I used to run in Hokas but switched last year. Right now I’m running in Nike Air Pegasus 34 and I really like them. I was hesitant to buy them because I’m not a Nike fan, but they’re great good shoes. I’m definitely going to buy another pair. I’m also running in Adidas Boston for tempo runs and races. Those are great shoes too, but more lightweight and probably not the cushioning you’re looking for.
I think what I like so much about the Nike Air Pegasus is that they’re just good, basic, well-built running shoes. No gimmicks. I wasn’t amazed by them when I first put them on because they just felt like normal running shoes. The more I run in them, the more I like them. I liked the feel of Hokas when I first tried them on, but I was never impressed with their quality (especially for the price).
The Pegasus may not have as much cushioning as you’re after, but they are good shoes if you decide to go that route.