Strange decision at the finish of today's TdF finish (spoiler)

It seems that the judges have taken a dozen or so points from Cavendish for the sprint finish with Thor. My reading of it is the same as Emich and Roll’s in so much as the only reason Cav changed his line was that the barriers stuck out at the point in the bend. It’s not as though he’s responsible for their placement.

Well he is out of the green jersey now as long as Thor can finish the mt. stages. He better win on the Champs Elysee (sp) or that will be a disappointing end to his Tour.

It seems that the judges have taken a dozen or so points from Cavendish for the sprint finish with Thor. My reading of it is the same as Emich and Roll’s in so much as the only reason Cav changed his line was that the barriers stuck out at the point in the bend. It’s not as though he’s responsible for their placement.

It looked to me like he swerved to the right just as Thor was making a move in the same direction. Perhaps the barriers jutted out a bit as well, but Cav definitely swerved. A questionable, but understandable decision from the judges.

Cav’s going to have to go for those intermediate sprints now. There’s no other way he can top Thor, barring catastrophe.

FWIW I also disagree with the ruling.

If the appeal is upheld he is out of the competition now unless Hushovd failes to finish. He is a far better climber than Cav. The points difference currently stands at 18 not the 4 or 5 it was at the end of the stage.

In his interview Thor was asked what he said to Cav as they crossed the line and his only comment was a little ambiguous in that he couldn’t see why he sprinted but that every point counted. Certainly no comment about being blocked or Cav deviating from his line on the bend.

Now we must wait.

Yeah, it’s not the way he would have liked to finsh after being in such a good position. But, looking at the positives, he has won 4 stages in this year’s Tour and still his another 8 stages to go. If he can haul his carcass over the Alpes in the time limits he has a good shot at finishing in Paris and maybe a win on the finsh day.

Pretty good work for his second year there.

Fingers crossed.

It looked to me like he swerved to the right just as Thor was making a move in the same direction. Perhaps the barriers jutted out a bit as well, but Cav definitely swerved. A questionable, but understandable decision from the judges.

Cav’s going to have to go for those intermediate sprints now. There’s no other way he can top Thor, barring catastrophe.

Fair enough, like everything it’s open to interpretation. I think it would be a shame to take out what has arguably been the most interesting part of this year’s tour to date.

We will have to agree to disgree.

I think it would be a shame to take out what has arguably been the most interesting part of this year’s tour to date.

I agree totally. However, it would be an amazing comeback by Cav if he can pick up some intermediate sprints and bring Thor back to within striking distance on the Champs! That would be quite the showdown!

Let’s just hope that Cav can take enough intermediate points to make the race on the Champs worthwhile. If not, all Thor has to do is sit on Cav’s wheel at the Champs to get the green. I’d rather see the Green go to the guy who wins on the Champs. For that to happen, the spread needs to be less then 5 points if they finish 1-2 or 2-3.

As for today’s penalty, Cav clearly swerved from his line.

Dev

Let’s just hope that Cav can take enough intermediate points to make the race on the Champs worthwhile. If not, all Thor has to do is sit on Cav’s wheel at the Champs to get the green. I’d rather see the Green go to the guy who wins on the Champs. For that to happen, the spread needs to be less then 5 points if they finish 1-2 or 2-3.

As for today’s penalty, Cav clearly swerved from his line.

Dev
Thor may give Cav 1 int. sprint points, but Cav isnt catching Thor unless catastrohe happens with Thor. He will eventually just sit on his wheel and basically limit his loses. The final Green Jersey point difference may be smaller, but at this point, its all but over with this decision and poor sprint by Cav.

The scoring system is just stupid when the guy who has 4 stage wins is behind a guy with 1.

SHould be a bigger spread in points between 1st and 2nd in a stage.

Until earlier this week I hadn’t realised that the points went all the way down to 20th place. I think making it the top 5 of 10 max would make things more interesting.

Until earlier this week I hadn’t realised that the points went all the way down to 20th place. I think making it the top 5 of 10 max would make things more interesting.
I think it even goes back to the top 25, as 25th gets 1 point.

Oh yeah, sorry, you are right, it goes down to 25th. Which is even crazier, IMHO.

As for today’s penalty, Cav clearly swerved from his line.


Agreed, the question is whether he did so to avoid the barrier section, that stuck out from the bend, or to prevent Thor coming through.

As for today’s penalty, Cav clearly swerved from his line.


Agreed, the question is whether he did so to avoid the barrier section, that stuck out from the bend, or to prevent Thor coming through.

What I dont understand, it didnt even seem like a sprint. It more or less just seemed like a confused train at the front. You could see Cav kinda looking around, as if kinda surprised by the finish.

While, I guess I get the penalty, it seemed kinda moot as it seemed like it wasnt even a full on sprint.

My take was that the leadout guys didn’t want to go until forced to by the other sprinter’s teams to lessen George’s chances. But every time he looked for Thor, Cav would look the wrong side so when he was on the front he suddenly had to move. IF he meant to block him then he deserves the penalty. Not a smart move but a lesson for a very inexperienced sprinter. Don’t forget that because of his raw power he hasn’t been in that position many times before and probably was confused and didn’t know what to do.

What I dont understand, it didnt even seem like a sprint. It more or less just seemed like a confused train at the front. You could see Cav kinda looking around, as if kinda surprised by the finish.


They weren’t really sprinting all out because they knew they were taking the yellow from George. It was a columbia clusterf**K.

http://uk.eurosport.yahoo.com/18072009/58/tour-de-france-cavendish-disqualified-stage.html

http://cosmos.bcst.yahoo.com/up/ukyvideo?ch=5127641&cl=14578557&lang=

Not the most endearing interview from Thor. It’s a good job he wasn’t in the sprint against the old school hard men of the sprints like Tom Steels or Chippo or even lil’ Robbie, they would have been leaning all over him.

It might take the sprinters completely out of it. While it seems a shame that the strongest sprinter doesn’t win the green jersey, it’s really a prize for the most consistent sprinter. If you limit it to 5 places, a successful breakaway can take all the points. The green jersey will go to the one that can handle the mountain stages and sprint consistently on the flats even though he never wins a stage sprint.

Also, remember that though in recent years the overall winner has won stages, it is possible to win the TDF never having won a stage. Seems like an undeserved win but may just be good strategy.

I think you are right, Cavendish looked really confused at the end there as he cut off the green jersey.