"Phantom Fury": Day 7 In Fallujah ("Mop Up")

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans11911141642.iraq_the_bridge_ans119.jpg

U.S. Marine Maj. Gen. Richard Natonski stands at the bridge in the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, where the bodies of two American contractors killed by militants were strung up in March, sparking the earlier U.S. siege, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans11811141634.iraq_the_bridge_ans118.jpg

A US Marine of the 1st Division writes the words ‘Dark Horse’ on a beam of the bridge western Fallujah, Iraq, where the bodies of two American contractors killed by militants were strung up in March, sparking the earlier U.S. siege, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. An earlier message left by soldiers reads: ‘This is for the Americans of Blackwater that were murdered here in 2004, Semper Fidelis 3/5.’ (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)
http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans12011141648.iraq_the_bridge_ans120.jpg US Marines of the first division move towards the bridge in the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, at background centre, where the bodies of two American contractors killed by militants were strung up in March, sparking the earlier U.S. siege, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans12111141649.iraq_fallujah_ans121.jpg

US Marines of the 1st Division take up position as they advance in the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. The U.S. military’s ground and air assault of Fallujah has gone quicker than expected, with the entire city occupied after six days of fighting, the Marine commander who planned the offensive said Sunday.(AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans11311141607.iraq_fallujah_ans113.jpg

U.S. Marines of the 1st Division push further into the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. The U.S. military’s ground and air assault of Fallujah has gone quicker than expected, with the entire city occupied after six days of fighting, the Marine commander who planned the offensive said Sunday. The military said 31 Americans have been killed in the siege. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans11111141605.iraq_fallujah_ans111.jpg

US Marine of the 1st Division take up positions Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004 near the bridge in the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, where the bodies of two American contractors killed by militants were strung up in March, 2004, sparking the earlier U.S. siege. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans11211141554.iraq_fallujah_ans112.jpg

US Marines of the 1st Division approach the bridge in the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, where the bodies of two American contractors killed by militants were strung up in March, 2004, sparking the earlier U.S. siege, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans10411141459.iraq_fallujah_ans104.jpg

A U.S. Marine of the 1st Division carries a mascot for good luck in his backpack as his unit push further into the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. U.S. military officials said Saturday that U.S. Forces had now ‘occupied’ the entire city of Fallujah. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans10111141443.iraq_fallujah_ans101.jpg

A U.S. Marine of the first Division passes by a burning house in the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. U.S. military officials said Saturday that U.S. Forces had now ‘occupied’ the entire city of Fallujah. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://hosted.ap.org/photos/J/JBM10911141638-medium.jpg

American Army doctors treat the broken leg of an Iraqi prisoner of war captured in Fallujah, according to hospital officials, after he was transported to the 31st Combat Support Hospital in Baghdad, Iraq Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. (AP Photo/John Moore)

http://hosted.ap.org/photos/A/ANS11611141636-big.jpg

US Marines of the 1st Division raid a house where they found improvised explosive devices (IED) in the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. U.S. military officials said Saturday that US Forces had now “occupied” the entire city of Fallujah. The U.S. military’s ground and air assault of Fallujah has gone quicker than expected, with the entire city occupied after six days of fighting, the Marine commander who planned the offensive said Sunday. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://hosted.ap.org/photos/A/ANS10611141525-big.jpg

A U.S. Marine of the 1st Division carries a mascot for good luck in his backpack as his unit pushed further into the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. The U.S. military’s ground and air assault of Fallujah has gone quicker than expected, with the entire city occupied after six days of fighting, the Marine commander who planned the offensive said Sunday. The military said 31 Americans have been killed in the siege. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://images.wn.com/i/01/0ebef84f1986b1.jpg

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/ap/20041114/capt.ans12211141708.iraq_fallujah_ans122.jpg http://us.i1.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/i/us/nws/p/ap120.gif

U.S. Marines of the 1st Division push further into the western part of Fallujah, Iraq, Sunday, Nov. 14, 2004. The U.S. military’s ground and air assault of Fallujah has gone quicker than expected, with the entire city occupied after six days of fighting, the Marine commander who planned the offensive said Sunday. The military said 31 Americans have been killed in the siege. (AP Photo/Anja Niedringhaus)

http://graphics7.nytimes.com/images/2004/11/13/international/iraq.gif

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/afp/20041114/capt.sge.fxl95.141104190413.photo01.photo.default-380x275.jpg

A US marine from the 3/5 Lima company walks towards a destroyed building along the main street in the restive city of Fallujah, 50 kms west of Baghdad.(AFP/Patrick Baz)

http://us.news2.yimg.com/us.yimg.com/p/afp/20041114/capt.sge.fxl95.141104190413.photo00.photo.default-315x380.jpg

A US marine of the 3/5 Lima company walks through damaged house gates in the restive city of Fallujah.(AFP/Patrick Baz)

For Scott.

