Medicare, IRMAA, Roth Conversions, and SSA-44

IYKYK.

Anyone done this?

it is an interesting topic, I’ve never found any really good answers. Roth conversion = lower RMD (and no forced taxable distributions when your kids inherit) is a reasonable approach. I’d add consider swapping some large savings account balances to tax deferred annuities (not the high expense options with worthless benefits that have been largely derided) as a possible arrow in the quiver too. And of course QCD’s

The problem I have is RMD’s are calculated off market value and trying to create plans based on something wildly unpredictable is frought with difficulty. Rule number one, know the brackets and be mindful.

I have also been told that the Roth conversion makes the most sense. But that is coming from my money manager and is above my understanding. I was also told that just because it makes sense today, that things are always changing based upon the current administration and congress, so what makes sense today could change by the time I’m ready to do anything with it. So the best we can do is play by the rules we have.

For those who might be curious: a Roth conversion increases your income and can kick you into a higher bracket when calculating Medicare premiums for the next three years. There is a process (SSA-44) where you ask that some income (here, the Roth conversion) be ignored for purposes of calculating Medicare premiums. The argument is that a Roth conversion does not make you wealthier but, instead, just shifts an asset from one category (like an IRA) to another category (Roth) and thus should not affect your Medicare premium.

I thought that anyone who needed explaining wouldn’t be able to answer the question as to using the SSA-44. I did the conversion in 2025, and for 2027 that would bump me up two tiers in IRMAA, which I obviously don’t want. Found out about the SSA-44, and wanted to know if anyone has used this. It seems like it was designed to handle situations just like this except for not being explicit about Roth conversions.

I’m in the same boat. My spouse converted a Roth some years ago; we did so knowing nothing about IRMAA. So when I signed up for Medicare it was a rude surprise to find how much I had to pay for it. Unfortunately SSA-44 does not apply to me so I’m screwed.

Ike, am I missing something? I thought IRMAA just looked back two years - your AGI from 2 years ago determines your Medicare Part B and D premiums.

Doing a quick read on it is the form is generally used to adjust for the switch from being employed to being retired. If you do a Roth conversion though during that year it generally is denied.

The more I read, the more I’m convinced that Roth conversions can’t be a basis for an appeal. Like, completely convinced. Oh, well. Although my wife retired, and that would be considered a life-changing event, it won’t have that much effect (pension kicked in).

I’m fortunate enough that the IRMAA surcharges aren’t that big a deal. I’d rather have that amount than not, but it isn’t a “life-changing event” for us.

Glad I double-checked.

You’re right.

After posting, I actually did some reading (not the ideal sequence of events) and think your conclusion is correct.

That’s what I think, too.

Why does all this have to be so damn complicated?

Because the people that make the laws have never done workflow design before.

As someone who had to modify a whole crapton of brokerage and pension workflow at my previous company because of secure act 1 and 2, trust me, none of it was done with any logic on how it would actually work.

Don’t get me wrong the law mostly made sense, just none of it is done with any thought on how this will be implemented.

It’s like Colorado’s unemployment. I’m going through that right now since my company moved out of state and I wasn’t going with them. We have now gone back and forth 3 times on what my salary was. Im about to send and email to whoever runs that division with a redesigned workflow on how to improve it. If I can’t get this right, I feel horrible for everyone else who is trying to do this and is really in a bad place for money.

Politicians think this crap up with no way to make it work easily. I honestly don’t think most are doing it on purpose they’re just like here’s what we need done, but not concept of implementation.

It’s not just the politicians. In Boulder there was a ballot item on whether to tax vacant homes. Part of the argument against the tax was that there was no practical way to prove that a home was unoccupied more than half the year. Despite the absence of any solution (yet), the tax passed.

I’d be good with having on the ballot in a couple years that if you want to put any amendment, policy or whatever on the ballot you need to have a full plan on how it will be implemented.

It’s been a few years since the secure act stuff but if I remember right, we couldn’t even do some of the implementation, because they didn’t define what the rules/calculations were around one of the rules. The IRS finally had to postpone part of the bill because they didn’t know how they were going to do the math either.