I want to thank everyone for the input, I appreciate you all taking time to provide your thoughts and experiences. I realize that I am very new to the sport and likely have little to gain with respect to performance (speed/time) by moving from my Planet-X wheels to “more aero” wheels (e.g., Zipp, HED,FLO). At this point it looks like I should be focusing on honing my skills so that I could truly benefit from a move to a more aero wheel. Thanks again for your responses.
Little to add, other than consider a wheel cover for your rear PX 60 if you haven´t already.
I was thinking about that. I have poked around at Wheelbuilder.com but was not sure if they could create on to fit my wheel. Are the covers easy to install? Thanks
Dead easy. Do the drive side cover first and using parcel tape, tape the cover tightly to the spokes. This prevents chain rub on the cover when in the biggest (inboard) cassette sprocket.
Thanks for the quick response.
I’m also a big advocate of disc-covers - very cost-effective solution.
Just make sure not to request the disc without holes (meaning you simply tape the disc to the rim). I did this once, untaped it in transition before the race, retaped it while wet…and it came undone in the race.
I had been dueling with number 10 in my age group, then the cover came undone and got caught in my spokes - 3 minute pit stop. During the stop, I was passed. I took 11th by 2:13.
Top 10 woulda been cool.
Bike split was still under 1:17 on a moderately hilly NYC course…#1 in my ag did a 1:06…only about 10 minutes faster.
Will i be faster? don’t know, but it looks cool
Sorry to bust your balls but many athletes fall victim to marketing hype & make poor equipment decisions based on this logic.
If I go through wheelbuilder (is there another source?) do I just specify I want a disc with holes? Honestly I’m not sure what that means but I look into it - I realize I have a lot to learn. Thanks
no worries but i don’t think this qualifies as falling victim to marketing. If that were the case I’d have bought the “faster wheels” to save “x seconds over 40k” Nobody markets there product as “buy these because they look cooler than the real fast ones”. Instead I bought the Planet x because the are probably a little faster than my stock rims, they fit my budget, and they make my bike look cooler. All my criteria was hit in this purchase.
There is another source, a guy in the UK has just started making carbon wheelcovers:
http://www.raltech.co.uk/Prod_3-Wh-Cov.html
He´s new to the market.
The default cover from WB has holes, you have to request the cover without them. Have a chat to them, they will know exactly what you need and their CS is second to none.
By the way, don´t confuse the taping I mentioned (inside of cover, parcel tape to spokes on drive side) with the current ST fad of ordering without attachment holes and taping the outside of said cover to the rim with 3M electrical tape instead.
Oh, and one guy on here made his own, and a VERY nice job he made of it too:
There is another source, a guy in the UK has just started making carbon wheelcovers:
http://www.raltech.co.uk/Prod_3-Wh-Cov.html
He´s new to the market.
I’ve just ordered one for a 404, I’ll post pic when it arrives.
here you go. pages 13-15 for competitor comparisons and pages 25-28 for shape case study in the 50-60mm depth class where the V-shaped easton EC90 @56mm is the class representative for V-shapes.
here you go. pages 13-15 for competitor comparisons and pages 25-28 for shape case study in the 50-60mm depth class where the V-shaped easton EC90 @56mm is the class representative for V-shapes.
Thanks.
I wonder what tires were used on each, and what effect that would have. Of course their own wheel is the fastest… ![]()
The chart sure makes the HED3 and Easton Ec90 look bad. Doing the math, at 10 degree yaw, there is roughly 110 grams difference between the EC90 and the HED stinger 6. So at 30mph, I believe that is about 13 watts? I wonder what the figure is for a more manageable speed like 23-25mph?
If it were, hypothetically, 8 watts, how do you calculate the time savings over say 40km?
interesting reading, thank you.
" notice the extremely high drag of the box section (traditional aluminum classics) wheel, which as a single
wheel has more drag than an entire Speed Concept bike at many yaw angles."
amusing…
I wonder what tires were used on each, and what effect that would have.
according to the paper p32,
"Bontrager engineers used the very same Bontrager XXX Lite 23c tire in the exact same orientation for every wheel test. "
that’s the tire I ride… it’s the only piece of equipment mentioned in the paper that I can afford ![]()
no kidding. even with a different protocol & tunnel entirely, you can see the FLO-generated mavic open32 data climbing up into the same general space.
tunnel protocol details not otherwise contained in the preceeding pages are on p32. it was a single 23c Bontrager Race XXX Lite used on every wheel. One less variable
(oy…doug in co beat me to it)
intent is not so much to make certain wheels look bad, but to highlight that there is a measureable difference, and that it’s often significant. don’t hone in on the EC90, then, but rather view it as representative of the class of V-section aero rims. the wide-rim phenomena is all that and then some. we’ve just gotten some data on the A9 D3 clincher with the R4 tires (23c I believe)…and as much as I love my tubie testride set I’m starting to regret passing up the clinchers that came by my desk yesterday. I do sit next to the guy who got them though…maybe I can set up a fake meeting to distract him for a few minutes…
as for time savings, I think jackmott’s got everything you need here.
Thanks Carl, appreciate the info.
Cheers
I am curious. If the Easton EC90 wheels perform so poorly then why do the sell for upward of $2,000/set? Or am I reading these results out of context. Is it that the Eastons are not too bad but the Bontrager (in the case) are better. Thanks
I think you understand things in the intended context…that depth is only part of the aero equation where rims are concerned. Shape matters. A lot.
We like to think we did a good job of laying out why we did what we did design-wise, and how we got the data to support it…but lets say you prefer to take your koolaid at half-strength*. So, in that depth class knock the D3 advantage over the (insert V-shape brand here) in half at whatever yaw you want to believe you ride in. Plug that drag delta into the rule-of-thumb relationships I linked to above, and you’re still talking roughly 5-25sec over 40k and 30sec-2min over the course of an IM. For a single wheel. Never mind improvements in handling qualities.
Everyone has their own pricing strategy, and a few of us try to give you some information you can plug into your personal value equation to decide if the bucks provide enough bang.
*Unfortunately, that’s understandable…there used to be standards around here for data citation by industry types. Maybe it has since been decided to let the forum simply hash it out on their own. We’ll continue to act as though you expect more from us. (/rant)