Isn't it time to stop whining about WMD?

I have been listening to this WMD whining for nearly two years now. It is like fingers on a chalk board to me, since saying that is the reason we went into Iraq is just revisionist history. It was one of many reasons, and never the most important reason.

So I went back to some old Bush speeches and pulled up one that was on target. The title of the speech was “Bush presents Vision of Middle East.” He gave it in February, 2003, a month or two before the invasion. The pull quote is:


“A liberated Iraq can show the power of freedom to transform that vital region, by bringing hope and progress into the lives of millions. America’s interests in security, and America’s belief in liberty, both lead in the same direction: to a free and peaceful Iraq.”


The whole speech is here: http://belgrade.usembassy.gov/iraq/030227a.html
Everything in that speech is happening now, two years later.

Isn’t it time to stop the whining, recognize the facts on the ground, just admit the guy was right and move on?

Oooh, but whining and crying about how life isn’t fair is soooooo much more fun.
I miss John Kerry. He was fun to laugh at.
And when was the last time Bush did anything corny? I must say, I’m very disapointed in the current political system. I think I’m going to go back to watching the Comedy Channel. CNN sucks.

Sounds like you’re the one doing the whining.

“This war is and was about weapons of mass destruction.” Ari Fleischer


So tell me again, how did this bad person revise history? I said possession of WMD was one of many reasons.

You usually argue more persuasively than just setting up straw men.

Want more? How about this quote:


“Without this outside support for terrorism, Palestinians who are working for reform and long for democracy will be in a better position to choose new leaders. True leaders who strive for peace; true leaders who faithfully serve the people. A Palestinian state must be a reformed and peaceful state that abandons forever the use of terror,”


The word prescient (sp?)comes to mind.

No problem. Ignore the visionary speech which is coming true from the man who sets the policy. Instead fall back on one out of context sentence by a harried press secretary from two years ago.

Why not just wallow in the past of Florida 2000?

FYI, the date is March 4, 2005.

Talk about revisionist history. Why is it when President Clinton made the same claims (along with John Kerry) it was OK with the liberals but when President Bush says the EXACT same thing he misled and lied to the USA?

Where are the WMDs, President Clinton?
By Observer Viewpoint
Published: Friday, October 17, 2003
Article Tools:Email This ArticlePrint This Article Page 1 of 2Next Page

Over the last five years, leaders of the Democratic Party have blatantly led the public to assume that Saddam Hussein possessed or intended to possess weapons of mass destruction despite recent evidence which may prove to the contrary.

On Feb. 17, 1998, President Bill Clinton boldly asserted, “We want to seriously diminish the threat posed by Iraq’s weapons of mass destruction program.” Incidentally, he made no reference to an international coalition including countries such as France, Germany and Russia as imperative to any military campaign aimed at disarmament and liberation of the Iraqi people.

The very next day both Secretary of State Madeline Albright and National Security Adviser Sandy Berger issued warnings to the same effect. Albright made perfectly clear the stance of the Clinton administration by stating that the possibility of Hussein “using nuclear, chemical or biological weapons against us or our allies is the greatest security threat we face.” Berger echoed her sentiments by claiming that " will use those weapons of mass destruction again, as he has 10 times since 1983."

These are powerful words. Granted, they came from an administration with a documented history of misleading the public in every way, shape or form, so they may be suspect. Still, I always assumed that the Democratic Party was one of peace, never interested in starting a war against a sovereign power unless an imminent threat existed.

A letter to Clinton signed on Oct. 9, 1998 by Senators Carl Levin, Tom Daschle, John Kerry and others urged the commander-in-chief to “take necessary actions … to respond effectively to the threat posed by Iraq’s refusal to end its weapons of mass destruction programs.” So much for Democratic opposition to a U.S.-led war against a brutal, dictatorial regime.

Fast-forward to the year 2003. The party of “opposition” to President George W. Bush’s purportedly unilateral war of aggression against a sovereign nation slams him for blatantly misleading the American public into thinking weapons of mass destruction existed at any time. In the six months since the end of major military action, occupying troops have found no smoking gun and Democrats couldn’t be happier. Behind their backs they cross their fingers and hope none will surface. Understandably, no one enjoys the taste of his own foot in his mouth. Continued…

However, it is difficult to ignore the warnings that emanated from the most powerful ranks in the Democratic party, such as the statements made by Al Gore and Senator Edward Kennedy just over a year ago. In his superior wisdom, Gore declared, “We know that has stored secret supplies of biological and chemical weapons throughout his country.” Kennedy, perhaps harkening back to Clinton’s comments a few years prior, said, “We have known for many years that Saddam Hussein is seeking and developing weapons of mass destruction.”

