Mesomorph tri training tips (request)

So some people don’t gain weight, whether fat or muscle, more easily than others? To me, its the predisposition to a body type. at 5’10 and a bit over 200, I’m never going to look like my brother in law (6’0 and 140#). He doesn’t do any exercise, he just is that way.

And by insisting on that limitation, it is yours to keep!

Not that you want to get that skinny or that it would be a good thing, but you could

This is the most important point. Macca, Sindballe, Chris Lieto, Starky–all mesomorphs.

There are some inescapable biophysical limitations, and I see them every time Lawi Lalang, Bernard Lagat, and friends float past me on the River Path here in Tucson, holding what looks like sub-6 min/mile pace with virtually zero effort. There are also accommodations mesomorphs have to make for their particular physiology–more aggressive cooling and hydration in warmer climates is the most obvious example. But unless you’re a sub-8:30 at Kona type mesomorph, it’s more than likely that there’s still room for improvement.

I feel for you. I am 5’10 and am 185 lbs with a very muscular build. Back in my body building days I was 215 lbs, so I cut out weights and high carb/protein to shrink down in size. I actually started triathlon because I wanted the challenge and to be leaner. If I do any kind of weight training I put on a lot of mass. Currently working my weight down to 170-175 with Paleo for Athletes. I think the sbr training is the same, just cut down on weights and focus on diet. Keep carbs low at night.

Exactly my proportions. At 5’11"/220#, I ran, swam, did martial arts, and body weight exercises (pushups, pullups, sit-ups), and thought I had a pretty balanced physique. In re to leanness, I was no pin-up boy, but could knock out 15 dead-hang pull-ups and 100 real push-ups. Since starting tris in 2011, I have deliberately avoided upper body strength training, as carrying around a bulky upper body is clearly a net minus. Now, I race at 180-185 and about 8-10% BF by calipers, and could probably be 175-180… I didn’t keep a close eye on run training pace until recently, but I would guess it was 8:45-9:30/mile then, and 7:30-8:00 now. My swim times have stayed the same or gone a little backwards, but gaining muscle to have a faster swim will never be worth it in triathlon.

OTOH, I just started lower body weights, with the hope that I can increase W/Kg not just by shrinking the denominator but increasing the numerator. That’s one of this year’s experiments.

And I agree on diet. I can throw on pounds of all sorts with ease. It may be my own perceptual bias, but I think that meso/endomorphs have to work harder to stay lean. So it is. But I think it’s worth noting that a mesomorphic body type also has its relative advantages, as my cycling has improved dramatically in the last three years, likely due to my ability to readily grow quads and glutes. :wink:

My build is similar to your build. I am 5’6" and currently 165 lbs. My background is a retired powerlifter and competitive bodybuilder. When I came into cycling in 2004 I was at my offseason weight of 190 lbs, but was very fortunate to stumble into a forum a thread where the likes of Alex Simmons, Ric Stern, Dr. Coggan and several others were giving advice on training and training with a power meter. Long before I purchased a power meter I just took note of what they often suggested in training for sustainable power output. I also started reading Lydiard and a few other type of endurance type coaches.

In short I suppose my training is much like many (not all) that race in cycling without regards to how I am built. Sure my wider shoulders and back hurt my CdA and I have struggled to teach my legs to spin faster, but very slowly I am adapting and improving a little each year. I personally believe if I wanted to compete in endurance type sports I would stop lifting altogether, which would give me more time to focus on specific training and would help me drop some of my muscle mass.

As I slowly lose muscle mass and strength over the years my FTP and Watts/Kg have improved. Also because of my work and life schedule are tight my training has been easing more toward a polarized type of schedule where I do higher intensity short intervals like 4 x 10’s in a 60 to 90 minute session during the weekday and then longer lower intensity rides on the weekends. I would not dare say that this is the best routine; rather something that seems to work well with my daily/weekly routine. This is just cycling (Not SBR). Mainly just chiming in that perhaps it is just best to dig in and get something going by reading, applying, trying to be consistent week to week and be a bit progressive in training. Don’t worry too much for how you are built and let your body adapt as time (years) roll on and enjoy the journey.

…but I think that meso/endomorphs have to work harder to stay lean…

They don’t, because there’s no such thing as a mesomorph or any other somatotype.

Say with me: somatotypes don’t exist, somatotypes don’t exist, somatotypes don’t exist.

And just before you reply: they don’t exist. Really. They don’t. Eliminate this from the sports lexicon and the world will be a better place.

