My legs quit before my engine does. Is this training block built for the wrong limiter?

Hello,

I am 39M, 76 kg. Self-taught swimmer of four years, runner before that; this year two sprints, one Olympic, and first 70.3 in August as my A race. No youth sport, no natural endurance talent.

Last year: self-built high volume, mostly easy plus some threshold/sweet spot. Biggest weeks 14-20 h; Garmin VO2max went 52.6 to 59.1 by August. After the race it dropped to 55.3 and I felt muscularly maxed out. HR is fine at easy and threshold efforts, the legs just won’t hold the numbers.

I tried a plain HIIT block weeks (four VO2max sessions on the bike) but my legs didn’t hold up.

Now I use Stöggl & Sperlich’s 2014 polarized study loosely — they only ran and rode, I keep three swims. A deload/test week, three working weeks (12:55, 14:20, 14:45 planned), then a deload week ending in a local 10 km race. And repeating it, ending with a test week

Week:

- Mon: long ride 2:30-3:00 at 60% FTP (long easy)

- Tue: easy swim, plus optional easy run (recovery)

- Wed: hard run, 4x4 min at ~4:11/km, 3 min jog (Vo2max)

- Thu: easy run 60-70 min (easy)

- Fri: easy ride 2:00-2:20 at 60% FTP plus a swim (long easy)

- Sat: hard ride, 3x11-13x30/15 at 120-130% FTP (Vo2max)

- Sun: long hilly run 1:45-2:00 plus an easy swim (long)

All rides indoors, ERG, about 95% aero. Full week-by-week plan and session data, kept current: https://triathlon-trainingblock.vercel.app/

Test week: 262 W for 20 min → FTP 249 W. 5 km TT 21:22 (goal 20:50).

Expectations after 9 weeks: 5 km at 20:30, FTP up 3-5% (257-261 W) off two VO2max sessions plus easy volume for the legs to catch up.

Pick these apart:

1. Will increasing Vo2Max help with muscular limiter and am I hitting the same limiter twice with the 30/15s and the 4x4?

2. Is 60% FTP too easy for the easy rides if the legs are the limiter? My instinct says more time at 70-75%, but this might cook me. Priority of easy days protecting the hard days?

3. Three loading weeks from 12:55 to 14:45 with no recovery week, instead of the 2/1 week ratio from the study okay?

4. Should I add some progression within the session (longer, harder) over the weeks or keep them the same workload?

5. Is 4% off my 5 km plus 3-5% FTP gains realistic based on such a polarized trainingsblock that aims to increase Vo2max?

Blunt feedback welcome.

When I hear “legs won’t hold the numbers” when referencing a HR that seems ideal………….screams fatigue to me.

2 Likes

If you feel muscularly limited, I would consider taking out some endurance intensity and adding super basic strength training and plyometrics for the offseason, then back that off to the lowest possible maintenance of the strength training when you’re ramping up for races (~1.5 workouts per week, dropped the number of sets). I would also consider, again because of what you’ve said about muscular limitation, alternating the bike VO2 between your 13x30/15 and more traditional straight blocks of VO2 effort such as 6x3min (with some sort of progression, maybe working up to 3 sets of 3x3min or even 8x4min). They may not look as good in the research, but they do provide a different muscular stimulus.

Personally, I also like to go often closer to 70% FTP for endurance because the volume you’re doing is solid already, but I expect you can build more muscular endurance (“durability” is the new term being used for this very old concept) by doing that. You have to be pretty careful not to dig a hole and be willing to do a rest day if you really feel it after a long one. I think it’s also possible that some sweet spot training could do wonders for you. I know that’s a dirty word these days with “polarized” training being the only way to get fit, but I’ve always found it highly effective.

Finally: do not do it all at once. Pick one thing that seems compelling and give it a shot for 4-6 weeks. Strength training is what I’m doing for myself first, and I have zero doubt it will be worth it.