After seeing a man I admired hung from that bridge they got off easy.

Don’t make the mistake of taking pity here. It’s a different world. The same rules don’t apply.

Sure, it’s terrible. No kidding.

But think about this: Did we display their burned remains dangling frm a bridge on CNN after we murdered them in an unprovoked attack?

No.

We told them we were coming. Announced it on the news. We came not to conquer but becasue it was a lawless place stright out of hell iteself.

So yeah, be nice to them, embrace them, send them aid, fel sorry for them. And they will murder you, cut your head off on TV, kidnap your family.

It is a different world. A world of animals and murderers. The rules are different. Nice dosen’t work. Ever.

Dear Howard Dean,

Ask the folks that were being tortured and held prisoner by these filthy animals if they are glad we liberated Fallujah? The only mistake we made was waiting to go in. We should have gone in 2 mo ago and shot every MFer in the back of the head. Who gives a shit what the people think. You are correct about one thing, we should not lose one of our boys in Iraq. Unless it is one of our pilots being shot down as he flattened the city.

In Flanders Fields

In Flanders fields the poppies blow
Between the crosses, row on row,
That mark our place; and in the sky
The larks, still bravely singing, fly
Scarce heard amid the guns below.

We are the Dead. Short days ago
We lived, felt dawn, saw sunset glow,
Loved, and were loved, and now we lie
In Flanders fields.

Take up our quarrel with the foe:
To you from failing hands we throw
The torch; be yours to hold it high.
If ye break faith with us who die
We shall not sleep, though poppies grow
In Flanders fields.

…Lt. Col. John Macrae
1915

**Final steps of dead men walking **
**The Times (UK) **| 11/15/04 | James Hider

**Fleeing rebels are tracked by aircraft and killed by US troops **

THE last hours of the mujahidin are terrifying. With the city they once ruled with the absolute authority of medieval caliphs now overrun by American and Iraqi troops, they have to keep moving. To pause even for a few minutes can mean instant death from an unseen enemy.

A group of 15 fighters dressed in black and carrying an array of weapons ducked into a two-storey house in war-torn southern Fallujah yesterday morning. Their movement was picked up by an unmanned spy plane that beamed back live footage to a control centre on the edge of the city. Within minutes, an airstrike was called and the house disappeared in a giant plume of grey smoke. From a house across the road, the explosion flushed out another group of guerrillas. Deafened by the blast, they stumbled out into the street, formed a ragged line and started off on the marathon to postpone their deaths, the drone dogging their every step.

“The rats are trying to move about,” Major Tim Karcher, of the Second Battalion, Seventh Cavalry, said as the figures flitted from street to street, seeking cover close to walls.

Sometimes they can throw off the drone, ducking out of sight of the men in whose power it is to summon FA18 fighter-bombers or 155mm artillery strikes. But they have no way of knowing. And, increasingly, as they run they are coming into the crosshairs of American snipers, crackshots such as Sergeant Marc Veen and his long-barrelled rifle, Lucille. Yesterday morning he spotted a black- clad man with an AK47 assault rifle peering round a corner 500 yards from the villa where Cougar Company of the Seventh Cavalry has set up a forward base.

He shot the man in the stomach: he fell, but kept crawling, so Sergeant Veen shot him again in the shoulder. Still the man tried to move away, so the sergeant blasted him with his 50-calibre machinegun.

“There’s pretty much no feeling,” the 24-year-old from Chicago explained, perched on the parapet of the house, the shell of the killer bullet tucked as a trophy into his flak jacket. “If I didn’t get that guy, that guy would get one of my buddies some time later down the line.”

The battle for Fallujah is all but over. The main north-south road in the once-dreaded Jolan district is a US military highway, smothered in dust kicked up by troop carriers and giant bulldozers. Almost every building is cracked, chipped or holed by the fighting.

