I have ridden Speedplays for many years and have been pleased. I sent the X1s off my Tri bike off to speedplay for service and they confirmed that I had worn them out. So, this got me to thinking is there any particular reason why I should, or should not, switch to the Zeros. The free float is fine with me. I understand all of the multiple bike issues (I have multiple shoes) so I am just talking about the pedals themselves. My thought is to stay with the X1s unless there is a compelling reason not too. I believe the bearing, etc are the exact same.
I think I would get them rebuilt at speed play if its just bearings. The X-5’s are around $115 same bearing just chromoly spindles. Once you go Zeros on a multi bike ( I have 3 sets ) set up ,as nothing is interchangeable ,it runs into a few $$.
No, mine are not just the bearings…it is the spindle, bearings and pedal body…rebuilt would cost as much as new pedals. These had LOTS of miles on them!
BTW, I don’t believe the X5s have the same bearings as the X1s, and the X1s have a shorter spindle for a lower Q factor which is one reason I like them so much…the Ti Zeros have the same. Also, FYI w/ any Ti Speedplay you get free maintenance labor for life - you only pay for parts/shipping.
BTW, I don’t believe the X5s have the same bearings as the X1s, and the X1s have a shorter spindle for a lower Q factor
I think the old X3s had a teflon sleeve on one side ,but X2 - X1 ,are the same bearing wise. X5s have one less cartridge brg. Still all ball or needle brg.
**** Easy dual-sided entry: no kicking it over, no looking down, no fumbling. Half the weight of most other clipless systems: X/5 Chrome-Moly pedals per pair - 220g X/2 Stainless pedals per pair - 198g X/1 Titanium pedals per pair - 150g X cleats per pair - 85g Non-centering free float minimizes the potential for knee strain. Unbeatable cornering clearance: X/1 - 39 degrees; X/2 - 37 degrees; X/5 - 35 degrees. Large contact area, extremely stable cleat-to-shoe connection. Compatible with virtually all 3-hole and 4-hole shoe mountings. Standard step-in, turn-out entry and release. Built-in grease port for easy bearing lubrication. True locking mechanism - engagement security is independent of spring tension. **NEW X/5 **features needle and cartridge bearings for improved durability and easier servicing. X/5 incorporates an earlier release angle than the race-oriented X/1 and X/2. The X/5 needs only a slight heel twist to exit, so you’ll have no worries about getting out when you need to.
FWIW - I just swapped all my bikes to Zeros after using CX6s last year. (Used X series in 2003) The float is set to its max. Its nice the have the limit screws b/c you know when you will dis-engage. With the X series, you just fell out. If that makes sense…
I find the Zeros cleats more finiky to engage, but figure they need time to wear in and/or there is slight tolerence issues with my shoe bottom where I might need to go back and add a shim.
David, I’ve been using X1’s for many years on both my road and tri bike and really like them. This past year I tried DAs and ended up taking them back. Talk about heavy(large adapter plate), bulky and hard to clip in. I then got a pair of Zeros for my tri bike. I must say I like the X1s better but will stay with the Zeros because I can clip them onto my pedals for T1. I tried that with the X1s and ended up having my shoes pop off the pedals while running in the transition area. I still have the X1s on my roadbike. I also use Time shoes which are great with Speedplays.
“I must say I like the X1s better but will stay with the Zeros because I can clip them onto my pedals for T1.”
Rod, thanks for the comments. I have left my X1s in the pedals for T1 ( and T2)for years…are you saying the Zeros hold tighter? And, what is it about the X1s you like better? Regarding the pedals themselves (ie not the cleats) are they the same as far as materials, bearings, construction?
David, if you don’t have any problem using X1s on your tri bike in T1 and T2 I would stay with them. They’re cheaper then the Zeros and durability wise, I think the X1 cleat will last longer. The Zero has more plastic in it’s construction. I’m thinking of going back to X1s for my tri bike because I usually end up putting my shoes on before getting on the bike anyway. I’m not the most coordinated when trying to mount my bike with the shoes already attached to the pedals. Must be old age setting in.