1 Like

I see:

1.) Zero off days. Likely not recovered enough to go as hard as you need to go on hard days.

2.) All rides on ERG. Maybe you have not trained yourself to push the power when you have to be the one pushing it.

3.) Maybe FTP is inflated. How did you test the 20 minute? Did you do a full gas 5 minute before you did the 20 minute? If not, FTP is likely inflated.

2 Likes

From what you describe, I would not automatically assume VO2max is your main limiter. When your legs fatigue before your cardiovascular system, accumulated fatigue and insufficient muscular endurance could both be contributing factors.

I would recommend a few adjustments to your training plan.

First, I would keep one VO2max session on the bike and one harder running session per week, provided you recover well. For cycling, I would also consider including longer sustained intervals, such as 3 × 12 min at 90–95% FTP, to develop your ability to maintain power.

Second, 60–70% FTP is perfectly fine for easy rides. Increasing everything to 70–75% could simply add fatigue without improving the quality of your harder sessions.

Third, with your current fatigue, I would favour 2 loading weeks followed by a recovery week. Gradually increase interval duration rather than intensity and volume simultaneously.

Finally, your FTP and 5 km improvement targets are possible, but I would focus on recovery and consistent training quality rather than chasing specific numbers.

I hope you find my input useful!

1 Like

Thanks a lot for your answers.
@redcloud I have chosen the short Vo2 intervals just based on the study results that they provide more time in the correct HR region and should give a higher Vo2 stimulus. In that HIIT block I mentioned and I tried, I did 5x5min at 108% FTP and on the last two the legs fell apart and I was fighting to do them at around 104% FTP. Considering that I plan to have 6 Vo2max Session during the block. Changing them weekly with some progression might be an option.

Can you recommend any good resources considering strength training, especially for somebody starting it? With strength training I never know on which day they should be done. On a hard day like AM: normal workout, PM: strength training or on an easy/recovery day. My experience with some lower body strength excercises on an easy day was that the performance in the hard workouts suffered.

To bootsie_cat:
Thats why I thought doing the endurance rides on the easy side to manage recovery better. 20min FTP test was the standard protocol of ramping up first, little easy, then 5min between 110-120% of old FTP estimate, 5min easy and then starting the 20min effort.

@coachlykkeendurance Considering the different week structure, would the harder run session be something in the threshold/tempo? For the last training blocks I did some kind of sweetspot bike session on the region of 90-95% FTP with progression from 3x10, 4x10, 3x15 which worked well even on double days. Thats why I thought I need to include more work over my threshold to get the legs used to pushing more power.
The improvement targets are some kind of guidelines for me to answer the questions if the block did have any positive effect. So I can decide afterwards to do it again or not.

out of interest what is your actual goal. getting Garmin to tell you that your vo2 max is hitting 60. improving your ftp , or your 5 k time , or be best over 70.3 ?

@pk
Longterm goal is to peak in next August to do the same 70.3 as fast as possible. Thats the A-race. I guess that all the other things, better Vo2max, FTP and running performance over 5km will be indicators on the way to see if the path I am going is working. During the year I will do some other events too but performance on these events are more like good markers and tests

Yes, exactly. By a harder running session, I meant a controlled tempo or threshold workout rather than another VO2max session. For example, 3 × 8–10 min around threshold pace with 2–3 min easy recovery.

Regarding cycling, your previous sweet spot progression makes good sense. Since you have already responded well to those sessions, I understand why you want to introduce more work above FTP.

I would recommend replacing one sweet spot session with something like 5 × 3 min at 110–115% FTP, with 3 min recovery. This provides a stronger VO2max stimulus without necessarily increasing your overall training load.

However, feeling limited by your legs does not automatically mean you need more intensity. Muscular endurance and accumulated fatigue could still be contributing factors.