The quotes go on, too plentiful to be listed in this limited column. The best defense they can conjure if ever anyone confronts them on these points is that Bush blatantly misled them as well by presenting skewed intelligence reports overstating the existence of the Iraqi’s weapons of mass destruction programs. Hillary Clinton’s allegation of a “vast right-wing conspiracy” comes to mind, starting at the top with Bush, Cheney and Rumsfeld, continuing down to the pundits like Rush Limbaugh and his disciples on Clear Channel radio. Make no mistake, this neoconservative push to unilaterally dominate the world comes in spite of Bush’s sheer incompetence and utter stupidity - a curious yet self-serving contradiction for Democrats.

As the ever-increasing field of Democratic presidential hopefuls sling more mud at Bush by claiming he and he alone inflated the claims of Iraqi weapons programs, one must conclude that they are relying on either the impeccable short-term memory or the logical ineptitude of the average American citizen. Such tactics make my stomach turn as I consider what once called itself the party of the people.

Are we to forget that Democrats have a recent history of condemning Iraq’s weapons programs and suggesting military action for their removal when their fingers point squarely at Bush? Should we exempt presidential hopefuls who approved a resolution giving the president the power to use force in Iraq and backed up their vote as more than passive acquiescence if we believe that no weapons ever existed? Can we not admit that Saddam was probably clever enough to remove any vestiges of a weapons program to neighboring friendly countries in the months before the seemingly inevitable war, or should we jump to the naive conclusion that if we can’t find any smoking guns then they never existed in the first place?

Considering the angry rhetoric spewed forth by today’s Democratic Party after years of believing in the existence of Iraqi weapons of mass destruction, their accusations of Bush blatantly misleading the nation reek of partisan political hypocrisy.

Art, you’re wasting breath. You and I both know that WMD was not the single reason for going to war. However, it is not revisionism when people say that we were convinced to go to war based on the threat of the spread of WMD. Colin Powell stood in front f the UN and showed pictures of what we thought were wmd production trailers. Every speech talked about WMD and it’s proliferation. The administration decided that wmd was the best way to sell the invasion to the domestic and international communities, and then when they didn’t find any, they needed to start talking about all the other reasons for going. You can’t repeat the same thing over and over again to sell war, and then not expect people to expect results with regard to the thing you were selling.

I don’t deny that WMD was a part of the reason to go to Iraq. I don’t deny the intelligence was faulty. I don’t deny that WMD was a big part of the sales pitch.

My point is that many other important reasons were advanced as well. I found them very persuasive, possibly because I listened to them while trying to ignore all the BS.

All of those reasons articulate by Bush and laughed at much the way Reagan was laughed at in Berlin (Mr. Gorbechev, tear down this wall) have proven valid.

It is time to stop wallowing in the one miscalculation of the distant past and acknowledge reality and the terrific opportunities on the ground.

Or not.

WMD whining for nearly two years now. It is like fingers on a chalk board to me, since saying that is the reason we went into Iraq is just revisionist history. It was one of many reasons, and never the most important reason.

I’m sorry, Art, but that’s a flat out lie.

Isn’t it time to stop the whining, recognize the facts on the ground, just admit the guy was right and move on?

Facts on the ground? What are you smoking tonight, Art?

ok, here’s the premise: both the dems and republicans both “blatantly misled” the public re: saddam and wmd’s with faulty info. now here’s the difference: a dem administration didn’t use that faulty info as a basis for going to war. they didn’t present iffy info in front of the u.n. to garner support for the subsequent invasion. they didn’t make claims in a sotu address about saddam’s attempt to gain elements for more powerful wmd’s as a means to drum up support for the war. the fact that the bush has us in iraq with soldiers dying and the cost of war mounting in a big way makes the situation different.

Instead fall back on one out of context sentence by a harried press secretary from two years ago.

a) how was the quote out of context?

b) you seem to indicate that he was flustered and slipped up a bit when making that statement. but isn’t that a bit dismissive? this guy is paid to be a spokesman and do message/spin control. it’s his job not to mess up and stay on message, especially in this admin whose defining characteristic is the ability to “stay on message”. moreover, it’s not like there aren’t other quotes out there along the same lines as the one by fleischer.

Speaking of intelligence, but not the faulty variation, and certainly far removed from any Bush has:

“Only two things are infinite, the universe and human stupidity, and I’m not sure about the former.” --Albert Einstein

-Robert
.

I am not lying or engaging in revisionist history. This is what some guy named vitus asked me nearly one year ago now.


Now I guess the question is, just what are we trying to accomplish in Iraq? Seriously. Someone please spell it out for me. We went there because Hussein was a bad guy who was a threat. I’ll grant that premise for the sake of argument. He’s gone now. What are we hoping to accomplish by staying there?

