Slowman's Clearwater editorial

In it, Dan doth declare:

" When this happens, it’s not the fault of the athlete. It’s not the fault of the officials. Like a hurricane formed by a confluence of atmospheric events, packs happen when the conditions encourage them, and there’s not a lot you can do about them."

I call BS. It is the fault of the athlete. Like they say in the software business: “How does a project become a year behind schedule? One day at a time”. If nobody drafted, there would be no packs. I’m still waiting for a cogent argument where anyone is forced to draft. I’m willing to be convinced otherwise.

I totally agree with Dans comments.

Dave

as a matter of fact, someone already posted their RR here and talked about not drafting and the comments made to them about that. So it is possible, the athlete’s just have to decide weather they want to cheat or not.

Now to help them, the RD can layout a proper course with enough room, the officials can enforce the rules and the punishment can be increased.

Probably in the USA too, but in Canada the rule book puts the onus on everyone to avoid drafting, not just the beneficiary: “Competitors must reject attempts by others to draft”

That could get pretty exciting with people swerving all over the road and throwing things to get rid of wheel suckers…

As it stands now, in races like Clearwater (as I understand it, I wasn’t there) it is possible for some individuals to follow the rules and not draft. It is not possible for everyone to do so, there simply isn’t enough room. Basically, the folks in the 100 person pelotons make more room on the course outside of those pelotons. The only way to combat the problem is to drastically reduce field sizes.

I call BS. It is the fault of the athlete.\

You are right, but you ignore human nature, and assume that the racers have more control over their actions than they truly have. It is all well and good to just say don’t draft, but that is like telling a 1000 fat people, just don’t eat so much. You can’t ignore our competitive nature, and given the set of parameters that were given at Clearwater, the majority will draft. I wanted to do this race really bad, and to try and win a world championship, that is my competitive nature. I knew with certainty, that the way they set up the waves, the small # of them, the time inbetween, quality of athlete, the flat course, ect., that to win and be competitive in this race, you would have to draft. I would have drafted at this race, and I imagine that if most are honest with themselves, they also drafted too. Reality check people, look at your split on the bike, and try and recall when you ever got close to that in a legit ride. SO I made my choice not to draft by not going to the race, and have taken it off my schedule for future years. They didn’t crown real world champions, but ITU style champions. I would rather see them just allow drafting, and then I would go and race. That way everyone knows going in what to expect, and we can all have a fair race. ITU style, but fair in that respect…

It was tough.

As an example, I tried going wide many times to get around the pelotons, but got shoved almost into some barriers. At some points, I was pushed outside the yellow lines almost into some of the police guides.

And when one tried to observe the stagger rule, there was guy I’d pass and he’d cut right in front of me, then sway back and forth. It felt like a Cat 5 road race at times, with bike handling abilities very disparate.

The race director could improve conditions by creating wider lanes. Furthermore, people passed left, right and into oncoming traffic.

I’d like somebody to explain how one would observe the seven meter rule with twenty seconds to pass under those conditions. Furthermore, how does one observe it, if somebody blocks your pass? And if you’d gap a group you just pass, there were persons bridging the gap.

Sure one does NOT get right behind, inches behind like one does in a real road race, and one tried to stagger, but how could one observe all the rules in the midst of congestion?

Perhaps I’m too much the novice, but it seemed if one tried to observe one rule, one violated another.

Drafting does “just happen” like traffic. No one wants to sit in traffic but it happens as a result of external factors such as bottleneck, volume of autos (think rush hour), merges, lane shifts etc.

It would be interesting to get the feedback from some traffic engineers on a large triathlon and drafting. Guess you could equate average speed in a tri to speed limit on a freeway and crunch some numbers on volume.

Dre

I totally agree with Ken. It is BS.

The athletes have to take responsibility.

for those who want to read ALL the commentary about this race, and not just the trailer ken provided, you’ll find it here:

http://www.slowtwitch.com/mainheadings/opinion/clearwater.html
.

Drafting happens because people break the rules. You don’t pass if you don’t have room to get through (because someone is blocking and breaking the rules). What people do is attempt to pass when they can’t, and compound the problem, creating packs. Blocked? Bummer. Someone is breaking the rules, and you are paying for it. You can take it or break the rules yourself.

Look up the Prisoner’s Dilemma.

You don’t pass if you don’t have room to get through (because someone is blocking and breaking the rules). What people do is attempt to pass when they can’t, and compound the problem, creating packs. Blocked? Bummer. Someone is breaking the rules, and you are paying for it. You can take it or break the rules yourself. \

SO you are OK with triathlons becoming fun runs??? I for one want them to remain competitive races. It is how they began, and for those of us that enjoy competition, I hope they continue to be. In you scenario, they are nothing more than the Baja to Ensansda ride. 20k people riding however they want, not racing anyone in paticular, but just finishing a prescribed course. No reward for exellence on the course, just everyone getting through a mess of riders .Oh ya, everyone gets a medal too…

As much as you guys like to be black and white here with statements like “athletes can make a choice” and “cheaters will always cheat”. How do you propose to solve the problem of lack of space on a course like Clearwater?

