I predict that the proposal will refer to “victory” or “success” without defining what constitutes same or how to measure it.
I predict that any stated milestones will not be accompanied by a description of what happens if those milestones aren’t met.
I predict that any proposed actions that include matching Iraqi Army forces will not indicate why these forces will be any more capable than those forces that failed to do their jobs in the past.
I predict there will be no admission of mistakes in the past (e.g., no indication that maybe the time for more troops was earlier than now) that might lead us to believe that anything done now will actually fix problems.
Your prediction about me, however, is spot on. That’s because any solution I’d approve would involve things like admitting errors, eating a bunch of crow, changing a world view, asking for sacrifice from everyone in the country, and related stuff that won’t happen.
“stupid and incompetent” is so last year - - now and forevermore the phrase is “criminal”
…
I think Bush’s proposal will wrap together the same rhetoric he has used since day one . . lots of the word ‘freedom’ and etc, but mostly it will be about building the Iraqi economy, Iraqi jobs, getting the Iraqis to take over security … you know, the same stuff he has been saying we have to from the beginning - the same stuff he has failed to do over the last 4 years.
He may use the word surge when referring to proposed troop levels - but we know that a surge implies a short duration and this will be no short surge - he and his minions have already spun this to take 12-24 months.
He won’t refer to how he used to say how he responds to the generals on the ground regarding troop levels (the generals used to say they needed more troops and he fired them) - - now they say a surge won’t work and he is once again ignoring them.
Once again Bush will prove to the world he is criminally insane.
I predict he will declare victory and announce that all US troops will be coming home within the month.
Meanwhile back on planet earth…
He will admit that some tactical mistakes have been made in the past but that the overall strategy is sound and the objectives (whatever they may be) are worth the sacrifices.
He will tell us that victory is within our grasp and that we cannot let this unprecedented opportunity to foster a friendly democracy in the middle east pass us by.
He will taunt Democrats by repeating over and over that we cannot turn out backs on the troops over there, that we must allow them to finish the job and we must give them every resource they need no matter what the cost.
He will talk a lot about the morale of the troops and that political squabbling at home does not help.
He will as alway talk in vague sweeping generalities and refuse to define our reasons for being in Iraq or what it will take for us to be able to leave.
More troops and of course more money to help support their programs. NBC was saying something along the lines of 1 billion in support . Where is this money coming from?
I am so glad I blew my knee out a few years ago so I can’t be picked when the draft starts. Send his 2 daughters over there and you would be amazed how fast the troops leave that hell hole
I think your predictions are going to turn out to be pretty accurate. I also think that Bush probably won’t even describe or define a specific mission for the “new” troops.
As for this being fun, it isn’t.
I am curious as to why you would like to see an Iraq solution that calls for sacrifice from everyone in the country, though. What kind of sacrifice(s), and how would that help us in Iraq? Possibly you will say energy/oil conservation as part of a broad policy of independence from the Mid East, and while I’m in agreement with that, I don’t see how that’s going to help us in Iraq at this point. The time to have applied that solution as an Iraq strategy was before the invasion- like the increased troop level, our window of oppurtunity for that has passed.
I think your predictions are going to turn out to be pretty accurate. I also think that Bush probably won’t even describe or define a specific mission for the “new” troops.
As for this being fun, it isn’t.
I am curious as to why you would like to see an Iraq solution that calls for sacrifice from everyone in the country, though. What kind of sacrifice(s), and how would that help us in Iraq? Possibly you will say energy/oil conservation as part of a broad policy of independence from the Mid East, and while I’m in agreement with that, I don’t see how that’s going to help us in Iraq at this point. The time to have applied that solution as an Iraq strategy was before the invasion- like the increased troop level, our window of oppurtunity for that has passed.
Taking the cue from Art (believe it or not): stipulate to the fact that everything we’ve done since the beginning of time is a screw-up, what do we do know? Yes, renewable energy is the long term cornerstone of what to do about Iraq and the Middle East. It is the only stick we have to wield against the oil-rich Islamic countries that are at the root of this whole mess. We lie down with the dogs (corrupt governments of oil-rich countries), we get up with the fleas. Tell them that we are going to be energy-independent in 20 years, with or without their help, and that we will share the technology with the whole world. What they do in the meantime will dictate our attitude toward them after that. Those that see the writing on the wall will cooperate. Those that don’t will find that going back to herding camels ain’t all it’s cracked up to be. This will create some turmoil (maybe a lot of turmoil) in our and the global economy, resulting in sacrifice (like giving up your SUV is such a hardship) from people in this country.
This stick might just cause some real pressure on those who support Islamic extremists, and those who ride high on the oil gravy train. Such pressure (and admitting we screwed up in Iraq) just might get some regional support in Iraq, so we aren’t the unwanted target there. Eat crow, ask Saudi Arabia, Syria, Iran to assist in providing security in Iraq. Let them know in no uncertain terms that we will use more than harsh language if they try to meddle.
I’m not sure about whether we try to split Iraq; I’m thinking yes, as long as Iran/Syria/Turkey/Saudi Arabia understand we won’t tolerate annexation without due process of the people involved.
Talk about the chance to be another Greatest Generation…
The Pentagon has admitted they have been operating in Somalia for a while but you do have to question the timing of the announcement of the attacks on Al Qaeda.
What kind of sacrifice(s), and how would that help us in Iraq?
It probably won’t
From a recent Bush press conference:
“I’m not going to make predictions about what 2007 will look like in Iraq, except that it’s going to require difficult choices and additional sacrifices, because the enemy is merciless and violent.”
With his intent on increasing troop levels, I believe I’m beginning to realize what he means when he uses the word “sacrifice”. The implication that each of us are somehow giving up or “sacrificing” something is bs.