Nowhere to Run: The Death of Moderation and Why the Republicans may Win Back the House in 2010

Some food for thought, my worthy friends. Just some musings on a very hot and very steamy southeast Michigan day (I have **got **to find something to do with myself ;-):

Democratic Senator Arlen Specter and Republican Representative Mike Castle of Delaware must feel like they’re caught in a bizarre nightmare not of their own making. In fact, everywhere a political moderate in the legislative branch looks these days, he’s liable to run across other politicians, constituents or special interest groups who aren’t interested in “a middle way” as a means of delivering responsive government.

No, what folks like Specter and Castle are hearing from the more “ideologically pure” elements in each party are accusations of selling out and, basically, of sleeping with the enemy, in a political sense. For a fact, former-Republican Specter received a dose of what passes for reasoned discourse these days when he and Department of Health and Human Services Secretary Kathleen Sebelius caught the brunt of the anger and emotion emanating from a crowd of citizens at a recent town hall, when Specter unknowingly stepped onto the land mine which is today known as “health care reform.”

As for a person like Mike Castle, a man with a distinguished history of public service in the State of Delaware and a solid record of bipartisanship in the U.S. House, well…he seems to be part of an increasingly rare species in that chamber; that of the so-called Parcus politician (“moderate politician”). F&M Politics writers Terry Madonna and Michael Young have an interesting piece in yesterday’s Real Clear Politics that highlights the quandary in which a politician like Specter now finds himself.

Beset by the more hard-right elements in his former party – where he was regularly vilified as a “Republican in Name Only” (RINO) – and facing a primary challenge from former House member, and admitted conservative, Pat Toomey (who he barely turned away in the 2004 primary) – Specter earlier this year switched parties and declared he’d be running as a Democrat in the 2010 primary.

Certainly part of the Pennsylvania senator’s motivations can be ascribed to a purely political calculation. Most experts agree he’d have never made it out of the Republican primary against Toomey, who proudly carries the flag of doctrinaire rightwing conservatism.

But another factor that most likely played a part in Specter’s sudden switch was his desire to continue occupying a middle area in the Senate where both Republican and Democratic moderates like Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins of Maine and Ben Nelson and Max Baucus – of Nebraska and Montana, respectively – easily intermingle.

This commingling is readily apparent, and all of them strive to meet regularly with the aim of coming to consensus and then delivering legislation which they honestly believe to be in the best interest of *all *Americans, not just those from one wing or another in their respective political parties.

Unfortunately, these worthy legislators are themselves experiencing something akin to what Yeats wrote when he said “Things fall apart; the centre cannot hold…“ Sadly, at least when it comes to the political atmosphere in the United States lately, the Irish poet was more prescient than he knew. The “best” (the “head people,” or intellectuals) seem to lack all conviction while the worst (“the mob”) seem to have the whip hand, reacting from a sense of passionate intensity and little real intelligence, much of which can be gained only from a regimen of careful intellectual study and expression.

What is apparent during this vigorous debate over health care reform is that sides are being chosen and that there also seems to be no happy medium where classic moderates from either party can exist. By now, most politically astute observers have noted how White House Chief of Staff Rahm Emanuel, during his time as a House Democratic leader, managed to recruit a number of moderate-to-conservative Democrats to run against Republicans in historically conservative districts which seemed to be ripe for a message of change.

Certainly, this message was well-received, especially after several years of Republican mismanagement and fiscal irresponsibility in the Congress led people to realize that the political party in power at the time (Republicans) really wasn’t worthy of keeping that power.

Into that breach poured a number of fiscally conservative and socially moderate new Democrats. Election results in 2006 – in the wake of President George W. Bush’s missteps on Hurricanes Rita and Katrina and his failed attempt at selling social security reform (an entitlement program that, along with Medicare and Medicaid, is called “the third rail of politics” for a very good reason…touch it and you die) – saw significant Democratic gains in the Congress.

The coup de grace was delivered in last year’s presidential election, when large Democratic majorities in the House and (eventually) the Senate resulted. Republicans are still stinging over the seeming repudiation of their philosophy by an electorate that was intrigued by a promise of post-partisan political reconciliation along with a message of racial comity and healing.

And therein lays the rub. For what seemed a long-lasting and glorious ascendancy in which a real majority of Americans had finally settled on one direction now seems to have been nothing more than a slight facial tic; once there, now not there. This is unfortunate on many different levels. In the main, it seems both parties have hardened their respective positions to an even greater degree since the presidential inauguration last January.

Perhaps some of this is the fault of a new president (Barack Obama) who appears to have curiously outsourced the development of certain vital pieces of legislation, including an economic stimulus package that is composed mostly of pent-up liberal “wish list” type spending (only 6% of the total amount appropriated is actually going towards infrastructure improvement) and a series of health care reform bills in the Democrat-dominated House (acknowledged by most observers to be far more passionate and partisan) that most legislators and citizens are having a difficult time understanding.

