Read and Weep: Attitudes to Cycling in New Zealand

A group I ride with was hit by a car which apparently went straight through a stop sign. One of us was critically injured, three more were hospitalized. Fortunately I wasn’t riding with them that day. This group is comprised of predominately middle-aged men, rides with good group etiqette, never more than two abreast and obeys the traffic signals.

Here’s the news item:

A cyclist was critically injured and three others hurt when a car ploughed into a pack of 20 riders in Auckland yesterday.
Cyclists who were with the injured men described the scene as “absolute carnage.”
“All you could hear was the sound of carbon and bodies falling everywhere … they were crashing all over the place,” said Max Horley, who was riding behind the injured men.
Cyclist Maryanne Bawden described: “Bits flying, the noise, and then my friends lying on the ground.”
The seriously injured rider, Auckland civil engineer Greg Paterson, was last night in Auckland Hospital with critical head injuries.
Police said the serious crash unit was investigating the accident on Tamaki Dr in St Heliers, a popular waterfront cycling route.
Charges were likely to be laid against the female driver.
Peter Restall, who was leading the group, said Paterson was an experienced rider who had previously taken part in the 160km Lake Taupo Cycle Challenge.
He was riding yesterday with a social cycling group, the Pickled Pedallers.

Paterson’s wife Claire had flown to Christchurch yesterday morning but rushed back to Auckland to be at his bedside.
His two adult children, who are studying in Christchurch and Dunedin, were also flying to Auckland yesterday.
Another rider, Dave Woods, suffered broken vertebrae in his neck, broken ribs and facial cuts.
A third rider, Kevin Marsh, received a deep gash to the knee and a broken kneecap needing surgery. The fourth man, Steve Lobb, also broke his collarbone, a shoulder blade and a thumb.
Witnesses to the crash said the vehicle was turning from Cliff Rd on to Tamaki Dr when it collided with the pack, who were riding from the waterfront towards Vale Rd.
They said the car appeared to slow down briefly before speeding towards the cyclists.
“She accelerated into the middle of the group, just cleaned the guys up,” said John Cooney.
The driver was “roundly abused” by the riders when she stopped.
Police inspector Willie Taylor said the driver appeared to have driven through a compulsory stop before colliding with the group.
The driver, who stayed at the scene and tried to help, was being interviewed “with a view that there is some fault.”
He said the incident was concerning. “Hundreds of cyclists use this road at the weekend. The intersection is fairly clearly marked and the driver will have some questions to answer.”
Cyclists called for urgent action to provide a safe cycling track in the wake of the collision.
“Cars and cyclists don’t mix,” said Restall.
“It’s my firm belief that if they can’t close a road for an hour early in the morning, then the most ideal solution would be a dedicated cycle lane.”
Cycle Action Auckland co-chair Barbara Cuthbert agreed cyclists needed dedicated track facilities - but motorists should also respect their right to be on the road.
“It’s about better driving habits in New Zealand firstly, and that includes respecting cyclists.”
Cuthbert said Tamaki Dr was a regular source of conflict between cyclists, pedestrians and traffic.
Most riders avoided using a dedicated cycleway on the pavement because of the number of runners and walkers.
“There isn’t an instant solution for it, but it’s certainly an issue that needs to be addressed.”
Cycling Advocate’s Network co-chairman Axel Wilke said lowering urban speed limits should be considered. The move has successfully lowered the road toll overseas.
“We don’t need to reinvent the wheel, we just have to look at what works elsewhere and how we can implement it here,” he said.
Unless speeds were lowered, cyclists would continue to be killed.
*** Fatal cost of riding your bike**

Seven cyclists have been killed so far this year on New Zealand roads.
Last year 10 riders were killed and almost 900 injured, with most crashes occurring at intersections on urban roads.
Last weekend cyclist Frank van Kampen, 46, was killed after being struck by a car near Otaki.
A 34-year-old cyclist was killed last month in a hit-and-run accident near Leeston, Christchurch.
Another Christchurch crash took the life of a 19-year-old cyclist in July.
Two cyclists have been killed in the Bay of Plenty, one in a May accident at a Mt Maunganui roundabout, and another following a crash involving a logging truck near Te Puke in March.
Two Dunedin cyclists have also lost their lives - one after colliding with a car in the city in March, and another in a crash outside of Mosgiel in June.

But here’s a sample comment from the blog:

Cyclists need to stay off the roads and stop pretending they are motor vehicles.
Cyclists don’t pay registration fee’s so they don’t have the same entitlement as a motor vehicle.
They shouldn’t be on the roads!
In the past 2 years we’ve noticed a flood of cyclists hitting the roads riding like idiots. They endanger themselves and registration paying motorists.
Ban bikes from using roads, thats how you make cycling in New Zealand safer!

I would like to think the blog is just being trolled, but I suspect most of the posters are serious. The general tenor seems to be that cyclists mustn’t ride in groups. Here’s the link

http://blogs.nzherald.co.nz/blog/your-views/2009/9/27/what-can-be-done-make-cycling-new-zealand-safer/?c_id=1&objectid=10600013

I read the NZ Herald and the responses a few hours ago and none of the responses really surprised me.

Regardless of what us cyclists think though, we will always come off 2nd best in road accidents with motor vehicles. Coming from the countryside I don’t really have any solutions for riders in ‘built up’ areas of big cities.

