…so i have this half marathon on Sunday…its in Sevilla, Spain of course…i hope to do from 1hr 30mins to hr 45mins as a realistic target…
I have three pairs of running shoes to choose from…do i go with the lightest or is shoe weight another marketing myth? There is a difference of like 140g total between the lightest and heaviest.
Persoanlly I think its all hype…just go with the shoe you think won’t make your foot blister and your joints ache less…rather than go for light shoe…
Any facts out there about lighter shoes saving you energy?
Everything else being equal…a lighter shoe is a faster time. But if you have shoes that “make” your foot blister toss em out, those aren’t working for you. Even lighter shoes (racing flats, lightweight trainers) should fit well and not cause blistering. That’s a sign of a bad fitting shoe for you.
I don’t know specific time savings but its definitly a speed boost. I have a pair of flats for tri and road races and when i put them on it feels like i am running in nothing its great.
I remember in class we discussed it was something like 1 or 2 percent more oxygen is needed for every 100 grams added to the feet. If you think about a racing flat being 300 to 400g (in total) lighter than trainers, that’s a lot of energy saved.
Yup - assuming you have trained some in your “racing” shoes, go with the lighter shoes, especially for a 1/2 marathon. I finally made the switch this year to racing shoes for IM and a full marathon. The lighter shoes should improve your time some (my WAG is about 30 secs for 1/2 marathon vs. trainers).
the half is short enough that a lighter shoe probably won’t hurt… as long as it doesn’t produce blisters or pains over a run of an hour or more, it’ll be fine. The benefits from lighter shoes are mostly psychological IMO. Certainly for sprinting the lightest shoe is best. For distance, it’s a matter of experiment, to find the lightest shoe that works best with the individual’s biomechanics.
Amby Burfoot reported from the Science & Medicine of the Marathon Conference in Chicago last year,
“Biomechanics expert Keith Williams pointed out that each additional 100 grams of shoe weight adds 1.9 percent to the oxygen cost of running”
but I could not find any citations for this assertion. Pubmed shows another reference to this 100g/1% theory, but again without data, http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/entrez/query.fcgi?cmd=Retrieve&db=PubMed&list_uids=15676526&dopt=Abstract
and also says “Cushioning and other features of shoe design besides weight have been shown to have significant effects on the economy of locomotion”.
Jack Daniels had this to say, on a letsrun thread:
“Definitely a couple different ways of viewing the situation – one from a mechanical point of view (potential for aiding or messing up mechanics) and one from a physiological (what shoe, or lack thereof requires the least energy to run in). I remember a shoe we played with that was very economical to run in but produced (allowed is a better choice of a word) considerable pronation and probably not for the masses. We saw less pronation when barefoot running compared with a variety of shoes of that time, but barefoot subjects the runner to more landing shock, so for some people costs more to run in than does a particular pair of shoes. You have to wonder if what you wear as you first get into running influences what works best. Then there is the whole issue of people being designed differently.”
I agree with what everyone has said here. I have racing flats, but after running about 6 miles in them my feet and legs get a lot of pains in them. So I only race in them for a 10K and down. I raced in my trainers for my 1/2 marathon last week. But if I could find lighter shoes that could see me through 13.1 miles I know I would be faster and I would use them! You have to decide if you have run far enough in your racing flats to know that you can make it for 13.1 miles in them.
I think it’s more like 1 second per mile per ounce of shoe weight. Typical trainer = 12 ounces and typical flat about 8-9 ounces (for marathon) so one could expect about 4 seconds per mile. That adds up to roughly 39-52 seconds for 1/2 mar.
I raced US duathlon nationals this year in a shoe that I can only estimate at about 100 grams, perhaps a little less. That was 15K on a pair of shoes that probably had 800 miles on them and all the blown rubber outsole was totally gone. I was used to them though, so I had no issues and the difference between them and a pair of 280 gram “lightweight” trainers was like night and day.
If you have not run your race distance in the racing flats, then I would use a different shoe.
It’s in your head, baby! And that’s a good thing! I have racing flats and I love them. I am by no means “fast enough” to wear flats for long races, but I do because I love how they feel. Basically, I feel really fast in them, and in my opinion that definitely contributes to having a better, stronger, faster run. Certainly there are mechanical advantages that can be quantified, and I appreciate that, but it’s the physhological advantage that I like the most.