You’re a rather self-righteous type, Tape-worm, lol!
… Or would you suggest there’s also no such thing as self-righteous types, as well???

What’s next?
No such thing as proteins, fats and carbo’s (not to mention their sub-categories)???
It’s all just food… proteins, fats and carbs are just myths made up by scientists?

=)

Self righteous? Or just willing to point out fallacies when they present? Somatotypes are junk psychology, well disproven by science.

Science has no dealings with this crap. Profiling of athletic trends is science and vastly different, if you can understand it.

Or does it just hurt to have your preconceived fallacies busted?

Self righteous? Or just willing to point out fallacies when they present? Somatotypes are junk psychology, well disproven by science.

Science has no dealings with this crap. Profiling of athletic trends is science and vastly different, if you can understand it.

Or does it just hurt to have your preconceived fallacies busted?

Wow. Congratulate yourself much?

As much as I tend to avoid back-and-forths with posters who are both anonymous and snarky, I’ll give you my POV, FWIW: There are numerous unproven methods/schemata/whatever that still possess enough merit to persist despite a lack of incontrovertible, double-blind, placebo controlled, scientific proof. Two examples in medicine are the use of pulse oximetry to monitor the oxygen saturation of a surgical patient, or tocometry to monitor women in labor. They persist, because everyone involved knows they’re useful. Anyone who attempts to accomplish anything in the real world will eventually run into the necessity to avail themselves of less than Category I-A evidence in order to accomplish pretty much anything, and this is likely why the use of somatotypes continues.

This is why I find somatotypes to be a useful, albeit limited, model:

–Some people appear to put on muscle easier than others, given the same stimulus. I’m one of them.
–Some people put on fat easier than others. I may or may not be one of them.
–Some people seem to be leaner than others, with less apparent deprivation. I’m definitely not one of them.
–Some people have larger frames, meaning skeletons, than others.

Disagree?

The notion of somatotypes models well some of the real training, racing, hydration, and nutritional differences between athletes like me and the “typical” longer, leaner, ECTOMORPHIC competitive triathletes, whom I coincidentally label the “People of the Magic Tapeworm.” If it didn’t predict these differences well, I’d ditch it like the Daily Horoscope.

It’s worth noting that all models of reality are by their nature limited. Perhaps even some of yours.

Still, I agree with one of your points. If someone wishes to use this as a rationalization for failing to get into optimal race shape, that’s their problem. And that’s one fewer contender for the rest of us. If you’re looking for an excuse, your somatotype is as good as any other.

BTW, what does “profiling of athletic trends” mean?

Self righteous? Or just willing to point out fallacies when they present? Somatotypes are junk psychology, well disproven by science.

Science has no dealings with this crap. Profiling of athletic trends is science and vastly different, if you can understand it.

Or does it just hurt to have your preconceived fallacies busted?

Wow. Congratulate yourself much?

As much as I tend to avoid back-and-forths with posters who are both anonymous and snarky, I’ll give you my POV, FWIW: There are numerous unproven methods/schemata/whatever that still possess enough merit to persist despite a lack of incontrovertible, double-blind, placebo controlled, scientific proof. Two examples in medicine are the use of pulse oximetry to monitor the oxygen saturation of a surgical patient, or tocometry to monitor women in labor. They persist, because everyone involved knows they’re useful. Anyone who attempts to accomplish anything in the real world will eventually run into the necessity to avail themselves of less than Category I-A evidence in order to accomplish pretty much anything, and this is likely why the use of somatotypes continues.

This is why I find somatotypes to be a useful, albeit limited, model:

–Some people appear to put on muscle easier than others, given the same stimulus. I’m one of them.
–Some people put on fat easier than others. I may or may not be one of them.
–Some people seem to be leaner than others, with less apparent deprivation. I’m definitely not one of them.
–Some people have larger frames, meaning skeletons, than others.

Disagree?

The notion of somatotypes models well some of the real training, racing, hydration, and nutritional differences between athletes like me and the “typical” longer, leaner, ECTOMORPHIC competitive triathletes, whom I coincidentally label the “People of the Magic Tapeworm.” If it didn’t predict these differences well, I’d ditch it like the Daily Horoscope.

It’s worth noting that all models of reality are by their nature limited. Perhaps even some of yours.

