Newton Running Shoe review

I had read a number of articles regarding Newton shoes in the weeks prior to IMAZ. At the race expo, Newton had set up a demonstartion area where you could take a pair for a run around. I gave them a spin and found them…very interesting. For more info on their history, design, and claimed benefits, visit there web site:
http://newtonrunning.com/

I read a number of different reviews and opinions of some of the very early adopters, ranging from they feel great to those who couldn’t run a mile without pain. A local triathlete friend also bought a pair at IMAZ and has been running in them for over a month. He likes them, and ran what for him was an impressive 10K for him at a race we did 2 weeks ago. My concern looking at his shoe’s was that they seemed very worn already.

So I decided to hold off buying these as the jury was clearly out, but I made the error of mentioning them to my mom, who promptly bought herself and me a pair. I purchsed the men’s Gravity Trainer:
http://www.newtonrunning.com/shoe.php?s=001

So, what do you get for $175 beans! They arrived with a nice carry bag, orange and white laces, a pair of Newton socks, and a nice headsweat cap! I will be going for an hour run tomorrow, so stay tuned!

INITIAL RUN REVIEW

“Preceptions vs. Realities”

Run Data- 1:00:00, 8.38 miles, 7:08 pace, 148HR
My run this morning in the Newtons was on a rec path along a canal her near my office. It is very flat, with a few short, steep up and downs into pedestrian tunnels to cross under a few roads. My heart rate is at the high end of my aerobic training zone, so from an effort standpoint, this is my normal exertion for a 60min run.

The first 2 miles in the Newtons felt very different, but not as I had expected. They felt much less cushioned than my Nike Haywards and somewhat stiff and flat. I did not feel any sense of forward assist from the lug system in the forefoot, although I’m not sure why I thought I would. I concentrated on maintaining a high 80-90 cadence and ran without my iPod so I could listen to my feet. When I run, I always try and land lightly and immediately scrap my foot back propelling me forward. If I can hear that slight scraping sound, I know I am imparting momentun forward and not wasting it by bouncing up. As I am not a heel striker by nature, so the running on my toe’s concept is something I always try and do, so again the shoe’s positioning wasn’t noticeabley different. My initial perception was that I wasn’t running as fast as I thought.

As the run progressed and I warmed up and lossened up, things began to change. First was when I came to the first pedestrian underpass. These shoes feel great running down hill. Suddenly the shoe geometry really kicked in for me and keeping my stride short, your turnover increases and you can really fly down a hill with less pounding caused by making the mistake of overstriding the downhills. Then when it came time to climb back up to the path…OH MY GOD! These shoe’s are a revolution in hill climbing! It has never felt so effortless climbing. Suddenly I was really up on my toes and I absolutley flew up the hill. Now, I run hills all the time and consider myself a strong hill climber but this felt profoundly different in a very good way.

As I came into the last 2 miles, I began to be able to put it all together. What I preceived as flat and less cushioned was actually me completely eliminating any bounce in my stride. Sometimes I think I can fool myself into thinking I’m moving quickly when I start to get a little bouncey when in reality, I’m wasting time and energy moving up and down and not forward. The shoes were forcing me to push myself forward with every step. They felt very efficient in providing me with the correct mechanics to maintain good form and running economy. Whereas my initial perception was that I didn’t feel that much different, the reality was that I was running very differently. Whereas before I porbably only held perfect form when I though about it, now it seemed I was doing it without the same mental effort and not slipping into old, bad habits.

Post run, my legs didn’t feel as fatigued from the normal pounding of a good hard run. Again, I attribute this to the shoes preventing me from engaging in the poor form of bouncing too much. My quads and calves feel a little more tired as they have been engaged in a different way, but nothing very noticeable. I will be very curious to get out and run a more varied elevation run.

So my first impression is very favorable. $175 worth of favorable? More testing will tell. I will continue to update this thread, so keep an eye on it!

Thanks for the review. Mine are still sitting in a box waiting to be tested. Hope it goes as well as yours!

