I’m all for people demonstrating and picketing if they want. But I’m curious about people’s thoughts on the advocacy and support of people shouting down the health care reform proponents at town hall meetings.
A couple of months ago, Tom Tancredo was invited to speak at UNC. A bunch of students caused a commotion and shouted him down. Those students were correctly excoriated and much of the media, especially the right wing media, used that as an example of poor liberal behavior. But it seems to be encouraged in these cases.
I’m all for standing up for what you believe in, and for groups on both sides of the health care reform debate to make their voices heard, BUT I don’t think people on either side should be shouting down the speaker at these events. It’s just not respectful. I think people get so frustrated and disagree so strongly with what is being said they don’t want to hear it and start shouting out and disrupt the speaker BUT I don’t think that is right - it’s not right if it’s a liberal or conservative group shouting down the speaker. We saw this same thing from during the Bush administration. It seems that these town hall meetings were less violent and disruptive before the dems encouraged union groups and ACORN to come in and get in the opposition’s faces. I also really think that those opposed to health care reform, and the current administration’s policies in general, believe the administration is not listening to them and are trying to be heard. I mean, you have Obama himself saying these folks need to shut up and get out of the way and asking people to report email, etc… that disagrees with his policies. The polls show the majority of people oppose this plan but are being ignored. I plan to go to my congressman’s town hall meeting on Monday and am curious as to what I see and hear. My husband and I are very conservative and live in a liberal district - we are also the minority (race-wise) so it will be interesting.
Have not been at either of said events, but from what I understand the difference is that the students come and protest Coulter, Tancredo, Rove, etc from the start, in order to prevent them from speaking. These townhalls otoh, supposedly are starting out okay, then get to a boiling point of frustration...and that gets put on youtube. In my mind the problem is that probably several of the protesters show up knowing more about specifics of what is written in the various bills than the congress-person. The facts that we are not down to one bill, and that the bills are huge, are really making debate difficult, and most people just end up stumping for the "idea" of healthcare reform. It's time to get more specific, and I hope the pressure remains (or returns) to do so.
On a related point, DC seems to be treating this just like every other issue, and that is what is so destructive and disgusting about the place:
"
*Washington runs on political leverage, and at the current moment few people have more of it than Chuck Grassley. President Obama is desperate to have the Iowa Republican sign on to some version of ObamaCare to give cover to jittery Democrats. So in a remarkable noncoincidence, the Obama Administration decided to roll over last week on one of Mr. Grassley’s major concerns: ethanol. * OK, we will give in to your ridiculous use of government power if you will accept our ridiculous use of government power.
" http://www.coyoteblog.com/
ps. Hell, I think they should cancel all the townhalls…I mean how can you get together and discuss legislation that almost noone on either side has read? What a waste of time. It’s moronic for dems to be screaming “we have to do this, and NOW” and pubs to be shouting “don’t do it!”. It does distill to a shorter argument for those against it “Read the bill!”.
"
Here are some notes on the health care bill from one person who plowed all the way through it. Some of the interpretations are a bit over the top, but I find it a useful index to help me find relevent sections I want to read in more detail.
"
**But I’m curious about people’s thoughts on the advocacy and support of people shouting down the health care reform proponents at town hall meetings. **
There is nothing wrong with people expressing their views but these planned and deliberate acts are simply signs of playing politics.
The people are coached on how to protest and are essentially hired guns from the various parties. They are told to yell early to get the speaker off their topic, which really prevents the audience from hearing the opposing side, not even giving them a chance to express their views, their minds are already made up. If I went to a town hall meeting, I would want to hear both sides, and not the shrill voices of people who is there just to repeat the talking points from their party.
The people are coached on how to protest and are essentially hired guns from the various parties.
Who are the hired guns you are speaking of? Certainly not those who oppose health care reform! The majority of this country is against this health care reform bill and they actually care enough to show up to these events. In the early town hall meetings that ended up on youtube the people speaking out had valid concerns and knew enough about the bill to question it at these meetings. The congressmen and other officials leading these meetings clearly were not prepared for the opposition. After the health care reform supporters realized how much opposition was out there, and after they realized these people how are opposed are showing up to these meetings to make their voice heard, were groups, such as the unions and ACORN, encouraged to show up in force. Don’t know if it’s true but heard in some cases they were bussed in from other districts. Clearly this administration just cannot comprehend that so many people not only oppose their policies, but are willing to try to make their voices heard. Conservatives are not really known for protesting things, so I really think the left just doesn’t know how to handle this. As another poster said, most of these citizens know more about what’s in the bill then their representatives. They were able to ignore the “Tea Parties” but people showing up at their town hall meetings are much harder to ignore.
I’m all for standing up for what you believe in, and for groups on both sides of the health care reform debate to make their voices heard, BUT I don’t think people on either side should be shouting down the speaker at these events. It’s just not respectful. I think people get so frustrated and disagree so strongly with what is being said they don’t want to hear it and start shouting out and disrupt the speaker BUT I don’t think that is right - it’s not right if it’s a liberal or conservative group shouting down the speaker. We saw this same thing from during the Bush administration. It seems that these town hall meetings were less violent and disruptive before the dems encouraged union groups and ACORN to come in and get in the opposition’s faces. I also really think that those opposed to health care reform, and the current administration’s policies in general, believe the administration is not listening to them and are trying to be heard. I mean, you have Obama himself saying these folks need to shut up and get out of the way and asking people to report email, etc… that disagrees with his policies. The polls show the majority of people oppose this plan but are being ignored. I plan to go to my congressman’s town hall meeting on Monday and am curious as to what I see and hear. My husband and I are very conservative and live in a liberal district - we are also the minority (race-wise) so it will be interesting.
