I almost went the pizza route as well. The only thing that stopped me was supreme is a collection of topping, whereas the rest are individual toppings. That and I’m sure we’ve had the debate in the LR already, but a little voice in my head said pineapple doesn’t belong on pizza.
This is the first time I recall getting one word from each different category as my mistake. Usually, it’s three words that go together and one that doesn’t. It did make getting the rest of the puzzle easier.