Any guerrilla who could make his way back up from the last pockets of resistance in the south would see the mujahidin graffiti — “Jihad, jihad, jihad, God is Greatest and Islam will win” — replaced by slogans daubed by the US-backed Iraqi Army, posted the length of the route. Standing on a street reeking of decomposed bodies, the ruins of a five-floor building silhouetted behind him, Lieutenant Fares Ahmed Hassan said that the destroyed city would send a strong message to a nation where force has long been the lingua franca of government. “When the people of Fallujah come back and see their houses, they will kick out any terrorists. This will be an example to all Iraqi cities,” the Kurdish officer said.

Apart from a handful of women and children, the only civilians he had encountered were men of fighting age, about 500, detained for vetting. He said that some civilians had said that insurgent snipers had shot anyone trying to leave their homes. As US troops sweep through the houses, they are unearthing the insurgents’ horrifying secrets — more akin to the handiwork of psychotic serial killers than guerrillas or even terrorists — that have shocked the world and explain why this devastating offensive has met with so little opposition from the Arab world.

In the south of Fallujah yesterday, US Marines found the armless, legless body of a blonde woman, her throat slashed and her entrails cut out. Benjamin Finnell, a hospital apprentice with the US Navy Corps, said that she had been dead for a while, but at that location for only a day or two. The woman was wearing a blue dress and her face had been disfigured. It was unclear last night if the grisly remains were the body of the Irish-born aid worker Margaret Hassan, 59, or of Teresa Borcz, 54, a Pole abducted two weeks ago. Both were married to Iraqis and held Iraqi citizenship; both were kidnapped in Baghdad last month.

US and Iraqi troops have discovered kidnappers’ lairs filled with corpses or emaciated prisoners half-mad with fear, and piles of bodies of men who had refused to fight to the death with the insurgents. As the guerrillas run their last sprint from death, sympathy for their cause among Iraqis is rapidly running out.

**http://img128.exs.cx/img128/7199/bradley.jpg **


A BRADLEY FIGHTING VEHICLE.

**Deception and mass firepower were key to success **
**The Times (UK) **| 11/15/04 | Michael Evans

OPERATION DAWN, renamed by the Iraqi interim Government to offer the battered city of Fallujah hope of a better future, was a six-day battle. But its success was based on the message in the initial codename for the battle plan — Phantom Fury.

Twelve thousand troops from the 1st US Marine Division, 1st US Infantry Division and 1st US Cavalry Division, backed by fewer than 2,000 Iraqi national guardsmen, covered the length and breadth of the city under a complex plan that involved deception as well as mass firepower.

The Americans had learnt their lesson from the previous aborted attempt to seize control of Fallujah from the rebel insurgents and foreign terrorists in April. Then there were too few American troops and too many civilian casualties.

Six times as many troops were deployed for the second attempt, and hundreds of armoured vehicles were engaged in either encircling the city to confuse the enemy or sent down the narrow streets to launch blistering tank shell and artillery fire at any building or hideout from where masked and uniformed rebels were spotted firing their weapons. Although the rebel fighters, numbering some 3,000, had had since April to develop their defences and to prepare to take on the Americans, they were finally confronted with a plan that outwitted them.

US Marine Major-General Richard Natonski, who devised the ground attack, yesterday revealed one of the key ingredients of Operation Phantom Fury: several days before the start of the real attack, a large “invasion” force, with up to 200 armoured vehicles, carried out several “feint” attacks to the south of Fallujah, charging right up to the edge of the city in what is known as dynamic manoeuvres.

General Natonski said that these feint invasions confused the insurgents, who assumed that the attack was going to come initially from the south and built up their forces in that part of the city.

In fact, the main thrust of the invading force was made up of six battalions of US Army and Marine troops, punching through defensive lines across six points in the north of Fallujah. The feints to the south also forced insurgents to open fire from their secret bunkers, which immediately exposed them to bombing from the air and artillery fire.

Under General Natonski’s plan, which he said was followed to the letter (unusual in warfare where carefully laid plans are often disrupted by enemy counter-moves), another “pretend” attack was carried out on November 6, this time in the north. The real start date for the attack was at sunset a week ago.

General Natonski claimed that by last Monday evening Fallujah’s defending rebels were staying under cover because they were not sure whether the attack was about to begin or whether they were being tricked into coming out into the open again. “That’s kind of what we wanted, we desensitised the enemy to the formations they saw on the night we attacked,” he said.

Another key tactic was to choke off all exits from the city. Insurgents used mortars and machinegun fire to try to breach the outer ring to escape, but failed. However, the top leaders of the insurgents, including the terrorist chiefs linked to al-Qaeda — Abu Musab al-Zarqawi, Sheik Abdullah al-Janabi and Omar al-Hadid — appear to have vanished before fighting started.

