Good points from Kinsley.
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/sunday/commentary/la-oe-kinsley7nov07,1,7784296.column?coll=la-sunday-commentary
It’s true that people on my side of the divide want to live in a society where women are free to choose and where gay relationships have civil equality with straight ones. And you want to live in a society where the opposite is true. These are some of those conflicting values everyone is talking about. But at least my values…don’t involve any direct imposition on you. We don’t want to force you to have an abortion or to marry someone of the same sex, whereas you do want to close out those possibilities for us. Which is more arrogant? We on my side of the great divide don’t, for the most part, believe that our values are direct orders from God. We don’t claim that they are immutable and beyond argument. We are, if anything, crippled by reason and open-mindedness, by a desire to persuade rather than insist. Which philosophy is more elitist? Which is more contemptuous of people who disagree?
This is tit for tack quicksand. Both sides need to get a grip and get along.
That commentary (from the elite commentariat metality so in vogue these days among the hard left) starts from a number of false assumptions, and would be just as hard to answer as would be trying to debate the existence or non-existence of a supreme being to someone from the hard Christian fundamentalist right.
You just can’t. No one from either side will stop the yowling, screeching and stammering long enough to try to find some middle ground. Certainly, the hard left will not concede any reasonable restriction on late 3rd trimester abortions, for fear that the “slippery slope” will lead to a total ban on all abortion, and the hard right will not accept even the consideration that some abortion (in cases of rape, incest or the health of the mother) might also be called for.
Certainly the left has its hands just as dirty as the right. To refuse to accept that is to be just as obtuse, stubborn and foolhardy as those on the other side. In fact, I’d hazard an opinion that the left, with its doctinaire and rigid worldview could be a pretty good example of what something like the Taliban would be, if it were secular-humanist, rather than theocratic-fundamentalist.
Both sides need to grow up. Fast.
K
I like how you tried to be all deliberate and reasonable, then slipped in a comparison of the left to the taliban at the end.
Well, maybe his side believes that women should be free to choose to abort, but he is not interested in father’s having any freedom to choose, and certainly not interested in advocates for the babies have any freedom to choose. He wants to impose that choice on fathers and babies.
He is also not right about desires of “his side” to have gay marriage, unless he really limits the definition of his side. Millions of Kerry voters voted in favor of the 11 anti gay marriage amendments. He wants to impose gay marriage on an unwilling majority.
Other than that, incisive analysis from Kinsley, as usual.
The condescendtion never ends. They just won’t get it.
I can’t wait. Nominate Thomas for Chief Justice and let the filibuster begin. Nominate Estrada to take his place, and let that filibuster move forward. How many more Senate seats do the Democrats want to lose? How much more of the black and Hispanic vote do they want to give up?
I love how condescending you are when you complain about condescension from the other side!!!
**I like how you tried to be all deliberate and reasonable, then slipped in a comparison of the left to the taliban at the end. **
I’m always deliberate and reasonable, and I’ll take the time to explicate if you want. I’d rather you parse the passage and ruminate on what I wrote, which was not a characterization of the left, but rather what the left could be in danger of BECOMING if they are not willing to at least try to compromise on its viewpoint.
Still lashing out in anger and frustration over November 2nd? Then, that’s why the Dems are doomed to decades of minority party status. Get it quickly or become captive to a quixotic quest for that which you may not have. At least for this next generation.
K
I am not condescending at all. I am asking you to step up with cogent ideas rather than ridicule.
This country needs two competitive major political parties. Democrats aren’t going to become one again by listening to the likes of Kinsley.
You really don’t understand me at all.
I can’t have a reasonable conversation with someone that thinks democrats = taliban.