Saddam's execution

I can’t believe that our military is going to execute Saddam when he didn’t even have WMD!?!?
There is no way he got a fair trial with Bush’s last couple of appointees to the Supreme Court.
I heard they were going to get the guy from Florida that kept missing the vein just to make it more painful…

Wow, so many wrong facts in so few sentences, are you being sarcastic?

First our military is not executing Saddam. His trial was not about WMD, it was about Crimes against the people, more specifically the kurds in the North of Iraq that he had murdered in large numbers.

It was an Iraqi court not the US Supreme Court.

And with the last line, I really hope the whole post was in jest or a Troll.

I was trying to represent what I think the average uninformed citizen might be thinking about the situation.

No I believe the average uninformed citizen would say something like this “I’m glad that Saddam is being executed it will bring justice to the people he killed.”
.

I was trying to represent what I think the average uninformed citizen might be thinking about the situation.

I think the uninformed would say, “now that Hussein is gone, Democracy in Iraq will flourish.”

I think that you’re right (but just about this).

Ahh, the benefit of cutting and pasting.

See my new signature line.

:slight_smile:

Damn,
I was trying to avoid this.

Dave,

As I experience you as a thoughtful and wise man, I thought I would pass this link on to you. It is one of the better things I’ve read about the Hussein trial and impending execution.

http://www.time.com/time/world/article/0,8599,1573182,00.html

While I think the majority of what you’ve said in your post is factually incorrect:
I have a problem with executing Saddam Hussein. We (as human beings) have a choice to do something better than Saddam himself. We can choose not to kill. Since we are in a position to exercise choice in this matter, and we are humans, we must recognize that- when presented with such a choice- we must *always choose not to take life as we regard it as wrong. * For all the occasions in warfare when the taking of life is not a choice, mandated by the urgency of combat, this is a vastly different circumstance- one that we imposed upon the circumstance- yet we choose to kill, the very offense we use to convict Hussein.
I know that my view of this is rudimentary. I am also not an Iraqi, and have not been subjected to Saddam’s long list of human rights violations including murder, torture and genocide. I know that. Perhaps it is this detached perspective that skews my outlook.

I cannot, as a human, condone the termination of another human’s life when there is choice in the matter.

This news of Saddam Hussein’s execution- I read it with great concern and some measure of fear that we are lowering ourselves to the same level of barbarism we accuse him of. That does not feel good.

Fair opinion, and, as always well stated. But do you really think the Iraqi approach is inferior to how Milosevic was handled?

Tom,
the majority of what I said in my first post is not factually incorrect…all of it is. I respect your stance on life. The fact is that this is what the iraqi government has chosen as their path. What choice do they have as a government? They are struggling for some sort of national legitimacy in a culture where people only understand violence. If their first act is one of mercy, I think it would be wildly misinterpreted.
Remember, we are not lowering ourselves to any level, unless the we you speak of is as a human race

I was speaking of the human race, and this is not a step forward.

I am opposed to the death penalty but since it was carried out in Iraq, by Iraqis, you have to accept it. I don’t think anyone really wins when someone is hanged. The victims are still victims and the family members are still missing their family member. I often hear the press report that family members can now “rest easily” or “get on with their lives” but if you have ever lost a family member to a violent crime, you know that is not the case.

As for the reaction in Iraq, I don’t think Saddam Hussein will have any impact whatsoever. The conflicts are not about Hussein, they are about religious factions trying to assert power in his vacuum. The Sunnis are not out there fighting for their former leader, they are fighting to assert power as a minority.

Hussein has been out of the picture for a long time. The family members who lost someone to Hussein will feel a bit of satisfaction at his death because they now know no one else will have to go through what they did but ultimately, they are still without their loved ones.

Iraq is still in a civil war and will be as long as we are there and until they find a way to reach some form of government without any outside interference. In other words, it will be more of the same old same old as long as this administration continues to think our involvement will help the situation.

Tom, Thanks for the link.

I think that article was spot on. Lets hope , as it appears now, that this will not be a rallying cry for increased problems in Iraq.

Although my views on the Death Penalty are not as clear as yours. I do think the way it is handled in the US is completely screwed up and wrong.

Also not being from the region or that upbringing I do not know how the Iraqi people would have viewed the new government had it just handed Saddam over to the world courts to deal with.

I’m glad they killed the fucker.