You start off your little rant on the right track. People should be polite and allow speakers to finish without shouting them down. But to blame the entire situation on the Obama administration is ludicrous. The political environment in the US is so poisoned right now that trying to blame one side or the other is not even worth trying.
There is no meaningful health care debate, there is just a bunch of shouting from either side. Most people admit that there are serious problems with the system, but rather than have a serious debate into some type of reform, everyone is pushing their own agenda. What the US will end up with is a seriously flawed clusterfuck that will satisfy no one.
It is a sad state of affairs to watch, the political environment is poison right now. And don’t try and tell me it is democracy in action. Far from it. These “protests” from both side are fueled by special interest groups from both sides and large pots of money, the end result will be the little guy getting screwed as per usual. Pathetic.
To quote an article published in Saturday’s New York Times,
…"There is no dispute, however, that most of the shouting and mocking is from opponents of those plans. Many of those opponents have been encouraged to attend by conservative commentators and Web sites.
**“Become a part of the mob!” said a banner posted Friday on the Web site of the talk show host Sean Hannity. “Attend an Obama Care Townhall near you!” The exhortations do not advocate violence, but some urge opponents to be disruptive. ** “Pack the hall,” said a strategy memo circulated by the Web site Tea Party Patriots that instructed, “Yell out and challenge the Rep’s statements early.”
“Get him off his prepared script and agenda,” the memo continued. “Stand up and shout and sit right back down…"
It appears to me that a lot of the outrage is orchestrated and nothing more than Conservative talking points, without giving the speakers a chance to speak.
Yes, there is a lot of shouting from both sides BUT I do place more of the blame on the current administration. Republicans have proposed ideas but have been completely shut out by the democrats. Same thing with the so called stimulus that was passed. Obama said many times how he was going to be bi-partisan but this is by far the most partisan administration we’ve had in my lifetime. The president and his administration state they are going to ram this through and it will pass … they have totally closed their minds to any alternatives. Also, when the current administration asks for any emails, etc against health care reform to be forwarded to the White House, and encourages groups like ACORN to come out to basically oppose those who don’t agree with the president … well, then yes, Obama does deserve a lot of blame for this.
"
Here are some notes on the health care bill from one person who plowed all the way through it. Some of the interpretations are a bit over the top, but I find it a useful index to help me find relevent sections I want to read in more detail.
"
A “bit” over the top?
My favorite is the ever-popular “it’s going to insure all the illegals and us hardworking taxpayers will pay for it” bit (PG 50 Line 15). That section says nothing about citizenship status, legal or otherwise.
He apparently missed section 246 on page 143, which would be the section actually titled, “NO FEDERAL PAYMENT FOR UNDOCUMENTED ALIENS.”
In fact, I can’t find anything about free health care for anyone. Subsidized, yes. Free, no.
Yes, there is a lot of shouting from both sides BUT I do place more of the blame on the current administration. Republicans have proposed ideas but have been completely shut out by the democrats. Same thing with the so called stimulus that was passed. Obama said many times how he was going to be bi-partisan but this is by far the most partisan administration we’ve had in my lifetime. The president and his administration state they are going to ram this through and it will pass … they have totally closed their minds to any alternatives. Also, when the current administration asks for any emails, etc against health care reform to be forwarded to the White House, and encourages groups like ACORN to come out to basically oppose those who don’t agree with the president … well, then yes, Obama does deserve a lot of blame for this.
You think the Obama administration is more partisan than the previous administration? Sorry, the Republicans have perfected partisanship, and taken it to another level. There were certainly concessions made to Republicans on the stimulus, including a higher percentage of tax cuts than originally suggested by the Dems. Not a single Republican house member voted for it. Even in the highly partisan Bush administration, Democrats would cross over and vote with the Republicans. It’s not surprising the Dems aren’t involving the Republicans anymore – why bother? The Republicans clearly aren’t going to vote for anything anyway.
Much like Geithner to the finance bosses, Obama just recently took the same tact by telling those that disagree with him to "quit talking, and get out of the way". Dissent is not recognized or in any way accepted in this admin. Keep your eyes open, and even you may become troubled at some point.
I would love to see bi-partisanship on this or any bill. Unfortunately, I think the tone was set pretty early. I can recall Boehner essentially dismissing everything about the stimulus bill before it was even written. Of course, the Dems did try and get Republican input – and made some changes to try and accomodate them. That was rewarded with exactly 0 house Republican votes. That pretty much says it all. Bi-partisanship is a two way street. I guess this is Obama’s version of “If you’re not with us, you’re against us”.
“‘Become a part of the mob!’ said a banner posted Friday on the Web site of the talk show host Sean Hannity.”
I think the NYT’s writers need to become more adept at recognizing pink font. The “mob” business on Hannity is a humorous response to derogatory comments from the left labeling the critics of ObamaCare as a “mob.” I understand that Hannity is now asking all callers to identify themselves by “mob” names (e. g., “Vino the Enforcer”). I’m not a Hannity fan, but I did find that to be pretty funny.
“The polls show the majority of people oppose this plan but are being ignored.”
Interesting thoughts. At one point, the war in Iraq was very unpopular, and the majority of Americans were opposed to it. But I don’t think it was ok for people like Code Pink to go and try to disrupt hearings and meetings by shouting down speakers.
During the Bush years, when was ACORN encouraged to get in people’s faces at town hall meetings?
Not a perfect comparison, but here’s a thread from a while back where some (not all) of the normal liberals thought code pink activists were just cool, while several of the regular righties had significant problems with code pink, beyond the initial item of the wack-job lady accosting Condi Rice. A famouse poster here derided their courage.
Hopefully no dumbass protesting the health care reform plan does something as stupid as the lady that spawned the thread above. But, I’m guessing it is just time.