Again, the jury is still way out. These are going to have to really impress me if they are going to come with me to Kona in October.

all this from a shoe??? what is so special about them? What is inside the shoes that teach you all that stuff???Everything you describe about the biomechanic and good form is very important but that is something a good coach should teach you and that you should practice every signle run as turn over. I run with the Nike Hayward for all my training and racing so i m interested in your comments. I think the hayward is such a nice shoes already…but to have a good turn over, lean forward, keep the arm swing at 90 degres short and quick, head up and pelvis forward and you get the same results with the 50$ nike hayward??? There is something i dont understand here…

one more question…what kind of runner are you…weight wise, time wise for open 10km and triathlon times? just to give me a idea …from your pace for hour long run… i think you most probably be already a pretty good runner…

When I was a high school kid in the mid-70’s there were these new odd looking shoes that came out that were all the rage - called “Earth Shoes”. The idea was they would change the way you walked and had a neat image of a human that looked like a slumped over ape as of the marketing campaign.

The implied message that “you were a caveman if you didn’t buy these shoes”, was successful for a while, and the shoes are still sold today. Typically embraced by the same people who wear Birkenstocks. They call this a “Negative Heel” concept, which is claimed to be beneficial for posture, body alignment, etc…

For the most part, the shoes went the way of other 70’s fads such as Pet Rocks and Mood Rings.

While time will tell what happens with Newtons, I would be cautious of Athletic endorsements, and wonder how long many of these people will continue to run in them.
One thing I would ask about any Pro who endorses them is how many stock options or other compensation they have with the company. Follow the money.

Bottom line is, I think I will proceed with caution until enough un-biased data is recorded. While they may be great for some, slight changes in bio-mechanics can have deleterious results for others.

one more question…what kind of runner are you…weight wise, time wise for open 10km and triathlon times? just to give me a idea …from your pace for hour long run… i think you most probably be already a pretty good runner…

Hey Jonnyo! I was the guy who said hello to you and Sergio in Transition on Saturday before IMAZ. I’m 5’10", 156. I can run an open marathon of 2:59, I have run an open 8K @ 29:00, I’m a 2:03 Olympic, 4:20 Half, and 9:43:42 at IMAZ.
I love my Haywards. I will be very reluctant to give up on them, believe me. The Netwons certainly felt different, but as I said in my post, I’m still very unsure if there is that much benefit if you are already an efficient runner. I will contimnue to put in some miles with them and report back. Go check out their web site and you can read their “claims”.

Folker, I remeber Earth shoe’s too! Your post is exactly how I feel, so any comments I make will be brutally honest. I have no dog in this fight. :slight_smile:

keep us posted…from your time…you most definitly have some good running form to make these times… will be interesting to see if in the long run, you feel any technical gain from the shoe? I guess it s always a good idea to be open to now idea and see if there is something to gain!

but I made the error of mentioning them to my mom, who promptly bought herself and me a pair.

My mom could learn a thing or two from this post…

but I made the error of mentioning them to my mom, who promptly bought herself and me a pair.

My mom could learn a thing or two from this post…

Uh, I kind of took that post as legonis wanting to have a pair if his/her mom went out buying them. Sounded like a harmless response, anyway.

My bad, sorry.

Calm the F down and learn to read.

I did not read his post as anything negative either. Want to know how I can get my mom to buy me a pair of those
shoes to try,

Dave

Dude, are you serious? He didn’t even say anything about your mom. He said HIS mom could learn something from your post- like, I don’t know, how to plunk down $175 to buy him a pair of shoes. Settle down.

Besides, yo momma wears combat boots, not Newtons.

I stand corrected. I see what he was saying. My apologies Legonis, and yes, my mother wears combat boots.

Nice recovery!!!

Dave

Ha, I apparently am too late to see the action part !!! But no worries, as people said I meant that I wish my mom would buy me those shoes and on a more serious note I wish I had more family support about my training. They think I am over doing it.

The shoes sound very promising. I’ll be interested to know what kind of race results you get with them–particularly some before/after race comparisons.

Since they’re expensive and appear to wear out rather quickly, I wonder whether one might reserve them for speedwork sessions and races and still get most of the benefit?