This lack of understanding – House legislators home on recess and confronted by a myriad of questions they’re still ill-equipped to answer – is beginning to create in the minds of a certain portion of the electorate an impression that, this time, Democrats don’t seem to have the best interests of the majority of Americans at heart.

This fickle segment of the electorate is, of course, the so-called “independent voter.” The Independent showed itself in full plumage last October, when solid majorities swung decisively toward Democratic candidates in the Congress and also for the presidency, where Barack Obama gained the support of traditional Democratic blocs (minorities, labor unions and the like, but who lost the majority of seniors to John McCain) and those crucial independents. It is worth noting that those professed unaffiliated voters gave Democrats the victory in 2006 and 2008.

Trouble looms on the horizon for the Democratic Party, though, if recent trends in independent voter opinions hold steady. A series of recent polls show support for Mr. Obama and congressional Democrats among this bloc of voters consistently dropping. The most recent Rasmussen generic ballot shows that support for Republican congressional candidates has risen to its highest level in the last several years.

For six weeks in a row, the out-of-power party has maintained upwards of a 5 percentage point lead (43% to 38%) in a Republican versus Democratic matchup, district by district. Now, is somebody like Nancy Pelosi or Barney Frank in any danger whatsoever of tasting defeat at the polls, come November of 2010? Of course not.

But what’s certain is that a lot of moderate-conservative Democrats who ran in 2006 and 2008 on a series of policy differences with their more liberal (and far more numerous) colleagues in the House are glancing nervously at the public reaction to health reform and at their own districts, many of which were won by Republican John McCain in 2008.

And it is these Democrats, and the popular disaffection (whether warranted or not) for Democratic policies and recent legislation that may hold the key to a Republican overthrow of Democratic rule in the House. Currently, a majority of likely voters feel that the economic stimulus hasn’t, as yet, worked nor are they happy with carbon cap-and-trade legislation and also don’t seem all that concerned with controlling emissions of that gas in the first place. Add to that an inability by many House members to even begin to be explain what health reform may or may not be able to do, and the party in power could come in for popular voter backlash next year.

Is this the fault of those moderate-conservative Democrats? Certainly not. For the most part, they’re at minimum extremely queasy about certain of the provisions contained within the most popularly-known bill to pass out of committee (H.R. 3200), and will be trying mightily to avoid being caught up in yet another forced vote for something which majorities in many of their districts do not support.

Sadly, those mod-con Democrats don’t really have the guns to go up against the House Progressive Caucus, which is helmed by liberal northern California representative Lynn Woolsey, a close political ally of House Speaker Nancy Pelosi. In reaction to the expression of unease by a number of moderate Democrats to the health reform bill, Woolsey and her coalition issued a statement in which clear battle lines on this issue – which is of extreme importance to the more liberal wing in the House – have been drawn. “Fail to support it at your peril,” was the basic thrust of the California congresswoman’s message.

Caught betwixt and between, a goodly number of freshman or sophomore Democratic legislators in the House could end up on the outside looking in come 2010, especially if popular discontent with Democratic policies continues to grow among independents. While Barack Obama himself remains personally popular, dissatisfaction with his seeming left-wing agenda (whether or not that itself is true is open for legitimate debate) has been increasing at a measured pace among certain blocs of voters.

And what bloc of voters turns out in consistently high numbers? Seniors, of course, who cast ballots at a rate exceeding 60 or more percent in election after election. According to the U.S. Census, voters 18-24 actually improved their voting rate to 49%, which was a 2-point increase over 2004. Citizens 45-64 and 65 years of age and older voted at far greater rates, though, at 69 and 70 percent, respectively. Imagine a legion of upset seniors, looking to punish those who they deem to have been responsible for “stealing their healthcare.” It would be a fairly ugly site to many a House Democrat. Now, is the way this narrative is being framed in any way fair or reasonable? Again, of course not.

But nobody ever said life was either fair or equitable, and it is also well-known that (as former House Speaker Thomas P. “Tip” O’Neill once observed) “All politics is local.” Barack Obama did a magnificent job in overseeing a presidential campaign rightly celebrated for its efficiency, organization and ability to stay on message and ahead of the news cycle.

His curious decision, however, to leave much of the task of crafting several pieces of legislation which are near-and-dear to liberal hearts (climate change and health reform) and then his and the Democrats’ ongoing failure to especially sell what they say are health reform’s great benefits (lower cost, greater access) could doom the party to a return to minority status and a stay in the same wilderness Republicans once had no hope of escaping for quite some time.

Chaucer (who was one of several noted writers to use the phrase) famously said that “Time and tide wait for no man.” It would seem that Mr. Obama has taken this injunction to heart in seeking to push through what he hopes will be his signal piece of legislation. He must hope, though, that those tides are propitious and not of a type that will engulf the very tiny skiff in which a certain type of politician (the moderate-to-conservative Democrat) now finds himself cleaving to so desperately.

T.