Open letter to Carlos Galvao:IM Brazil

Carlos,

Just returned from Brazil this week and wanted to offer some constructive criticism on the race this year. Undoubtedly, you've heard the complaints on the blatant, risk free drafting that occured on the bike course. The elimination of standard blocking, postitioning, and passing rules offered up near draft legal and unsafe conditions. If the winds had been what they were the year before collisions would have been inevitable. The less scrupulous took advantage of the new rules. The more honest (like myself) simply rode along demoralized by the increasing time gaps being created by the cheaters. There were huge groups of AG athletes packed together throughout the entire bike leg. These groups were easy to identify due to the many turnarounds etc. The lack of marshalling was unbelievable. On more than one occasion I witnessed marshalls simply riding alongside groups for extended periods of time and then just speeding away! It was almost as if a conspiracy had been set in motion. As for the pro race I witnessed an armada of vehicles surrounding, and protecting  Fernanda K from the wind throughout the bike leg. The use of media and support vehicles as wind protection should be regulated. Seasoned pros know how to take advantage of situations like this. I've done this race twice and seen it both times. 
 The water that was made available at the water stations wasn't in appropriate containers. I know the sponsor wanted to have their containers used, but those bottles don't fit in standard bottle cages. This made for treacherous and trashy conditions at the water stops as well as a logistical dilemma for the athletes. If one were to not have an aero water bottle mounted on their aerobars he/she was forced to do some crafty things with their own bottles to ensure proper hydration: unscrew cap of personal bottle, fill bottle, throw sponsor bottle and cap -- all within the confines of the aid station in order to keep from trashing the course. These measures on the move, in race mode, are quite risky. 
 The traffic cones were placed too close together on many stretches of road making the lanes too narrow. I know of one athlete who was crashed into while passing another that swirved to avoid a cone. He went home with a broken collarbone and a story to tell all his fellow athletes in San Diego. 

Two years in a row I’ve witnessed and experienced some unusual problems with bouy placement in the swim. There’s a story circulating online of one of the bouy’s being moved during the race. Whether this is true or not I don’t know. But it’s bad PR for the race regardless. Many participants from the pro’s down felt the second loop to be quite a bit longer than the first.
For the run, many I’ve spoken with were unhappy with the cobbled sections included. Personally I wasn’t bothered by this but I felt you would want to know.
I can’t compliment your course volunteers enough. They were absolutley the best! Where the race organization failed to meet expectations, the volunteers exceeded them by far. Their enthusiasm lasted throughout the entire day and kept many a tired athlete going.
Word has spread far and wide via the internet on the drafting issue. Many went home disgusted by it. The race has a reputation now that you should be aware of. I personally have a great affection for the race, it’s location in Floripa, and Brazil in general. It’s likely I’ll return again and again. It’s for this reason, and the knowledge of your desire to make this race the top dog among the many international Ironman races, that I felt compelled to inform you of the above stated inconsistencies. Good luck with your other ventures and I hope to see you again next year.

Sincerely,
Keith Pillers

Good and constructive insights not only for race management but for people considering the event in the future as well.

Thanks Keith.

Keith, I am in full agreement with your comments, as we discussed after the rae itself. I have heard from a number of people including BOPers that Fernanda was not onl protected by the vechicles but had "un-numbered riders with her that forced other riders out of the way, handed her drinks outside of the sid stations etc.

I was astounded that people did not take advantage of the grass and pavements alongside the worse of the broken up paved sections on the run as I went past on said grass etc.

As you stated the helped were unparalleled in my experience all bottles were passed up to me on the bike by staff that has clearly been briefed correctly.

& well the entertainment at the pasta party! A good reason to go by it’s self!

Francois, is that a 3 foot gap? Or 3 minutes?

One is impressive the other not so! :wink:

I considered mentioning that but since I didn’t actually see it I left it alone. Another thing I found ineresting is the helmet Galindez wore. He picked up one of those illegal Rudy Project aero shells at the expo and wore it during the race! Nobody said a thing. I talked with Bustos about it the next day and he didn’t know those helmets were illegal, just unsafe. Maybe UCI regulations take time to hit down there.

Thanks for the tip on the travel plans thread.

-K

“how the hell do you close a 3’ gap in 20km to a guy riding 40km/h in an IM?”

You ride 44 km/h…

The reply…

Hi Keith,

Thanks for your email.

I’m aware of the problems that you mentioned on your note.

This year, for us, it was a tremendous challenge putting up the race. As you
participated the previous years, you realized the big change, the upgrade that
we did with the race.

You have my personal commitment to ensure that we’ll solve the problems for the
2005 race.

Thanks again for your email and we keep in touch.

Best regards,

Carlos

Those helmets were and are standard practice at time trials in Brazil, regardless of what the UCI rules say. In at least two 2.5 and one 2.3 ranked UCI races, all the top brazilian contenders wore illegal helmets. The officials checking equipment before the race didn’t seem to care - I ended up racing with a shell as well.
I had however never heard of such in a triathlon event, lest of all the IM Brazil which, from my triathlete training partners, was always regarded as a well-run race. Interesting to know all that was going on…