I know this has come up in other forums, but I wanted to start a new dedicated post to get some discussion going on start procedure for Kona.
To start I am going to say it should be Mass Start or Rolling.
My first trip to Kona to race was back in 2016 and I was lucky to et a mass start. The great thing is that quickly the races is sorted out in the swim so other then an initial battle for position once established there is no swimming over the top of people mid race like happens now. My next time to Kona was 2022 and it was a wave start, I ended up started some 90 mins after the pros. The issue was extreme heat exposure starting this late, it is awful. I also am a decent swimmer and was constantly running into slower waves and will admit did see many and went straight over them.
The solution just do a mass start, weaker swimmers will self seed or do a rolling start with the distance starting from the beach not the traditional 100m out and get people going as quick as they can. At least a rolling start encourages seeding based on speed and avoids this smashing into each other. I know it may mean front age groupers may not race head to head for worlds, but this doesnāt matter elsewhere in ironmans that now use rolling.
Iād take AG wave starts any day over rolling starts. You are racing your AG. They are all having the same miserable extreme heat experience you are.
If you want to pretend that the race just started ānowā for everyone, and everyone is suffering the same heat fate, do that. What difference does it make if someone you arenāt competing against has it easier (or harder)?
From the swimming over people, thatās something that will pretty much always happen, but I guess youāre thinking once you get away, you get away.
A rolling start wonāt really help much as most people will opportunistically crowd to the front, and youāre truly damaging the competition in that case. Why should a self-seeded, honest swimmer, start the bike 45 minutes later because they put themselves in the back of the line? That pretty much throws away the meaning of an age group world champion.
So the solution is either AG waves or mass start. Iām fine with either.
Appreciate your point and agree on a return to the mass start. If they stick with age group waves one issue is how long it takes to get them all started, and you make a good point that everyone who starts together is in the heat together, however, it is pretty extreme conditions in Kona and I donāt know of any other IM that has participants starting so late, especially in that climate.
I do think thereās something to be said for Ironman starting the race 1-2 hours earlier in the dark and figuring out some lighting both in the water and maybe on the ankles of the swimmers (just making crap up, who knows) for the ones in the dark. But Iāve done some swims in the dark (no light though) and it was legit one of the most terrifying things Iāve ever experienced plunging into the black above and below.
Wave starts make sense, you get to see and race your AG. You want the race to cater to you when it is actually thinking about the 95%. And Kona is just hot, starts very early in the morning and goes all day. The late start enables many to get to sundown earlier, when it does get cooler. And I bet a lot more people race after sundown than the ones that have to swim through a few slowpokes.
Perhaps a red hat with MAKA, but I dont think after 45 years they are going back to something they tried very hard to get away fromā¦
No many are going after sun down due to the quality of field racing, so there is a big group out suffering in the heat and that is part of the challenge of the day.
My main point is avoiding people being swum over constantly due to wave starts. A mass start solves this and returns the sport to the way it was traditionally done.
I started with the ENTIRE race starting at once back in the day & many times since. This year, was my first time after an 11 year hiatus psuedo-retirement from Kona, and enjoyed the age group start with my Wave 11/last wave. Fortunately, I didnāt bring a bike or run shoes to Kona, and never planned to go beyond the swim (near complete hamstring tear a month out & not authorized to run by my ortho, until December āand just got the ok to sit up biking (not TT position) days before arriving.
It was a miserable day for my fellow M55-59ārs and did the swim (not really kicking to protect the hammy), showered on the pier, and then cheered them on the rest of the dayāit was fun but felt I āshouldā have been on the course myself, that was the difficult part! Odd & unusual, but Iād have to say aside from the late, late start, there was absolutely no issues with how they have the swim now. I kind of prefer it actually. The mass start of all ages groups just creates a bigger drafting issue. Rolling starts take too long and takes some of the head to head competition out of it, which is part of the fun you may allude to with an āentire race mass startāā¦but age group waves solves both of those issues to a degree.
It was the single most expensive swim Iāve done in my entire life hands down!
So give us a little RR on how your swim went? I almost did this same thing 20 years ago. I had just turned 50 and I won Oceanside 70.3 and got a slot to Kona. I had no intention of doing the entire race, not from any injury, just that post pacemaker doing ironman training was not in the cards anymore. I could still fake a half, and back then that got you a ticket to the show.
