Self righteous? Or just willing to point out fallacies when they present? Somatotypes are junk psychology, well disproven by science.
Science has no dealings with this crap. Profiling of athletic trends is science and vastly different, if you can understand it.
Or does it just hurt to have your preconceived fallacies busted?
Wow. Congratulate yourself much?
As much as I tend to avoid back-and-forths with posters who are both anonymous and snarky, I’ll give you my POV, FWIW: There are numerous unproven methods/schemata/whatever that still possess enough merit to persist despite a lack of incontrovertible, double-blind, placebo controlled, scientific proof. Two examples in medicine are the use of pulse oximetry to monitor the oxygen saturation of a surgical patient, or tocometry to monitor women in labor. They persist, because everyone involved knows they’re useful. Anyone who attempts to accomplish anything in the real world will eventually run into the necessity to avail themselves of less than Category I-A evidence in order to accomplish pretty much anything, and this is likely why the use of somatotypes continues.
This is why I find somatotypes to be a useful, albeit limited, model:
–Some people appear to put on muscle easier than others, given the same stimulus. I’m one of them.
–Some people put on fat easier than others. I may or may not be one of them.
–Some people seem to be leaner than others, with less apparent deprivation. I’m definitely not one of them.
–Some people have larger frames, meaning skeletons, than others.
Disagree?
The notion of somatotypes models well some of the real training, racing, hydration, and nutritional differences between athletes like me and the “typical” longer, leaner, ECTOMORPHIC competitive triathletes, whom I coincidentally label the “People of the Magic Tapeworm.” If it didn’t predict these differences well, I’d ditch it like the Daily Horoscope.
It’s worth noting that all models of reality are by their nature limited. Perhaps even some of yours.
Still, I agree with one of your points. If someone wishes to use this as a rationalization for failing to get into optimal race shape, that’s their problem. And that’s one fewer contender for the rest of us. If you’re looking for an excuse, your somatotype is as good as any other.
BTW, what does “profiling of athletic trends” mean?
there are differences in rest, training, and hormones of each “Somatotypes” - but this can be easily altered over time (and the hormones I mean via diet).
Somatotype implies a permanent state.