Kona Video- Watching People not Make 17 Hour Cut Off

When I first started watching the Kona videos, I used to silently cheer on these people, the ones that are bent over, zig zagging down the road with the medical staff running beside them.

Now however, I’m not so sure. I recently watched the 2009 edition and people at the end of the video kind of make me think… “well you just haven’t trained enough, perhaps you should have more endurance experience behind you before attempting this, perhaps this sport just isn’t for you”

What are your thoughts?

http://img2.wikia.nocookie.net/__cb20140209013353/creepypasta/images/a/a9/Don't_Feed_the_Troll.jpeg

Exactly. Who recalls the Swiss runner staggering around the track at the end of the 1984 Women’s Olympic marathon? From wikipedia:

Gabriela (“Gaby”) Andersen-Schiess (born May 20, 1945 in Zürich) is a former Swiss long-distance runner who participated in the first women’s Olympic marathon at the 1984 Summer Olympics. Though living in Idaho and working as a ski instructor at the time, Andersen-Schiess represented Switzerland in the 1984 Los Angeles Games.
Fourteen minutes into the 1984 Olympic marathon, Joan Benoit began to pull away from the rest of the pack. She went on to win in a time of 2 hours, 24 minutes, and 52 seconds. Twenty minutes after Benoit finished, then 39-year-old Andersen-Schiess entered the stadium.
The crowd gasped in horror as she staggered onto the track, her torso twisted, her left arm limp, her right leg mostly seized. She waved away medical personnel who rushed to help her, knowing that, if they touched her, she would be disqualified. The L.A. Coliseum crowd applauded and cheered as she limped around the track in the race’s final 400 meters, occasionally stopping and holding her head.
While the effects of her heat exhaustion were plainly evident, trackside medics saw that she was perspiring, which meant that her body still had some disposable fluids, and let her continue her march to the finish line. At the completion of this final lap—which took Andersen-Schiess five minutes and 44 seconds—she fell across the finish line. She finished 37th, ahead of seven other runners. Medical personnel tended to her immediately and, miraculously, she was released two hours later. Her time of 2:48:45 would have won the gold medal in the first five Olympic marathons.

I barely remember seeing that on tv - here’s a 2 minute clip of her in the home stretch:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0Hjm29CmMfg

cool story bro.

those slots have been there forever. nothing is being devalued, its the same as it ever was.

Thanks for the compliment dude.

You don’t get chance to buy your way into the olympic games, or any other work championship. Just because they have been there forever does not mean it does not devalue the efforts of those who have committed to qualification.

Unless you’re the prince of Monaco. Or you are from some of the other smaller countries without a developed olympic program.

Those are the people that should do an Ironamn - not the world championships. If you are not good enough to finish you should be doing a local event, not be thinking you are part of the amazing crowd that are gifted and dedicated enough to get there in the first place. Reality is that some people commit a massive part of the lives to getting to Kona, and others who buy their way in, get lottery slots when they know they are not fit enough to finish or simply by chance otherwise end up with a slot devalue the sport when they cannot finish.

Kona is an age group and pro world championship - but it is rapidly being devalued by people who cannot finish, let alone commit to the life style necessary to get a recognized slot there.

Jamaica bob sled team. Eddie "The Eagle- ski jumper for Britain. St. Kzitts cycling. Eric Moussambini - Equatorial Guinea swimming (1:52 for the 100).

All of these competed at the bottom rung of the ladder at the Olympics, arguably the highest pinnacle of sport. Do their performances devalue the winner?

John

Jamaica bob sled team. They were the best bob sled team in Jamaica, hit the minimum qualification time and qualified through their own merit.

Eddie "The Eagle- ski jumper for Britain. Was the best ski jumper in Britain and qualified on his own merit. At the time he was the UK record holder for the event.

St. Kzitts cycling. - No idea what this is you got me here :slight_smile:

Eric Moussambini - Equatorial Guinea swimming (1:52 for the 100). Eric achieved a personal best at the games, and a new Equatoguinean national record. He was the best they had and was invited as part of an initiative to encourage developing countries to participate, despite their financial limitations. He definitely added value to the games, not detracted from it. He was at the games through merit, not because he bought his place or because he bought a slot on e-bay.

If you qualified on your own merit, if you are the best your Nation has, why would you devalue the winner? If you have not trained enough to finish, if you bought your slot, or if you are there because you happen to be rich and fancy a brag - how does that add value to a world championships?