I looked at one AG 25-29 and saw that over 50 swimmers came out of the water in under 30 minutes. So how do you plan to put all those athletes on a flat stretch of road and keep them appart. And this is just one age group. And remember these are among the strongest triathletes in the country so one would assume there are many who ride the same speed.

I think Slowtwich does a good job of pointing out the problems in triathlons but this thread is a perfect example of not always coming up with solutions.

Dan,

I did read your entire article, and your conclusion seems to be that no one is at fault, it was bound to happen because of the site. Well, I have to respectfully disagree. Instead of not assigning blame to anyone, you should be assigning blame to everyone. The RD chose the site, and even though there are limited options at that time of year, and it was nice to have a home town race, they still chose that site despite its limitations.

It is also the athletes’ fault. I understand that there are many people the same speed in the water and that there will likely be many coming out of T1 at the same time. Still, the rules are clear. Stay back or pass. If you want to be in front, then shave time off your swim or T1. The athletes knew what the course/venue/conditions would be like, they should have considered this. Instead I think many went into the race thinking “it’s going to be OK to draft here.” Do you throw out the rule against outside assistance if people start believing that 20 volunteers should be at a water stop instead of the 15 that an RD supplies? If there are 3 people abreast at the dismount line, do you allow people to ride into transition or do you expect them to stop behind those 3 abreast and get off?

The rules are the rules. I don’t see how you start making exceptions. And I think it is dangerous to begin to put the thought out there that no one is to blame, that sh!t just happens. Everyone involved in this race made decisions, and they should be held accountable for those decisions.

Good Clearwater commentary, Dan, and no, I’m not sucking up.

As it says in the USAT Official’s Manual, “The greatest threat to fairness in upper-level triathlon competition is the formation of packs on the bike course. Packs develop for a variety of reasons, including parity in ability, course design and layout, wather conditions, and course crowding. In any case, marshals should take an active role in preventing their formation. The philosophy behind effective marshaling is simple: the referee must take firm action against athletes riding in positions of questionable legality.”

From what others have posted, effective marshalling would have been very difficult on large stretches of the bike course due to narrow coned-off sections, hardscape, lack of shoulders, inability to pass riders, etc. Perhaps with some course and wave start changes, and the experience of this year, it will be a much more fair race next year.

And…as discussed on some older threads, perhaps some better technology (laser measuring, radar, photo zones, or whatever) may help in enforcing draft regs. I look forward to the engineer folks seeing if they can come up with some better enforcement tools to help the sport.

“your conclusion seems to be that no one is at fault, it was bound to happen because of the site.”

my conclusion would be most easily found at my article’s conclusion. and here’s what i conclude:

“I’m constrained to ask: if this was a world championship bike race, would it be on a flat course? If not – and the answer is a certain no – then isn’t it reasonable to expect a world championship triathlon to have a similar element of topographical difficulty? It’s not just about the issue of controlling drafting. It’s a championship, and that typically means some hills to climb.”

now, having reread the last paragraph in my oped, do you think my conclusion incorporates any element of course topography? i notice that neither you nor ken notes this.

if you put on a championship triathlon, with parity of field, on a flat course, you’re going to get drafting. there is nothing you can do to stop this. nobody is going to stop this. a personal course marshall for every athlete is not going to stop this. one thing will stop drafting among a full, competitive field. hills. steep hills and lots of them.

bike racing has known about this for a hundred years now. why does triathlon not know about this? is it a big secret?

good analogy in terms of volume creating congestion - the one difference being traffic slows things down but drafting speeds things up!

How awesome would it be if these were reversed??

I completely agree with Dan’s comments. While it’s nice to think we should all race fair and not draft, that ain’t gonna happen. But a course with some climbing would certainly help. I don’t know how everyone else feels, but I have no interest in gearing up and focusing my season on a race as late in the season as November. That makes for a really long season if you start in April or May as many of us do.

While I’m sure Clearwater is nice and served as terrific hosts, I for one am not dying to go there in November. It’s not like it’s a terrific tourist destination and it certainly ain’t Kona. So, why not move it somewhere else as Dan suggests and move it to September? I’ve done the Duke Half Ironman the last four years in September in North Carolina and the weather (and certainly not hurricanes) has never been an issue.

That is why I said that the RD should be assessed some blame, they chose the site, a flat course. Listen, I am not disagreeing with your conclusions on what a championship course should be, but rather with your statement earlier in your article that no one is to blame. The RD chose to have the race in November, limiting the number of available sites, and chose one close to home that was flat. Did they make the best choice they could based on the date of the race? Maybe. But still, they made a decision that ultimately contributed to the apparent rampant drafting. That was my point.

We have this trend in the US to always find excuses for everything, no one takes responsibity for their actions. The early paragraphs of your article seemed to take this kind of stance. That is where I disagree.

This has become so the norm on ST. Someone posts their opinion (In this case Editor-in-Chief Slowman). Thoughtful and well thought out. Someone comes along and disagrees. And it just can’t stay at that. Original poster can’t let it be and argues back. Quickly instead of a nice exchange of ideas it turns into a brew-ha-ha of a pissing match. State your opinion clearly, state it once, and then read what others have to say and let it be.

Just my .02