Still, I agree with one of your points. If someone wishes to use this as a rationalization for failing to get into optimal race shape, that’s their problem. And that’s one fewer contender for the rest of us. If you’re looking for an excuse, your somatotype is as good as any other.

BTW, what does “profiling of athletic trends” mean?

there are differences in rest, training, and hormones of each “Somatotypes” - but this can be easily altered over time (and the hormones I mean via diet).
Somatotype implies a permanent state.

there are differences in rest, training, and hormones of each “Somatotypes” - but this can be easily altered over time (and the hormones I mean via diet).
Somatotype implies a permanent state.

Some is permanent, some isn’t. The width of one’s pelvis and shoulder girdle won’t change. Length of levers and location of muscle attachments aren’t going to change. Ability to easily add muscle mass is likely mostly genetic. From what I’ve heard and seen this implies a lower limit for useful weight loss. If muscle mass drops below a certain point, the ability to move the frame gets compromised.

OTOH, bodyfat and related hormonal states are highly influenced by diet, rest, and exercise. And this is more the issue for 99.96243% of everyone I know.

Hmmm I bet you have a incline to the left temple and a slight indentation to the rear indicating a failing in the logic centre…

Junk sciences abound!

What are you arguing for? It’s not very clear.

Hi Synthetic,

That’s a very simplistic response, and assumes that:
a. I like to make excuses; and
b. I don’t put in the effort.

Tell me, why are you even on this site?
It is “slow twitch”, which is a “type” of muscle fibre, that is more dominant in certain somatotypes.

People of some races are pre-dominantly built a certain way, eg. natives of Tonga or New Zealand (Maoris) are “predominantly” large build… regardless of diet or level of exercise.
If you but open your eyes, you might actually notice this reality…

=)

PS. With your example of Shane Hammond, perhaps he’s got a fair share of fast twitch fibres, and the slam dunk (at least in his case) is an explosive act - something those with higher amounts of these fibres (generally mesomorphs) are good at…

Hmmm I bet you have a incline to the left temple and a slight indentation to the rear indicating a failing in the logic centre…

Junk sciences abound!

What are you arguing for? It’s not very clear.

Here’s half your problem tapeworm - you make all sorts of judgements and assumptions about people you’ve never even met.
Perhaps you’re a scrawny little dweeb, that can only come up with “tough” comments online, since you could be anywhere in the world when doing so, away from those you make allegations against…?

Nothing of what you “allege” hurts, not the least because that’s all they are - allegations - the jury aint out on what you’ve convinced yourself of.
Do different somatotypes exist? Yep, they do, but i won’t be so arrogant as yourself to expect everyone else to fall in to line and move to the beat of my drum on this point.

I provided an example in response to Synthetic’s reply.
Another example is those who have “Popeye-like” proportions, eg. with calves and forearms - of which I am one - partly genetic - my dad had whopping great calves, of which i did a skinfold test once, and could barely roll skin, let alone sub-cutaneous fat, and i never knew him to even once do calf raises/donkey raises, whatever. Mine are large without doing such exercises either… it’s called genetic make-up.
Further, no amount of high volume cycling will make them smaller - if anything, they’ll enlarge, given high proportion of fast-twitch fibres.

I hope this helps paint a more clearer picture for you.

So, in a nut-shell, my question was simply about us bigger blokes, who are this size through genetic disposition, and who DO put in the grunt, and are willing to continue to do so… just wanted some tips from those who could help (and not quips from those who can’t).

Cheers…

I have made no assumptions - just pointing out that somatotypes exist as much as phrenology does.

Individualistic genetic predispositions to certain physical traits is indeed a fact of life. But the human race can’t be broken down to, and be stuck with, 3 grossly ill-defined body types (and their corresponding mental traits, which was a crux of Sheldons work). Which is why it is junk science and not used by anyone with a reputable sports science background.

But keep believing if you want.

Hmmm I bet you have a incline to the left temple and a slight indentation to the rear indicating a failing in the logic centre…

Junk sciences abound!

What are you arguing for? It’s not very clear.

Here’s half your problem tapeworm - you make all sorts of judgements and assumptions about people you’ve never even met.
Perhaps you’re a scrawny little dweeb, that can only come up with “tough” comments online, since you could be anywhere in the world when doing so, away from those you make allegations against…?

Nothing of what you “allege” hurts, not the least because that’s all they are - allegations - the jury aint out on what you’ve convinced yourself of.
Do different somatotypes exist? Yep, they do, but i won’t be so arrogant as yourself to expect everyone else to fall in to line and move to the beat of my drum on this point.