In six days of total warfare in the streets of Fallujah, the Americans believe that they killed 1,200 insurgents, many of them foreigners from Iran, Chechnya, Saudi Arabia and other Arab countries.

By sunset on Saturday American tanks and armoured fighting vehicles had achieved their objective, penetrating the last rebel stronghold in the south and facing the final pockets of resistance from insurgents.

Thanks for taking the time to put together the updates. These are truly evil people that deserve no pity for what they have done.
“In the south of Fallujah yesterday, US Marines found the armless, legless body of a blonde woman, her throat slashed and her entrails cut out. Benjamin Finnell, a hospital apprentice with the US Navy Corps, said that she had been dead for a while, but at that location for only a day or two. The woman was wearing a blue dress and her face had been disfigured.”

Middle East - AP Bomb Labs, Hostages Found in Fallujah
Sun Nov 14, 5:27 PM ET

By EDWARD HARRIS, Associated Press Writer

FALLUJAH, Iraq - U.S. Marines have found beheading chambers, bomb-making factories and even one Iraqi hostage as they swept through Fallujah — turning up hard evidence of the city’s role in the insurgent campaign to drive American forces from Iraq Marines on Sunday showed off what they called a bomb-making factory, where insurgents prepared roadside explosives and car bombs that have killed hundreds of Iraqi civilians and U.S. troops.

Wires, cell phones, Motorola handheld radios and a Plastic foam box packed with C4 plastic explosives sat in the dark building down an alley, along with three balaclava-style masks reading: “There is only one god, Allah, and Muhammad is his messenger.” “It’s all significant because this is not the kind of stuff an average household has,” said Lt. Kevin Kimner, 25, of Cincinnati assigned to the 3rd Battalion, 5th Marines. “This is better than Radio Shack.”

So far U.S. troops have only found two hostages, one Iraqi and one Syrian. Marines last week found the Iraqi in a room with a black banner bearing the logo of one of Iraq’s extremist groups. He was chained to the wall, shackled hand and foot in front of a video camera. The floor was covered with blood. The rescued Syrian was the driver for two French journalists, Christian Chesnot and Georges Malbrunot, missing since August. The journalists have not been found, but France maintains they are still alive.

A Marine officer said he found signs that at least one foreign hostage was beheaded in that room. The Marine, who spoke on condition of anonymity, did not give details. The Iraqi hostage, who had been beaten on the back with steel cables, said his tormentors were Syrian and that he thought he was in Syria until the Marines found him, the Marine said. Other militants came and went, but “The Syrians were always in charge,” the Marine said.

The hostage was in a room — inside a compound that also had AK-47 rifles, improvised bombs, fake identification cards and shoulder-fired missiles that could down an airliner. Beneath it were tunnels running under the northern Jolan neighborhood. Marines said weapons depots were strategically placed throughout Jolan. Insurgents marked many of the caches with a piece of brick or rock, suspended from the buildings by a piece of string or wire.

U.S. officials hope that by retaking Fallujah they can deprive the rebels of an important headquarters and boost security in Iraq ahead of elections scheduled for January. Among the rebels’ most-fearsome weapons have been the car bombs and roadside explosives that have targeted military convoys but also churches and other areas where civilians gather.

On Sunday, a hollowed-out plastic foam container about the size of two shoe boxes lay in the bomb lab, packed with plastic explosives and wires. The plastic foam box was covered in cloth to disguise it as an innocuous package. Scattered on the ground nearby — cell phones, walkie-talkies, Motorola handheld radios — all used as detonators lay tangled in coils of wire. There was a computer without a hard drive and a box full of professional explosives-triggering.

“We’ve seen better,” Kimner said of the detonators. “But they’re reliable and they do the job right.” When Marines uncovered the lab in a Saturday sweep. Among the clutter were two wills, addressed to friends and family in Algeria.

“I will join my friends in heaven,” the will read. “Don’t cry for me. Celebrate my death.”

BK,

Thanks for the report. THe young sniper summed things up pretty well for anyone that couldmake the argument that we should not be over there killing these people.

“There’s pretty much no feeling,” the 24-year-old from Chicago explained, perched on the parapet of the house, the shell of the killer bullet tucked as a trophy into his flak jacket. “If I didn’t get that guy, that guy would get one of my buddies some time later down the line.”

Between that and the whole thing of dismembereing women? C’mon. These people (insurgents) deserve what they get. Every bit of it.

