Phonak - huge news

Press Release : Phonak Team : CAS Decision
The International Cycling Union has taken note of today’s decision from the Court of Arbitration for Sport to grant a UCI ProTour license to the Phonak team for the years 2005-2006.

The UCI’s License Commission had refused to grant a license. In accordance with the procedure laid down in the UCI ProTour regulations, the Phonak team had appealed against this decision to the CAS.

The UCI has taken note of the CAS decision, which proves the independence as much of the License Commission, as of the CAS and the validity of the procedures put into place within the frame of the UCI ProTour.

The UCI welcomes the Phonak team within the UCI ProTour. This team will be the 20th UCI ProTeam for the 2005 season.**

UCI Press Service

mp

But here’s the interesting part from Cyclingnews:

“While respecting the will of the UCI to be strict in the fight against doping, the CAS arbitrators have considered that it was not possible, at this stage, to remove the Phonak team from the Pro Tour on the sole basis of doping suspicions concerning the two riders and before knowing the outcome of the disciplinary proceedings regarding them,” CAS said in a press release. In the 31 page-thick ruling, CAS said it believed Phonak’s rights of a fair hearing had been breached.

“The panel consider that the appellant (Phonak) did not have an unethical behaviour and that its application met all the required conditions to obtain a licence,” CAS said. “However, it is indisputable that, for the Phonak team, the year 2004 was marked by blood tests with average high values, a confirmed doping case and two cases of adverse analytical findings.”

I find it interesting that the CAS said that the UCI breached Phonak’s rights. This is good for the teams and riders. Basically CAS is saying the UCI can make ‘judgement calls’ against the team and riders without sufficient evidence/reasoning.

Now I’m wondering why it’s taking so long for the UCI to bring sanctioins against Hamilton and Perez? I wonder if the CAS knows the outcome of the disciplinary proceedings. I thought Hamilton was to present his case to the CAS. Does anyone know if he has? The last I heard was that he was now presenting his case to the US Doping Agency. Wouldn’t that mean he’s already gone to CAS, or is it the other way around.

I bet the UCI/WADA are a little nervous these days.