The thing is this: I guess I’m not at all surprised, only surprised that it took this long.
This country, as wonderful and successful as it is, really worships a couple of things: Success and image. It doesn’t really matter how such success is achieved, and frankly, the intervening years will allow for a lot of massaging of fundamentally immoral or simply bad behavior. But the fact of the matter is that those who conduct themselves admirably but are unsuccessful are rarely role models, and their opposites are worshipped as gods, no matter how many indiscretions they commit. Witness the Rockefellers, Kennedys, etc (a couple of other obvious names I won’t mention to avoid another OT rant). We make a show about Trump, who in reality is a pretty crappy manager, with a public company on the ropes, and a history of losing a crapload of money for banks stupid enough to lend to him and his “image”.
We all want the good life, and we tend to idolize those who achieve it, regardless of their personal failings. We are a results-oriented culture, and somewhere along the line the notion of process fell away. It disheartens me greatly and frankly makes me fear for the future of the democracy when I see statistics like 50% of college students have cheated, and somewhat more condone it because they simply must achieve, whatever “achieve” means. I never considered it an option, and the notion that it is common and acceptable behavior makes me nauseous.
What does this have to do with breast implants? Well, in a society that values results, what do breast implants have to do with results? Well, one could easily argue that breast implants bring more attention from men, and more attention from men with money and prospects, and are economically a good trade. That they have a primary or secondary impact of self-esteem boost is not insignificant either. And if the desired result is to bring more attention to oneself or land the right guy, then implants are the easy way there. The fact that they may create an adverse selection problem (attracting the wrong kind of guy, for instance, or attracting the kind of guy who cares about implants and will probably trade the woman in for a different model at some point) is of some consideration, but we’re not a culture known for our farsightedness, at least not now.
We worship the winners, and if its that easy to be a winner, why wouldn’t you do it? Well, if you cared about content, for one thing, you might consider it to be a strange self-distortion to subject yourself to. I know a lot of people with rhinoplasties here and other cosmetic procedures, and I’ve always tried to articulate why I personally have an antipathy towards the whole idea. I don’t like it, and I’ve been trying to find the words to justify it. I guess for me it seems unreal, which is a step in the wrong direction. If our lives are about contributing to the world, and being evaluated on our merits, and achieving something, does enough of an obsession with our bodies to pay somebody to cut it up count as a meaningless and stupid distraction? I suspect so. It’s so patently frivolous and teaches the wrong values about how to treat and judge people that I don’t what to do with it.
I’m sure a lot of people will say, “well, if it makes you happy.” I’m inclined to agree, but then I think, will it really make you happy? Or will it just allow you to treat other people as inadequate, quite in the way that you may felt yourself prior to this?
What’s equally interesting to me is that as a country, we are deeply hypocritical in terms of our consideration of values. In conjunction with the above, we can on one hand decry this self-mutilation in the service of our egos, while on the other hand we may consider absolute laissez-faire attitude in business to be ideal, despite the fact that same lack of “values” will result in disastrous results.
A bit scattered, I know, but just something I’m thinking about.