After seeing the destruction we have caused in Fallujah, and counting the 31 American deaths, all I can say is thank God Fallujah is “free.”

Imagine how much the residents will love us after seeing their city completely destroyed. I can just imagine they will treat us as liberators and there is no end to >the love they will shower us with.

What a great victory.

Sarcasm off.

I guess it just doesn’t pay to be an insurgent and kill hostages, and kill Iraqi’s trying to be free, and mulilate your own people who are trying to be free, and disembowel 60 year old female aid workers.

Perhaps THAT is the message…

More victories to come.

No, we usually wait until we have them in “jail” before we mock and disgrace them.

This whole thing is a big, huge mess. I’m not sure there are any “good guys” in this.

(No offense meant to our brave soldiers, who are only following orders.)

"More victories to come. "

And more towns to be turned into rubble.

The poem isn’t meant to be associated with the war itself, cool breeze. The poem is for the coalition troops who’ve given their lives, regardless of the reason for the war itself.

I’d expect you to know the difference. Have you served in the military, by the way? Just curious?

The people who have tortured others (whether the victims were Americans, Iraqis or anyone else) of course deserve whatever they get. Let’s make sure that we keep it clear in our minds, though, that not every person who lives in Fallouja is a torturer or “insurgent.” Accoringly, Casey’s point is a fair one. In other words, just because certain lowlife individuals hung some Americans from a bridge doesn’t necessarily mean it is justified, or even wise, to level the entire city of Fallouja. Son of Sam brutally murdered lots of victims in New York. The best response, however, was not bombing NYC.

Is the attack on Fallouja justified or wise? I have no idea. Given the situation we have put ourselves in, we probably don’t have any other options. That is very different from misplacing our anger on innocent Iraqis.

“1915 Please don’t ever associate this beautiful poem written by a Canadian hero with any Iraqi war. They aren’t even close to being comparable”

BK,

I’d just like to repeat what TnT posted to you. Repeat: Not even close to being comparable.

But I’ll still feel sense of sorrow for all lost in Iraq.

Ironically McCrae survived WWI but died of the flu epidemic just after the war.

Don’t make the mistake of taking pity here. It’s a different world. The same rules don’t apply…think about this: Did we display their burned remains dangling frm a bridge on CNN after we murdered them in an unprovoked attack?

No, but Marines executed at least one wounded man in front of an NBC crew…perhaps “ask Kevin Sites’ crew if they’re rolling on this” should be moved up in the ROEs…the Corps will definitely get this right for the 4th/5th Battle of Fallujah in early 2005.

http://story.news.yahoo.com/news?tmpl=story&cid=564&ncid=716&e=12&u=/nm/20041115/ts_nm/iraq_marine_shooting_dc

With all the wingnuts of The Room stroking it to McRae’s “In Flanders Field”…I got to wondering why it doesn’t bother them that we’re not burying our dead like we used to when the cause was a little better.

You’d think the soon to be democracy-loving, Wendy’s-eating folks of Fallujah would want neat little rows of crosses at a convienent location to remind future generations of exactly how many Armies of One Uncle Sam expended in his noble search for WMD/links to Al Qaeda/oil at $41 per barrel/oil at $44 per barrel/oil at $48 per barrel/OK, Fine, Democracy.

And I’m sure the generous chaps at Blackwater would give a scholarship to a Fallujah H.S. kid for keeping those merc graves stocked with fresh flowers and inspiration sayings about capitalism.

Yes, it is most troubling that we don’t think this cause is worth burying our fallen where they, uh, fall, because now the grateful people of Iraq will have to join the poor people of Vietnam and Lebanon (sorry, Haitians, no visas por vous) in coming to Washington, DC at their own expense to pay tribute to those who gave their last full measure of devotion in service to some shit about Freedom & Democracy that didn’t turn out so hot.

But, like the man said, freedom is untidy.

"No, but Marines executed at least one wounded man in front of an NBC crew…perhaps “ask Kevin Sites’ crew if they’re rolling on this” should be moved up in the ROEs…the Corps will definitely get this right for the 4th/5th Battle of Fallujah in early 2005. "

– I would hope that there is more to this report than meets the eye. If it turns out to be true it would be a shame. But I am certain that this is an isolated incident and not characteristic of the Marine Corps in general or any ROE’s. I think we all know better than that.

Kevin Sites, the journalist witness, says the Marine didn’t know the guy was a wounded prisoner and did not pose a threat. The Marine was contrite when told the fact. Chalk it up to the fog of war.

