I have also had these and I used Dr. Scholl’s. It took me two weeks to get rid of them using Dr. Scholl’s medicated discs. Every 2 days I would take the pad off and while in the bathtub or shower I would scrape away the dead skin with a pumice stone and then cut the rest out with finger nail clippers. It was a long process but I got rid of them without any pain and my foot looked great about one day after I finished the treatments. Good luck!