I provided an example in response to Synthetic’s reply.
Another example is those who have “Popeye-like” proportions, eg. with calves and forearms - of which I am one - partly genetic - my dad had whopping great calves, of which i did a skinfold test once, and could barely roll skin, let alone sub-cutaneous fat, and i never knew him to even once do calf raises/donkey raises, whatever. Mine are large without doing such exercises either… it’s called genetic make-up.
Further, no amount of high volume cycling will make them smaller - if anything, they’ll enlarge, given high proportion of fast-twitch fibres.

I hope this helps paint a more clearer picture for you.

So, in a nut-shell, my question was simply about us bigger blokes, who are this size through genetic disposition, and who DO put in the grunt, and are willing to continue to do so… just wanted some tips from those who could help (and not quips from those who can’t).

Cheers…

…don’t feed the troll… Arguments have been made in simplistic enough terms that any halfway intelligent person who wishes to comprehend it would do so. Clearly that’s not the goal.

“… Incline to the left temple…”
“… pre-conceived fallacies…”
Don’t know if they were levelled at me, another contributor, or if they were just throw-away statements, but they sound like assumptions to me.
As do some of your other statments, eg. somatotypes being a fallacy / junk psychology, “well disproven by science.”… says who, apart from yourself?
No point throwing such statements out like they’re hard facts, and not provide credible evidence to back up your point ('tho even if you did, the debate would still rage, as do many debates between those who stand on different divides of various sciences).

You also allege that science has no dealings with this “crap”.
I think you’ll find that many who work in the scientific field, eg. doctors, nutritionists, etc., would beg to differ.

Now, I’m not one who believes in science as the be all and end all, as though it is God, but for the purpose of this topic, I hope you can see that science does play a part, to whatever degree.

Pity we’ve gone off topic a bit, and thanks to those who have provided beneficial feed-back…

=)

I have made no assumptions - just pointing out that somatotypes exist as much as phrenology does.

Individualistic genetic predispositions to certain physical traits is indeed a fact of life. But the human race can’t be broken down to, and be stuck with, 3 grossly ill-defined body types (and their corresponding mental traits, which was a crux of Sheldons work). Which is why it is junk science and not used by anyone with a reputable sports science background.

But keep believing if you want.

Somatotypes don’t have a lot of “hard science” debunking it as it was never a very solid theory in the first place. Additionally, how do they apply to women? Answer is: they never did as Sheldon never thought women to be particularly worthwhile physical specimens.

A nice overview of the history:-

http://articles.elitefts.com/features/columns/the-science-of-somatotypes/
http://articles.elitefts.com/training-articles/digging-deeper-into-the-science-of-somatotypes

A good overview of how somatotypes came into existence:-

http://www.cbmh.ca/index.php/cbmh/article/viewFile/928/923

Demonstrating the disconnect of body type and temperament (the crux of Sheldon’s work in the first place).

http://www.epjournal.net/wp-content/uploads/EP06369385.pdf

Lose weight!
Ever see “Dallas Buyers Club” or the “Fighter”? It is totally possible to go from yoked to skinny no matter what your body type is.

A very simplistic statement Bootsie.
I have attended to this reply already in this thread, providing my dimensions, etc.
We are all built differently - I have a solid build, high lean body mass, low (sub 10%) fat (regardless of those in this forum who would question this… perhaps out of jealousy???)

The original question was simple, and I appreciate the helpful advice provided by some… just a pity others make judgements based on simplistic assumtions…

Lose weight!
Ever see “Dallas Buyers Club” or the “Fighter”? It is totally possible to go from yoked to skinny no matter what your body type is.

You are taking it the wrong way.
I went to a college with a good wrestling program.
Guys who wrestled around 150 wee more like 175-180 in the off-season.
They were also low body fat at that higher weight.

You are taking it the wrong way.
I went to a college with a good wrestling program.
Guys who wrestled around 150 wee more like 175-180 in the off-season.
They were also low body fat at that higher weight.

Perhaps, perhaps not.
It’s all well and good to state “low body fat”, but how low is low?
Depending on profile, sport, etc., some would suggest 15% is low - then you look at how much of their dropped weight would be lost in fat, as opposed to other means (and muscle isn’t just the other means - it’s surprising how much can be in fluid - something that can be lost or gained/stored as excess, whether willingly or not).
There are many factors, and one size (theory/situation) does NOT fit all… =)