From NBC:

"NBC’s Kevin Sites, who witnessed the incident Saturday while assigned to represent a pool of news organizations, reported Monday that the man was shot by a Marine who appeared to be unaware that the Iraqi was a wounded prisoner and did not pose a threat…

“When told that the man he shot was a wounded prisoner, the Marine, who himself had been shot in the face the day before but had already returned to duty, told Sites: ‘I didn’t know, sir. I didn’t know.’” (Emphasis added.)

FALLUJAH, Iraq — The U.S. military is investigating the killing of a wounded and apparently unarmed Iraqi prisoner inside a mosque during combat operations here, the Defense Department told NBC News on Monday.

NBC’s Kevin Sites, who witnessed the incident Saturday while assigned to represent a pool of news organizations, reported Monday that the man was shot by a Marine who appeared to be unaware that the Iraqi was a wounded prisoner and did not pose a threat.

Bryan Whitman, a spokesman for the Defense Department, told NBC News that the military was investigating the incident observed by Sites. “We’re confident it will be a thorough investigation,” he said.

‘He’s faking!’
The incident occurred as a Marine battalion was taking part in a U.S.-led counteroffensive intended to secure Fallujah so national elections can go ahead in January as scheduled. Col. Michael Regner, operations officer for the 1st Marine Expeditionary Force in Fallujah, said Monday that the operation had secured control of the city.

Sites said the incident unfolded this way:

The Marine battalion stormed an unidentified mosque Saturday in southern Fallujah after taking casualties from heavy sniper fire and attacks with rocket-propelled grenades. Ten insurgents were killed and five others were wounded in the mosque and an adjacent building.

The Marines displayed a cache of rocket-propelled grenades and AK-47 assault rifles that they said the men were holding. They said the arms were conclusive evidence that insurgents had been using mosques as fighting positions in Fallujah, which they said made the use of force appropriate.

When the Marines left to advance farther south, the five wounded Iraqis, none of whose injuries appeared to be life-threatening, were left behind in the mosque for other Marines to evacuate for treatment.

Saturday, however, reports surfaced that mosques in the region had been reoccupied, including the mosque the Marine battalion had stormed the day before.

Two units that were not involved in Friday’s fighting advanced on the mosque, one moving around the back and the second, accompanied by Sites, from the front. Sites said he could hear gunfire from inside.

Sites was present when a lieutenant from one of the units asked a Marine what had happened inside the mosque. The Marine replied that there were people inside.

“Did you shoot them?” the lieutenant asked.

“Roger that, sir,” the second Marine replied.

“Were they armed?” the lieutenant asked.

The second Marine shrugged in reply.

Sites saw the five wounded men left behind on Friday still in the mosque. Four of them had been shot again, apparently by members of the squad that entered the mosque moments earlier. One appeared to be dead, and the three others were severely wounded. The fifth man was lying under a blanket, apparently not having been shot a second time.

One of the Marines noticed that one of the severely wounded men was still breathing. He did not appear to be armed, Sites said.

The Marine could be heard insisting: “He’s f—ing faking he’s dead — he’s faking he’s f—ing dead.” Sites then watched as the Marine raised his rifle and fired into the man’s head from point-blank range.

“Well, he’s dead now,” another Marine said.

When told that the man he shot was a wounded prisoner, the Marine, who himself had been shot in the face the day before but had already returned to duty, told Sites: “I didn’t know, sir. I didn’t know.”

Self-defense could be accepted
The Marine who shot the man was removed from the field and returned to headquarters. The investigation will address why the wounded men were left behind for 24 hours, why four of them were shot Saturday and whether the killing observed by Sites was illegal.

At the same time the incident was taking place in the mosque, a U.S. Marine was killed and five others were wounded when the booby-trapped body of a dead insurgent exploded. The judge advocate general heading the investigation of the mosque incident, Lt. Col. Bob Miller, told NBC News that depending on the evidence, it could be reasonable to conclude that the Marine was acting in self-defense.

“The policy of the rules of engagement authorize the Marines to use force when presented with a hostile act or hostile intent,” he said. “So they would have to be using force in self-defense, yes.”

But Miller added: “Enemy combatants — in this case, insurgents — who don’t pose a threat would not be considered a hostile.” NBC’s Kevin Sites in Fallujah, Iraq, and Jim Miklaszewski in Washington and MSNBC.com’s Alex Johnson contributed to this report. http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/6496898/