terror agains Israel. On 9/11/01, there were muslims dancing in the streets in Sunnyvale CA, a community in the Silicon Valley that has a very high density of muslims. These people were jubilantly celebrating an attack against innocent civilians.

If Islam is a religion of peace, then I’m Daffy Duck.

Ah I see. Some Muslims are terrorists, so the rest of the Muslims better keep them in line or else Cousin Elwood won’t be happy with any of 'em. Sorry, that’s not how terrorism works.

Can’t find any verification of Muslims dancing in the streets of Sunnyvale on 9/11. I’m not denying it happened, but I would have expected it be be in the news somewhere.

http://sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2004/09/10/MNGTQ8MS7A1.DTL

OK, I can see you’re either really stupid or yanking my chain. Which is it?

“so the rest of the Muslims better keep them in line or else Cousin Elwood won’t be happy with any of 'em. Sorry, that’s not how terrorism works.”

    • Don’t be a fool. It’s not about making me happy, it’s about personal responsibilty. Did that type of jab work for you back in kindergarten? It won’t get you anything but disdain among adults.

For practical purposes, all terrorists are muslims. Does that mean all muslims are terrorists? No, it doesn’t. I’m sorry for assuming you were intelligent enough to connect those dots. OTOH, the fact that muslims commit acts of terror in the name of their so-called religion is problematic. I have muslim friends, and they agree with me that there is very little and unquestionably insufficient rebuke and denouncement by muslims of terrorist acts commited in the name of Allah. If you and I were members of the same church, and I knew you were involved in terrorist acts in the name of our shared faith, I would personally transport you to the authorities. Muslims do not do this. They (many mosques) also raise funds for terrorist groups. That’s not bigotry on my part, that’s a fact. Don’t paint me as a bigot just because you don’t like the truth. That’s a cowardly dodge.

I believe that all muslims should feel shame for evil done in the name of their religion. If they don’t stand up to denounce these acts, that’s tacit approval and the guilt by association is justified. Since virtually none of them do, then those of us who believe in personal responsibility are justified in shunning them. The vast majority do not speak out against terrorism, and a large number actually revel in the inhuman acts of terrorists. If you’re part of a group, you have a certain responsibility. Catholics should demand the heads of priests who molest children. Methodists should deal harshly with those who force parishioners to attend bingo (joke) and Masons should deal harshly with those who disclose the secret handshake.

The Sunnyvale celebration was shown briefly that day on one channel here in the Bay Area, and then disappeared. I don’t know why anyone would be surprised. Here in the Bay Area the news media only report things that are anti-American or at least anti-conservative.

“In the three years since Sept. 11, the Northern California office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations has logged more than 50 cases of Muslims who say they’ve been threatened or harassed or discriminated against. In that same period, the Equal Employment Opportunity Commission’s offices in San Francisco, San Jose and Oakland have received 95 work-discrimination complaints…”

    • Considering what happened, considering the number of muslims who reside in the Bay Area (over 500,000) and considering the liberal victim mentality of the Bay Area, I’d say that’s a shockingly low number. I’m sure there have been those whose reactions to 9/11 were to lash out at anyone muslim, and I’d have expected more cases. Does that mean I endorse mistreating muslims? No, I don’t. I wouldn’t think it necessary to point that out, but you have apparently decided that attacking me is easier than dealing with the facts, so I’ll state what should be obvious.

Muslims object to “profiling.” Well, ALL good law enforcement officers know that profiling is part of their job. The BS PC laws make us less safe. If there’s a bomb threat at the airport, it would probably be an inefficient use of law enforcement’s valuable time to search the group of Chinese Tourists, the elderly Jewish couple or the Shriners. If there’s a group of muslims nearby, it would be dereliction not to make note of them and possibly search them.

“For practical purposes, all terrorists are muslims.”

You should replace the word “practical” and replace it with “Cousin Elwood’s.” There a a lot of non-muslim terrosit groups in the world, including many here at home. Basques, IRA, Neo-Nazi’s, even Jewish groups.

“Muslims object to “profiling.” Well, ALL good law enforcement officers know that profiling is part of their job.”

Most Muslims object to profiling based solely on ethinicity. Most law enforcement officers do not profile solely based on ethinicity or race, they profile based on a range of things, most important of which are activity, and what they call things that “just don’t feel right” like a white person alone in harlem or a Muslim sitting outside a Jewish Temple. Protection of the civil liberties of Americans is as large a part of law enforcement’s job as catching the bad guys.

