Funny, you have concluded that 180mm cranks are best for you, yet you don’t think the same precision (177.5mm vs. 180mm) can be applied to bike fitting in general?
about the cranks, please note the word i used before the crank example: hypothetically. i.e., it was a hypothetical example. and the case of bike cranks is good one for other reasons. the fact that manufacturers make cranks every 2.5 mm but over an extremely small range is hilariously goofy (but saves bike makers and sellers money). making them over such a small range shows how little thought is actually behind their manufacturing choices. what they should do is make cranks every, say, 5 mm but over a much larger range.
Except that I’ve seen what a MASSIVE difference 5mm makes, especially in terms of fit. 2.5mm is an appropriate increment, at least based on my experience.
so if you were the rider in the hypothetical crank example, would you pick the 150mm or 160mm cranks over the 179mm cranks?
No, but I also disagree that this is analogous to the STA discussion. Studies have shown that you can adapt to just about any crank length. There have not been studies showing similar adaptation to bike position. I.e., you can ride slack for years and years and years, and yet see immediate results from steepening your STA. This is not the case with crank length.
anyway, you misread what i wrote: I actually DO BELIEVE that precision can be applied to bike fitting in general. it is just that I DO NOT BELIEVE the current two (conflicting) STA measurement methodologies presented on the ST pages are currently anywhere near precise, in spite of their claims (claims which are not supported by any visible evidence).
I think there is truckloads of anecdotal evidence. Look at the riders that are, currently, dominating the elite level time trials OR elite level triathlon. Take that for what it is worth, but it is rather overwhelming. Do you think the entire world is so influenced by Dan Empfield’s personal beliefs?
-If you want to ride aerobars at 79deg, will you be comfortable at 76deg.?
-If you want to ride aerobars at 79deg, will you be comfortable at 77deg.?
-If you want to ride aerobars at 79deg, will you be comfortable at 78deg.?
-If you want to ride aerobars at 79deg, will you be comfortable at 78.5deg.?
-If you want to ride aerobars at 79deg, will you be comfortable at 78.2deg.?
It would depend on the saddle. If you are telling me that I could not move forward of the 76* line, then no, I would not be comfortable. It’s funny that you should ask this particular question, because I’ve actually tested it. I notice that a shift of as little as 7mm in saddle setback, which equates to roughly 1/2 a degree at my seat tube height, makes a massive difference in terms of my overall comfort, power, etc. I would say during the course of a ride, I probably shift fore-aft a net of 1cm or so. I also ride with a lot of other triathletes and find it remarkable how little they actually shift in the saddle during standard riding (i.e., on the flats, they sit in basically one spot, on steep climbs or descents, they may shift back/forward, but then move right back to the given spot for the vast majority of the ride)
jordan, it so easy to see on ST when someone is running out of ideas. the poster will make claims about what they think the other person knows or does not know. or about them being contrarian. or maybe make claims about their height. or just otherwise attack the messenger. the fact is, you have no idea what i have a grasp on, or do not have a grasp on, or who i have fit on their bikes. but we are not discussing your or my fitting resume. i am simply trying to get folks to think critically and to point out some major and glaring inconsistencies.
You are correct. However, whether or not you actually are employed as a fitter, I will dispute that your claims bely that you in fact do not grasp the fundamentals of tribike fitting. When 90+% of the top triathletes and time trialists (who are, by the way, limited by a stupid UCI rule) choose to ride in remarkably similar positions, and yet you say there is no evidence to support this methodology, I have to believe that you fundamentally don’t understand. Just because you may do something, it doesn’t mean you do it right. So yes, you may in fact be a fitter. But based on what you have written, I would not pay you to fit me.
i do not enjoy being contrarian. but i do enjoy using my head and my biomechanics knowledge to point out that there are some big problems in the methodology of the fittng philosophies presented here (even though i generally agree with the fitting philosophy). not acknowledging the existence of these problems and variability destroys the credibility of the idea.
On a fundamental level, I disagree with what I believe you are calling the basics of FIST fitting, which is to say that people select a STA within a very narrow band, and that pushing people outside of that narrow band results in tremendous discomfort. Perhaps if you could include a reply without all the quote/unquote that states simply what you disagree with (I am not sure what two STA measurements you are referring to, for example), that would help. I also think that there is a strong difference between “using your head” and being contrarian. You do not feel that you are contrarian. However, my reading of your replies is that you are basically nitpicking over what I perceive to be minor details, in an attempt to basically undermine a philosophy of fitting that you then claim to basically agree with. In my book, that is the definition of contrarian. Of course, I don’t expect you to write “you are right, I just like being difficult.” But that doesn’t mean that I cannot (or should not) infer that from what you write or how you write it.