But I realized how important those slots were to people, and folks would literally die for a shot. So I was the only person in the entire race who passed on the slot, got a lot of weird locks, except for the guy that actually got it though!. Would have been fun for me to just go and do the swim and watch like you did, probably would have brought my bike and rode around with my number on and watched the pro race from the inside..
Not much to report. Did Nats in Milwaukee then an easy weekā¦then a week later, did a local Oly race & was brought to a near dead stop on the run (think I did for a second or two), with worst run on the same course I race 3-4x a year onā¦knew something was up from the pain in the rear. Xray, then an MRI, showed a nearly full tear (stopped short of coming off the bone he said). No surgery, stopped short of that expense. Planned on bailing on Kona entirely for the race, but was all paid up with no cancel refunds, used it for a vacation w/wifey. A couple days before, chatted on InstaG w/Markus from Print4Watts (we chat a lot as I use his products) & he said, āYou may as well just swim & drop.ā⦠since my doc said I couldnāt race the bike/run. Last minute decision to do the swim was made about 6 hrs after that discussion. Besides, I wanted my damn $1,800 backpack! lol
RR goes like thisā¦normal breakfast of oatmeal, toast, and since it was a fullā¦a protein shake. Walked through transition to find where my bike WOULD have been since I didnāt drop one off on bike drop the day beforeā¦had no idea where I would have been on the pier until race morning (btw itās a jam packed cluster f*** on that pier & bikes are so crammed together itās quite silly). Took some pictures, then went & waited for the waves to line up for about maybe 2 hrsā¦talked to some folks, dropped my dry clothes and then lined up. Chatted with some M55-59ās. Completely relaxed knowing I only had a swim to do. Swam out to the start line, took off & immediately knew this was the worst conditions Iāve been in at Kona. Huge swells that you couldnāt tell from TV or streaming coverageā¦it was rough!
I didnāt navigate too well I think, and didnāt much care. Didnāt āgun itā either, it was a training swim. Issue I had was not being able to kick. My *ss end was sinking because of having to protect the hammy which I could feel. PRP takes a while to fix it, but on top of that, got punched in the foot by some dude drafting my swim from his hand enteringāand it sent a shock all the way up to the tear and I yelped! It hurt in my top hammy from him hitting the foot. Swam like this ā / ā versus āāā for body position. Just sorta went through the motions & was fairly surprised to see the position after the swim online from that crappy of an effort. I did swallow one mouthful of sea water but managed to not puke. That was a relief. Got up on shore & had a hard time getting out of transition because every 10 ft encountering someone asking why I wasnāt going to the change tent and if there was an issue. Basically said, āPlan never was to finish or go beyond the swim, I have no bike, docās orders to not do the bike/run. I am now a spectator for the rest of the day, where is the exit?ā They even made me go to the Med Tent as I was DNF/ing (all DNFās go to Med Tent first they said)ā¦had to explain it again to 2 nurses & 2 docs to convince them I was 100% fine. End of RR. Thanks for asking @monty Not that exciting of a RR really.
**I did get to rent a road bike earlier in the week and ride from Waikaloa to Hawi soft pedaling at 13 or 14 mph (docās orders to go easy sitting up only) & for the FIRST TIME EVER (true story) ride a road bike! **I never owned a road bike, just a TT bike. Had a Mtn bike in University but crashed it, never used one again. BTW, road bike position is weird & I canāt say I really liked it. Maybe if I had one & had it set up or fit just for me I would. But yeah, first time ever on a real road bikeāvery different indeed!
Iāve raced Kona a few times with different starts and think the wave starts can work but they need some changes to the gaps between waves. In terms of swim starts Iāve experienced:
2017 male mass start which was a rough swim for the 1st half and especially the 1st 500m but the biggest issue was congestion on the bike - it took a long time to spread out. There were at least a lot of referees around and penalties drafting penalties being applied which helped spread things out
2019/2022 AG wave start and I was in the 1st AG wave. Being in the 1st wave this was the best start for me as no fighting on the swim and the bike was spread out.