I’d be willing to bet there are a lot of groups in South America that would be categorized as “terrorists,” who also are not muslim.

"You should replace the word “practical” and replace it with ‘Cousin Elwood’s.’

    • Oh great sage, please list for me all the terrorist attacks here in America and in Europe that were NOT committed by muslims in the past three years.

“Most Muslims object to profiling based solely on ethinicity. Most law enforcement officers do not profile solely based on ethinicity or race, they profile based on a range of things, most important of which are activity, and what they call things that “just don’t feel right” like a white person alone in harlem or a Muslim sitting outside a Jewish Temple.”

    • I didn’t think I needed to define “profiling” for this group. Of course it involves more than just ethnicity. I did not say nor imply that being muslim was sufficient to create suspicion. My point was that if there’s a bomb, the odds are 1,000,000:1 that it’s muslims.

“Protection of the civil liberties of Americans is as large a part of law enforcement’s job as catching the bad guys.”

    • The typical reaction to the suggestion that muslims bear watching is that we’re going to somehow breach their civil rights. You can keep an eye on someone without doing that. Muslims could help themselves tremendously by outing those in their midst who promote violence against Americans, or who raise funds for those who do.

I wasn’t yanking your chain so I guess that makes me stupid. I was responding to your statement “Those who wish to follow Islam in peace need to do some serious work to weed out and eliminate those who would use it as a tool for terror.”

No they don’t. Following a religion does not necessitate extra community work for the people invloved - they have an unconditional right to follow whatever religion they wish. I agree that when people break the law that those who know about it should act, but I don’t think that the reticence you speak of is confined to Islam. I’m sorry if you feel that I have attacked you - I just attacked one sentence you said by paraphrasing it. Thanks for clarifying your position.

A series of ETA bombings during the summer of 2002 in resorts on the Costa Blanca and the Costa del Sol and other cities in Spain

http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/northern_ireland/3002232.stm
Further Real IRA attacks
4 Mar 2001: Car bomb outside BBC TV Centre, White City, London. Tube worker injured.
15 Apr 2001: Bomb explodes near sorting office in Hendon, north London. No-one hurt.
6 May 2001: A second blast at Hendon sorting office. One man injured.
2 Aug 2001: Car bomb detonates in Ealing Broadway, west London. Several people injured.
3 Nov 2001: Bomb in Birmingham city centre fails to detonate properly. Minor injuries.

In response to rb5980 “Anybody that thinks we can get rid of terrorism needs a trip to Israel and a big ole history book.”

Israel certainly learned an important lesson during the 2nd intifada when it decided to lift the ban on assassinating leaders of terrorist organizations. If you are a leader in Hamas sending someone else to go blow themselves up is no big deal if there are no repercussions personally. However, once Sharon officially changed policy and started going after the upper echelons of these organizations there was a marked change in the situation (i.e. fewer and fewer suicide bombers). Of course, the fence is playing a big factor as well.

However, it is not a matter of getting rid of terrorism. It’s more a matter of containing and limiting its reach. Holding the individuals responsible for their despicable actions is one way to do so.

United Kingdom, Spain, Portugal, Denmark, Netherlands, Iceland, Italy, Estonia, Latvia , Lithuania, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, Hungary, Albania, Macedonia, Romania, Bulgaria, Turkey, Croatia, Slovenia, Ukraine, Japan, South Korea, Singapore, Philippines, Afghanistan, Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan, Georgia, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Solomon Islands, Mongolia, Palau, Tonga, United States of America, El Salvador, Colombia, Nicaragua, Costa Rica, Dominican Republic, Honduras, Australia, Kuwait, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Uganda, Rwanda, Angola

I don’t believe Afghanistan should be on your list. Also, better take Thailand, Spain, Honduras, DR, Nicaragua, Philippines, Singapore and New Zealand off your list since they are gone. Poland will be drawing down soon. Norway has 10 people committed - wow! I’d bet the US is spending more time babysitting Iceland, Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania, Slovakia, Hungary, Albania, Macedonia, Romania, Bulgaria, Turkey, Croatia, Slovenia, Ukraine, Japan, South Korea, Azerbaijan, Uzbekistan, Georgia, Marshall Islands, Micronesia, Solomon Islands, Mongolia, Palau, Tonga, El Salvador, Colombia, Costa Rica, Kuwait, Eritrea, Ethiopia, Uganda, Rwanda, and Angola than it is worth.

globalsecurity.org is an informative source