rroof and I had an, um, discussion of this in an earlier thread…
here’s my take, FWIW:
I’ve had neuromas in both feet since 1974…
What’s worked well for me is a trick Johnny Halberstadt at the Boulder Running Co. showed me: cut a small circle of orthopaedic felt and stick it to the bottom of the inner of the shoe, just behind the metatarsals. It usually takes a few tries with each new pair of shoes to get the pad situated just right, but once it’s there, it lifts and separates the metatarsals and relieves the pressure on the neuroma. This helps with the pain and helps prevent further damage.
Placement of the pads is critical - this is why any consumer product except a custom orthotic probably won’t work. Doing it yourself allows for cheap trial-and-error until the pads are exactly right.
I tried some expensive custom orthotics, but they didn’t work as well as the pads, so junked them. I looked into surgery, but the anecdotal evidence I have so far is that of 9 surgeries, 5 of them re-grew the neuroma in less than 2 years. That doesn’t sound like worthwhile odds to me. Several doctors whose opinion I respect do recommend the surgery as an option, however.
it’s critical to have plenty of room in the toe box of ALL your shoes, running, bike, and work/casual. Compression of the metatarsals is a factor in this injury. Make sure to get running shoes with excellent forefoot cushion, that’s the primary characteristic I look for these days; and replace them often. Try running on softer surfaces - grass, dirt roads, or synthetic tracks. Concrete is a terrible surface to run on…
Also, be careful of running with the pain. Last year, I didn’t put the pads in a new pair of racing shoes, and consequently tore a calf muscle because I was compensating for the neuroma pain by altering my pushoff. Stupid stupid stupid.
I use these inserts in all my work and casual shoes:
http://www.footsmart.com/Product.aspx?ProductId=96&cmx=Y