Which is more powerful? Magic from the Potter-verse or The Force from Lucas-World.
Are they not one in the same, merely applied slightly differently?
MMA Cage Match: Wizard vs. Jedi Master?
No weapons at all, Jedi hands down. All the tricks in the bag, I’m going with the wizard.
**3. Wand vs. Light Saber (Could you stop one of those Wand blasts with a Light Saber?) **
A wand is multi dimensional. The light saber in and of itself contains no power. The true match would be “Could a Jedi master use the force to counter act a wand blast”. The answer to that would be yes. The light saber could not.
4. MMA Cage Match: J.K Rowling vs. George Lucas?
I don’t remember either of these characters.
5. MMA Cage Match: Hagrid vs. Chewy?
Does it matter…that would be AWESOME!
6. MMA Cage Match: Lord Voldemort vs. Darth Vader?
I’m not really into the Potter books as much as the Star Wars stuff. That being said it turns out in the big scheme of things Darth Vader wasn’t all that “Strong”. Yoda would have kicked his ass as well as a couple other Jedi and “Dark side” members. Hell he got ass whooped by Obi Wan originally. So I’m going with Lord Voldemort for the win.
**1. Which is more powerful? Magic from the Potter-verse or The Force from Lucas-World. **
Overall I’d have to go with magic. The Force is cool and all, it can move things and provide extra-sensory perception of a sort, but I don’t see any Jedis disapparating of anything like that. And horcruxes, dude, I ask you, how scary would Vader or the emperor have been if they had access to horcruxes?
**2. MMA Cage Match: Wizard vs. Jedi Master? **
Depends on which wizard, which Jedi. Dumbledore vs. Yoda - that’s a bloody draw.
**3. Wand vs. Light Saber (Could you stop one of those Wand blasts with a Light Saber?) **
Wand is going to win. One cunningly executed expelliarmus curse and the Jedi is left to levitate stones to pitch at the wizard with the wand.
**4. MMA Cage Match: J.K Rowling vs. George Lucas? **
Not sure, but there would be a lot of hair-pulling.
**5. MMA Cage Match: Hagrid vs. Chewy? **
Chewy. Hagrid’s a big wimp when you get down to it; lovable and strong, but a wimp. Chewy rips people’s arms out of their sockets when he loses a game of 3-D chess.
6. MMA Cage Match: Lord Voldemort vs. Darth Vader?
Again, not sure, but Spike TV would make a fortune either way.
Nicely discussed. I’m glad there are a few people out there in Lavender land that are interested in discussing something else once in a awhile other than Palinobamarushelosi Reformcare.
Which is more powerful? Magic from the Potter-verse or The Force from Lucas-World.
Overall I’d have to go with magic.
**
I am going to go with the Force. In a fight between Dumbledore and Yoda, I am going with Yoda hands down. "this is not the Jedi master you are looking for . . . The force is not just moving things around, it is MIND CONTROL!
Wand vs. Light Saber (Could you stop one of those Wand blasts with a Light Saber?)
Wand is going to win.
**
Wand without magician is a back scratcher. Toss that most elegant light saber to a jedi and you get the whole package.
After seeing Harry Potter and the Half Blood Prince this weekend, I have a few new discussion topics for the denizens of the Lavender Room.
Which is more powerful? Magic from the Potter-verse or The Force from Lucas-World. Well for overall power Magic would have the edge
MMA Cage Match: Wizard vs. Jedi Master?
Since the force is a thought and magic requires actually reciting a spell I would have to give the edge to the force as a quicker application of force
Wand vs. Light Saber (Could you stop one of those Wand blasts with a Light Saber?)
If you could stop the spells with a light saber then I would go with the light saber, otherwise the wand, ( although the light saber is much cooler)
MMA Cage Match: J.K Rowling vs. George Lucas? Since she was a welfare momma and George a college kid , I go for the Brit
MMA Cage Match: Hagrid vs. Chewy? Chewy is a hunter to the core, Hagrid a big guy but kinda a wuss, Chewy first round due to medical stoppage from Hargid loosing his arms
MMA Cage Match: Lord Voldemort vs. Darth Vader? Darth was played like a fiddle by Palpetine, Darth was not a nice guy but I think the emperor was the real player here. Lord V takes it
MMA Cage Match: Wizard vs. Jedi Master?
Since the force is a thought and magic requires actually reciting a spell I would have to give the edge to the force as a quicker application of force
Excellent point! Jedi could do that Darth trick of choking the wizard before he or she could get the spell out.
Bottom line being a Jedi Master is waaaaaaay cooooller than being a crusty old wizard, gotta have all those bat wings and dried frogs around … kinda creepy on date night or you could say hey babe wanna see my light saber??
Let’s take it another direction: Tolkein-verse or Star Wars:
Magic in Tolkein-verse or Force: You don’t really get to see alot of “magic” in Tolkein, but with all the elves can do, and Gandalf, it seems to be very powerful. And I think very similar to the Force in that it is much more connected to the earth and life, moreso than Potter Magic.
Gandalf vs Yoda: Yoda can bounce around and stuff, but Gandalf beat the crap out of a Balrog and “smote his ruin upon the mountainside”. Winner, Gandalf.
Light Saber or Staff (or should we say magic sword like Glamdring or Anduril?).
Tolkein or Lucas? Tolkein butted intellectual heads with the likes of CS Lewis and the Oxford Inklings, Lucas made Jar Jar Binks. I think Tolkein would outwit Lucas.
Chewy or who? Treebeard? Gimli? Legolas? Really, I think the fight we would all want to see is Han Solo vs. Aragorn. Loveable rogue or Ranger King?
Darth Vader vs. Sauron? No contest. As much as I love Vader, Sauron would crush him like a hobbit.
Let’s take it another direction: Tolkein-verse or Star Wars:
Magic in Tolkein-verse or Force: Much better match up then HP. I would have to see better examples of Tokkein-Magic to decide. The various force powers are pretty well known.
Gandalf vs Yoda: Tough call…completely different styles. Gandalf seems more of the chess master…lots of finesse and subtlety to the spell casting, letting the magic do the work. Yoda (and all Jedi) are more force-assisted martial arts. Lots of moving around with the assistance of the force. Gandalf Vs Sidious (aka Palpatine) or Yoda vs Sauron would probably be better fights to watch.
Light Saber or Staff (or should we say magic sword like Glamdring or Anduril?). Same as with HP. The light saber is an extension of the Jedi master, controlled with the force. It is simply a weapon, and does not influence the knight’s powers.
Tolkein or Lucas? Tolkein butted intellectual heads with the likes of CS Lewis and the Oxford Inklings, Lucas made Jar Jar Binks. I think Tolkein would outwit Lucas. Agreed.
Chewy or who? Treebeard? Gimli? Legolas? Really, I think the fight we would all want to see is Han Solo vs. Aragorn. Loveable rogue or Ranger King? ** I’d like to see an Ent take on an ATAC, or JarJar vs Gollum would just be funny.**
Darth Vader vs. Sauron? No contest. As much as I love Vader, Sauron would crush him like a hobbit. No kidding. Vader seemed kind of weak to me. Maybe it was just the difference in the eras the films were made, but Darth Maul seemed like a much bigger hard ass then Vader. Too much “agony and sorrow” and not enough raw badassness.
What the fuck is wrong with you people Vader would win for sure!!! Um he has the FORCE with him which has been generally agreed to as being more powerful/better than magic. That’s it I’m going back to political issues before I get really mad!