When I first started watching the Kona videos, I used to silently cheer on these people, the ones that are bent over, zig zagging down the road with the medical staff running beside them.

Now however, I’m not so sure. I recently watched the 2009 edition and people at the end of the video kind of make me think… “well you just haven’t trained enough, perhaps you should have more endurance experience behind you before attempting this, perhaps this sport just isn’t for you”
What are your thoughts?
Frankly, my first thought upon reading your post was: aren’t we judgmental. And who are you to determine of triathlon is the sport for them?
And I understand and have known people who are poorly trained, or don’t take training nearly as seriously as I do who want to participate in endurance events. But I feel if they want to do it then who am I to judge.

Quite frankly, it takes more mental determination to finish a 17hr IM than a 9 hr IM. You have to push yourself harder and longer.

quote]

Note: I have not read the entire thread.

While I agree with the general point you are trying to make, I disagree with the bold. I have IM finishes ranging from 11:40 to 16:32 and I disagree that a 17 hour IM requires you to push harder and longer. Longer yes, harder no.

Those are the people that should do an Ironamn - not the world championships. If you are not good enough to finish you should be doing a local event, not be thinking you are part of the amazing crowd that are gifted and dedicated enough to get there in the first place. Reality is that some people commit a massive part of the lives to getting to Kona, and others who buy their way in, get lottery slots when they know they are not fit enough to finish or simply by chance otherwise end up with a slot devalue the sport when they cannot finish.

Kona is an age group and pro world championship - but it is rapidly being devalued by people who cannot finish, let alone commit to the life style necessary to get a recognized slot there.

Jamaica bob sled team. Eddie “The Eagle” - ski jumper for Britain. St. Kitts cycling. Eric Moussambini - Equatorial Guinea swimming (1:52 for the 100).

All of these competed at the bottom rung of the ladder at the Olympics, arguably the highest pinnacle of sport. Do their performances devalue the winner?

John

No because they somehow qualified to be there.

In some cases, the “qualification” was they showed up. There are slots for the Olympics that are “discretionary” based on the country involved, development and other considerations to where the NGB can just point at someone (essentially) and say “Hey! You wanna go compete at the Olympics?”

John

That’s pretty much it, and there are cases where those spots are given as political favours, etc.

When I first started watching the Kona videos, I used to silently cheer on these people, the ones that are bent over, zig zagging down the road with the medical staff running beside them.

Now however, I’m not so sure. I recently watched the 2009 edition and people at the end of the video kind of make me think… “well you just haven’t trained enough, perhaps you should have more endurance experience behind you before attempting this, perhaps this sport just isn’t for you”

What are your thoughts?

Oddly enough I just finished watching the 2013 video on youtube, and the final minute of the film shows how some finishers cross the line past the cut off, but most surely add value to the event.

When I first started watching the Kona videos, I used to silently cheer on these people, the ones that are bent over, zig zagging down the road with the medical staff running beside them.

Now however, I’m not so sure. I recently watched the 2009 edition and people at the end of the video kind of make me think… “well you just haven’t trained enough, perhaps you should have more endurance experience behind you before attempting this, perhaps this sport just isn’t for you”

What are your thoughts?

Yeah, because they didn’t train enough to qualify in the first place.

Weak sauce. 3/10.

John

I disagree. “Qualifying” for Kona means many different things (i.e., corporate slot).

Just want to make sure people know the difference between MarkM (not me) and Mark M. (Me). I have completed Kona twice, in 1991 when I was invited ( long story) and 2001 as a lottery selection. I qualified for neither of those races, which were among the hardest, and best, days of my life.

They should turn it into a two-day-event like the 70.3 WC next year in Zell am See. On Saturday everybody can register for the event like any other Ironman race, on Sunday the WC for all the athletes who qualified for it.

…and I came here to see the '14 carnage
.

Just want to make sure people know the difference between MarkM (not me) and Mark M. (Me). I have completed Kona twice, in 1991 when I was invited ( long story) and 2001 as a lottery selection. I qualified for neither of those races, which were among the hardest, and best, days of my life.

You might have completed it twice, but in my opinion you are yet to take part in a world championship.

Just want to make sure people know the difference between MarkM (not me) and Mark M. (Me). I have completed Kona twice, in 1991 when I was invited ( long story) and 2001 as a lottery selection. I qualified for neither of those races, which were among the hardest, and best, days of my life.

You might have completed it twice, but in my opinion you are yet to take part in a world championship.

In my opinion, you don’t understand the history and heritage of the event.