And I completely agree with using FTP and 5 km improvements as benchmarks. I would also evaluate whether you can sustain higher power for longer and recover better between sessions. Those improvements are just as valuable when assessing whether the training block worked:

I hope my answers make sense.

energy system optimisation for 5 k and for a 70.3 is rather different , and of course a high v02 max is a good currency ( well garmin estimated vo2 max is like holding monopoly money in your hands … so its close to useless currency but that is a different subject, but what I will say is of you dont understand that it shows you still need a lot to learn )
so I guess your first job is to actually understand how garmin cant estimate vo2 max correctly.
the next job for you is that actually think what are your long term goals , and if you have a real long term goal focus first on going faster and then over years on longer.
and if it is a one and done 70.3 than you need to think how you can be the most efficient for 70,3 in a short time . ie 2 very different plans.

Vo2Max training is not productive long term. Much more performance to be extracted from threshold.

@pk What would you use as a proxy for Vo2max? Would you recommend a lab test once or twice a year to check if training blocks are building the targeted blocks? I thought that 5k times and some smart watch estimate helps me as a proxy guidance.

@Pguard Dont you think that trying to pull up the LT2 (via Vo2max work) should be done at some point in the season instead of only pushing it up from the bottom?

Sounds like you need a new bike and a new pair of shoes.

1 Like

It has its place but gains taper very quickly and it’s an intensity that generates a lot of low level fatigue. Threshold is much more sustainable, trainable and relevant to race pace.

Beginners used to read Joe Friel’s Triathlon Training Bible back in the day, and use ready plans (from Trainingpeaks or Matt Fitzgerald’s book).

I do think you could benefit from both, even though technically you’re no longer a beginner.

I think you are doing fine.

It can be harder to get the heart rate into vo2 max zone on the bike especially with longer intervals. I can only get mine up there in short intervals on the bike and it’s still lower than my average heart rate for an entire standalone half marathon!

My hr goes highest in swimming, it’s way higher than what I see on the bike and a little higher than the run for similar perceived effort. Cycling gives the most leg agony though on the intervals.

Don’t use the same heart rate metrics for all 3 disciplines. Cycling hr does tend to be lower and especially when the intervals are longer.

Paraphrasing Dr. Philip Skiba - “Shorter intervals are easier because they are easier.”

In my very limited experience, longer intervals at slightly lower power with the goal of accumulating time above a certain heart rate (i.e., 4x4min >90% of max HR) yielded more VO2max response.

Staple workouts by Bret Sutton are 25 minutes at 2% incline in the treadmill and 25 minutes all out at 0%. For the bike 15 min easy, 15 min moderate, 15 min medium, 15 min all out. That’s real strength endurance relevant for triathlon distances. 4X4 and 30/15 are good for a month.

Great Skiba quote. Skiba’s book is quite good, as well as his interviews on That Triathlon Show podcast (w/ @mikaeleriksson ).

I always like these types of threads, enjoy the responses so far on this one, and will just offer two things:

  1. Referencing the goals and timeline for the OP, I tend to think about Gordo Byrn’s 1000 day horizon idea and the concept of compounding gains over time through consistency. Sounds like you’ve done a lot of running, 4 years into swimming, but relatively new to cycling. If that is correct, then sure, play with different training blocks and sessions, but also maybe just keep doing the basic work and give your legs time (multiple training cycles/seasons) to more fully adapt to cycling and they’ll come around? It reminds me too of high school XC runners I used to coach who would improve, plateau, sometimes regress, and then in their 3rd or 4th season see the consistency pay off with a whole new level.

  2. Referencing the idea of fatigue that was introduced in various replies: 14-20 hour weeks can be a lot of volume for a person with a regular life and it sounds like you ramped up to that fairly quickly. Maybe you dealt with it for awhile but it just caught up to you. Life/work impact on recovery can make a big different at those levels. Going back to Gordo, even when he documented his return to tri 10 years after his elite career, jumping to that volume range within a year, even with mostly easy bike volume, put him in a serious hole that took him awhile to get out of.

1 Like

14-20 hour weeks would put me in hospital.

1 Like