What I will say though is that in general NZ driving is not good, which comes back to the original training/licensing process of drivers.
Road accidents in NZ have indirectly had a big effect on me and most NZers. We are very reliant on using cars and they are inherently more dangerous than a ‘good public’ transport system’. So I really feel bad for you cyclists but have also seen the photos of a large truck going straight through a stop sign and flattening a smaller vehicle(I did a locum and replaced the guy several days later). Meet the driver who wiped him off the earth when he come to say sorry and my intended reaction was only stopped by the dead guys work colleague. People do make mistakes, but when you look at the way some people drive they are accidents waiting to happen ; eg I still see people passing on blind hills and bends. More fines and policing of people running stop signs would be a good start.

I welcome you all to come down to Southland and ride on our very quiet roads in Summer. I count cars to keep me interested on solo rides and sometimes only see two vehicles on average/hr for 5hr rides. Have a couple of spare rooms also and you are welcome to get in touch.

I also do think riding in groups is dangerous in cities and haven’t liked it the few times I did it. when driving and riding in NZ I try whenever possible to be a defensive driver and slowdown near interesections and watch out for people who don’t see me.
The above is just how I see it. Going by the stats and from what I see, things are not going to improve anytime soon…Take care.

G.
www.TriathlonShots.com

Well said, sums things up well. I wish I could ride on those SI roads… out and backs to Thames from Auckland can get very dicey with truck and trailer log trucks passing within a metre, and those "%*$ing yoof in their skylines and subarus throwing whatever they can dredge from their car at me. I think the attitude to cyclists in Auckland is worse than most places, Christchurch drivers seem to be waaaay more accommodating than my fellow jafas

This thread is relevant beyond the borders of NZ so will respond again.

Accidents like the one reported in Auckland above was the result of driver error. But I think us cyclists are increasing our chances of problems if we ride alot in ‘built-up’ areas.
As you say this group rides only 2 abreast but if you are riding where there is alot of traffic then you will be holding them up in their vehicles. The drivers should just chill out, but that isn’t going to happen in the fast paced world of today. So I think it is better not to antagonise them(they are ‘bigger’ when they are in their cars afterall).

Solutions to that is to head out of town for the weekend to somewhere quiet with your family or friends. Mountain biking is a safer option also as you will be away from heavy traffic and drunk drivers returning home in the eraly morning.
I choose to base myself for 6 months of the year in an area where there are open roads and very little traffic. A deciding factor was for cycling to carry on doing triathlons. The open roads is an important part of safe cycling areas also.

G.
http://www.triathlonshots.com/Cycle%20safety.html

Same story here in Perth. Similar accident happened here over a year ago and from the sounds of things same type of idiotic responses.

http://www.news.com.au/perthnow/comments/0,21590,24016093-948,00.html

What infuriates me is that 99% of us also own a car and pay the same rego that they keep whining about. Separate facilities are not always the answer, at least in terms of shared paths. Pedestrians on these don’t realise they are thoroughfares and take up the full width. A tourist ped was killed by a commuter because they weren’t looking and strayed into the path of the cyclist. We’re public enemy number 1.

Govt’s really need to undertake public awareness campaigns (we’re trying to promote green these days aren’t we?) and police need to clamp down on aggressive motorists.

If these drivers only realised how many people they know (related, friends, colleagues) that actually ride bikes they could then humanise cyclists and then maybe they’d give them more respect.

Well put.

I ride in the Auckland area and a couple of years ago made a conscious decision to cycle on the quietest back roads I could find, even if the terrain is less than ideal for the training I need.

In addition to the many the inattentive and poorly trained drivers, there also seem to be so quite a lot of aggressive drivers who seem to have it in for cyclists - I have had things thrown at me and often people screaming and swerving near me, and I never ride two abreast. Virtually all the aggressive ones are young lads in souped up cars, or middle aged men in utes, it seems they feel threatened by the sight of a healthy guy, maybe its a primal instinct!

I would rather minimise the chance of meeting them.

Seriously, what am I supposed to do. I have just got back from the city and was riding towards the AK library on Mayoral Drive. I was doing about 40kph (the same as the bus in front of me) and was in the green bus/cycle lane. A bus driver behind me started sounding his horn and pulling right up to me, say 2m behind. He is yelling out his window to “get off the fucking road dickhead” . He CANNOT go faster than me because I was going the same speed as the bus in front. He changes out of the bus lane, half overtakes in a flurry of diesel fumes and then plows back into my lane, with me still in it - I had to SLAM on my brakes or else I would have been sideswiped with a good chance of being seriously injured or killed - I dont back myself against a bus. The fucker then pulls into the bus stop outside the library. I WAS RIDING IN THE CYCLE LANE AT THE SAME SPEED AS EVERYTHING ELSE.

At this point, and against my better judgement I lost the plot completely, rode to the bus, took a few steps on board, called him some terrible expletives and showered him with the sticky contents of my bottle. He was real angry and removed his 130+kg from behind the wheel and attempted to ‘get’ me. I walked quickly as jabba got all hot and bothered chasing me down the road. I doubled back behind him, sprinted back to the bus, removed the drivers keys and threw them on the roof of the bus, saluted the bus driver and left.

GRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!

I sincerely apologise to anyone who may have been late because of my red mist.

First time I’ve smiled in days! Well done Chur that’s classic, I salute you!

Dude that’s brilliant!!! Not perhaps the smartest thing to do, but still I feel your pain. Riding in Auckland really is quite terrifying at times.