2026 - wave start but in the 6th (of 11) AG wave. The swim wasnāt too bad although we were catching earlier waves quickly and by half way I couldnāt see anyone from my wave and had to navigate through earlier waves which made it a bit harder but overall it was alright. The biggest issue I found starting in a later wave was the bike was congested again - it was alright for the first 20km then around a group of 10-20 guys till 130km before things separated in the headwind back to Kona. People were too similar in ability to get any separation which wasnāt helped by the lack of referees on the bike - I think I saw 1 referee and no penalties even though there should have been a lot. I think with a few referees and penalties being given out it would have forced groups to spread out
Overall I think the waves can work but they need big gaps between waves. Increasing gaps to 20-30minute would solve a lot of the issues even if that means starting at or after 9. Iād be happy to start late and get clear roads and I donāt think theres a big issue for the faster waves as the majority of <50 men are finished under 12 hours. Also have some referees on the bikeā¦
Your reason and rationale makes sense for almost all Races except for Hawaii. I highly agree that mass starts are better than rolling starts or wave starts at most races, and although there is a fairly rough first 200 m and then all sorts itself out for most of the day.
The problem with Hawaii is that the swimmers come out in a much tighter window - 55 min - 70. If you do the math, there simply is not enough room on the bike course to prevent serious drafting. That is the Dilemma in Hawaii. I think they have done the best they can but it is difficult situation.
As an over 65 male I started in front of all of the fast people. I got clobbered in the last quarter of the swim (even though I am a fast swimmer), and was exposed to some pretty reckless bike riding by the younger athletes. There have been several threads of the issues that the older females had. The problem is what can you do about it.
Personally, my experience has been that rolling starts are the worst situation. Almost nobody places themself properly and it seems like it is always a cluster. I think I understand the reasoning and thought process, I just think there are more cons than pros. And for those who are trying to compete for a spot you really have no idea who you are racing against. Sometimes you donāt know where you have placed until 30, or more, minutes after you finish.
I commend Ironman for their efforts to confront an issue that does not have a perfect solution. Iām really not sure what you do in Hawaii other than the way they did it this past year.
Interesting that you say this David as I felt the same thing at 70.3 WC in Nice. I describe the descent of the Col de Vence as an hour of āwhite knuckle funā which was made more enjoyable by trains of younger athletes bombing down the descent past me while cursing that I was in their way. Unfortunately, the French werenāt that big on road in some sections and, although Ironman did a great job of marking the hazards in orange paint, many times the majority of the right side of the road was not good to ride on. I know well enough to hug the right side but road conditions didnāt present a safe option there many times. Iāve never been treated as poorly by other athletes during an event in my racing career. I guess I donāt feel like the yelling and cursing is necessary. I know that Iāll probably get panned by the crowd for my thoughts and encouraged to go race with the females ⦠oh well, just wanted to share a seemingly situation in Nice.
I was in that same wave. I swam outside on the way down and back and was pretty much on my own without any contact until about 25meters from the pier.
I guess my āpersonalā complaint is that having started in that early wave I was passed by over two thousand athletes on the bike, something Iāve never experienced before, and that was depressing, very depressing
Note sure if this is useful, but given my idea of having the men start and then 30 minutes later the women start, I gave chatgpt the csv of race results and asked it to table the amount of athletes arriving every 5 minutes to see how many youād have in transition at once.
No idea if this makes it a cluster or not in transition or on the bike.
From an operations stand point, I donāt like having transition open so long and virtually no one is in it the last 30%. Seems to be a poorly utilized resource from that perspective. But is getting people on the course faster a better trade off? Maybe they can use that extra gap to start the relay
If you want to reduce the density further, Youād have to do something like M18-44 all together, 20 minutes later, M45+ all together, and then all Women together. Kind of a hybrid version of what we do.
Iād assume the women starting together would like starting as a mass group in a nod to their own race?
Either I misunderstand or your information is wrong. According to your graph/table you donāt any women out under 1.20 (ish) and I do not think that is right at all. Unless of course you use the actual time of day start times instead of raw swim times. Raw swim times is what is needed in order to see where the grouping of the athletes are if youāre going to try to modify the start order. Do I have this right or am I missing something
Assuming women start 30 minutes after the men, the first women come in around 35 minutes after the first man. Seems about right. The 5 min buckets could be off by one, but for just a quick look itās close enough.
The problem is still 55 - 70 minutes after the start you have over 750 men come out in that short window. Do the math and the bike course simply cannot handle it without mass packs. Hawaii is the only place where it is that drastic.