Polar S625X/Garmin 301 Shoot Out

I posted a few weeks ago looking for opinions on these two devices. I have both and after several weeks with both of these I have to say that the Garmin 301 wins. The Garmin software and computer interface was far easier, no foot pod, and the link with Training Peaks is a great tool to monitor your training. I will say that the Polar Wearlink is superior. Still interested with your experiences with both.

The wearlink chest strap is great. My experience is the 625X is unreliable in,Running up or down hills, Running fast pace or slow pace, Inaccurate when doing interval training, Running into wind.

Can’t argue with your points. But the GPS goes out in the woods, and when it’s cloudy. That can be just as annoying. I’ve had a Timex GPS, and now have a Polar S625. I’ll stick with the Polar. Lesser of evils. I suppose if you could calibrate the Polar each time you use it (easily), then it would be superior. Unfortunately stride rate and pace vary over terrain and type of workout. If you were to use it for a marathon, and calibrate it on terrain similar to the race course, and calibrate it at a race pace, then the Polar would likely be quite accurate, rain or shine. Both are subject to innacuraccy. And since I live in cloudy Cleveland, Ohio, I had to dump the GPS. BTW, Wearlink is VERY comfortable.

I live in Newfoundland and we haven’t seen the sun through the clouds since, I don’t know, October? I have a 301 and my wife a 201 and we have no issues with GPS signal - even out here in the North Atlantic. Despite the size and less than fantastic chest strap - I will not go back to a foot pod device. I find they do not work well on soft trails or running in the snow.

I can’t seen to get my S625X foot pod to work with my Yankz quick laces. That kind of sucks!! Anyone come across this issue?

Thanks, Chris

I agree. I think the Garmin unit is the better of the two, but they both have a lot to offer.

This is an easy one in my opion both from a cost perspective and usability. Let’s look at the cost factor: 625x is $300+ online, include the USB infrared, $35 and the Speed Sensor $35 and your into $370+. The Garmin is $225 and includes the USB connection. Oh yea, yes Polar and measure cadence ($35) and power ($300+?) where as the Garmin cannot. Still I give the advantage to the 301.

Usability: Ever try running trails w/ the 625x? Does not work for a damn, unless your candence and stride are constant. Try using the 625x during a triathlon continuously…It doesn’t allow you to toggle to different sports and keep a continous clock running, hum…

301 - The garmin works great, and with their new software (remember Garmin can update the Forerunner 301 software at the click of a button,) software version 2.63 it’s great for multisport. I use the 301 on both motionbased and traininpeaks.com, it rules. It’s this simple in mulitsport mode:

Swim hit start. and the end of the swim hit the lap button, it automatically switches to T1, hit the lap button on your exit from T1 and it switches to bike mode. End of the bike hit the lap button and it switches to T2, exit T2 and hit lap button and it switches to run. At the end of your run hit stop, and you’ve got more data than you can possibly imagine. Oh yea, did I mention that you can toggle through 4 diffent screen data options during any one of your sports.

Warning - The garmin 301 is not for folks who actually believe they swim a straight line until proven otherwise. I swam a 2.4 miler in Tempe Town Lake this weekend…I ended up swimming 2.55 almost another 4 minutes worth fo distance!

I’ve since stitched to the 301 purchasd for $225, sold the 625x on ebay for $290 including the speed sensor.

I used the 201 for my marathon training last fall. All in all, it worked pretty well. But it completely fell apart when I tried to use it on a tight course (.5 mile loop) or on a trail. I’m surprised at the other posters saying that the S625X is no good on a trail and not saying anything about the Garmin. On a heavily wooded train the Garmin doesn’t work at all! I think that on any technical trail isn’t going to be close to impossible to get one of these devices to work properly.

This spring I switched to the S625X because I wanted a power meter for the bike and I wanted distance and heartrate together. The s625x+power meter cost $550 (sale at all3sports.com). The power meter works well. Almost certainly not as well as a powertap, but I can use a disc with it, so that’s cool. The running computer seems to work well. Today I did a run that measures 11.16 miles on my cyclocomputer, and the s625x gave a reading of 11.1. So I think that’s pretty good.

The Garmin definitely wins in the software division. I agree that it’s stupid that one can’t switch between bike and run modes without starting a new clock on the s625x. I didn’t realize that the 301 had a multisport setting. That is very interesting. I was told (by Garmin) not to swim with my 201. I take it that the 301 has been beefed up in the waterproof department?

My main complaint is that the foot pod keeps brusing my foot. Anybody have that experience?

-Colin

Where did you find the 301 for $225? Quite a few on E-bay, but not sure I want to go that route.

Barefoot

Did you wear the unit on your wrist for the swim? I hope that is true as I thought that it was only water resistant.

Found it at: http://www.gpscity.com
.

I’ve done a couple of open water swims with it under my swim cap, work fine.

With the 301 in your swim cap - did you still get the GPS signal? Your earlier post said you swam 2.55 miles vs 2.4, so it sounds like you did get the tracking.

I did not a problem
.