Sidi Ergo 2 Carbon: Pain in the foot?

I’m considering selling my bike shoes.
Two of my riding partners (Cat 2 and Cat 3) bought a pair of Ergo 2’s and they ALSO complain of discomfort with the shoes.

Oddly, all three of us have pain at different points in our foot, but the consensus is that the shoes are intolerable.

Anyone had a similar experience?

Any success stories with the Ergo 2?

Nope - I’ve tried them as well and just don’t work for me wither. Another of my teamates loves his though (he is Cat 3 - if that matters, since you mentioned it)

I just bought a pair earlier this year and I love them. The only issue I have with them is that they seem to leave me a little extra room in the toe box but otherwise I feel like the shoe really holds my foot well. I’d actually recommend this shoe to someone if they have a narrow foot. Ok - since it seems to matter I am a cat5 cyclist on my license.

What size? How used? How much?