I answered:

We are trying to undermine the sick culture of the Middle East that has allowed it, alone in the entire world, to make no social, political and economic progress for any number of decades or even centuries. We are doing this by establishing a successful model of freedom and democracy in the heart of the region.

Roll the tape forward two or three decades. Success in Iraq will undermine the dictatorships in the other 21 Arab countries. The end result will be freedom which is the engine of progress. The radicals are desperate to prevent this since it will destroy their power. Thus we have the attacks in Iraq which were completely predictable and predicted. More of the same will continue for many years. The cost in blood and treasure will be substantial.


Look at the facts on the ground. The insurgents have basically lost since they have nothing, no philosophy, no policy, nothing to appeal to the hearts and minds. Much work remains, but it is pretty clear how things are going to sort out. We have elections sweeping all over that part of the world. Things are breaking our way, even in Lebanon and Syria of all places.

I am smoking nothing, just understanding the historic moments we see unfolding.

You confuse the sizzle with the steak. WMD was the sizzle that made the steak more saleable. It turned out to be incorrect, but the steak was always the reason to go there.

The steak had many components. Here is another one from the same speech:


The first to benefit from a free Iraq would be the Iraqi people, themselves. Today they live in scarcity and fear, under a dictator who has brought them nothing but war, and misery, and torture. Their lives and their freedom matter little to Saddam Hussein – but Iraqi lives and freedom matter greatly to us.

Bringing stability and unity to a free Iraq will not be easy. Yet that is no excuse to leave the Iraqi regime’s torture chambers and poison labs in operation. Any future the Iraqi people choose for themselves will be better than the nightmare world that Saddam Hussein has chosen for them.


As the answer to the question in the title of this thread, I guess I will put you down as a no. Not only do you want to wallow in the one miscalculation of two plus years ago rather than the many brilliant calculations enabling the nearly unbelievable current driving freedom in southwest Asia, you also want to wallow in one sentence from one former press secretary.

Talk about missing the forest.

either respond to the point of my post or don’t respond at all.

moreover, you are way jumping the gun with the “unbelievable current driving freedom” nonsense.

fthe fact is, this admin threw a bunch of crap against the wall and is seeing what is sticking with respect to the justification of the war. first they tested the wmd angle. then it was a preemptive move against terrorism. now it’s iraqi liberation. that’s revisionism at its finest.

you accuse me of wanting to “wallow” in “one sentence” from fleischer. meanwhile, you pick out one quote from a speech as the basis for the new justification for this war. give me a break.

lastly, i’m sorry if i am concerned about the process and the mistakes made therein and won’t go for the ends justify the means approach…

The quote was out of context because I have heard Ari verbalize many of these same reasons before. He didn’t do it as well as Bush, as would be expected. Also, I didn’t vote for Ari. Ari doesn’t set policy. He is just a communications vehicle, much like a fax machine.

So why don’t you respond to the Bush quotes from before the war? Want another that looks to be right out of a crystal ball?


And as the terror threat is removed and security improves, the new government of Israel “will be expected to support the creation of a viable Palestinian state and to work as quickly as possible toward a final status agreement,” he said. “As progress is made toward peace, settlement activity in the occupied territories must end. And the Arab states will be expected to meet their responsibilities to oppose terrorism, to support the emergence of a peaceful and democratic Palestine, and state clearly they will live in peace with Israel.”

“Old patterns of conflict in the Middle East can be broken, if all concerned will let go of bitterness, hatred, and violence, and get on with the serious work of economic development, and political reform, and reconciliation,” the president said.


Does it get any more prophetic than that?

If you sell the steak with a whole lot of sizzle, then you don’t get to be surprised when the customer is pissed that there is no sizzle once the steak is on his plate. The administration sold this war as a means to prevent the spread of WMD, now they will have to expect to answer questions about why there weren’t any. If they had sold it based on some of the other reasons, they might have been closer to the truth, but might not have gotten enough support to go to war. They made a judgement that going to war for all the actual reasons was worth selling the WMD and risking pissing people off later on when there were none.

Also, I find it interesting in your post from however long ago that you said the Middle East is the only region in the world that is left behind. Not very astute.

what do you want me to respond to? i don’t see where the quote you just posted has any bearing on the revisionism that is occurring re: the war in iraq. there is a distinction to be made between the primary motivation for going to war and the ancillary benefits that come along afterwards. this war was packaged under the heading of protection of american interests via removal of wmd’s, removal of an imminent threat to the u.s., and removal of a terrorist haven. wmd’s took the lead in that justification. just because bush mentions something as an afterthought in a speech doesn’t change the overall reasoning for why we went to war. i remember how the war was sold. it wasn’t about iraqi liberation.

with respect to israel-palestine, show me where he predicted arafat’s demise and then i will label him nostradamus, because it was arafat’s death that is providing the catalyst in that situation. or to put it another way, did he have any policies that have led to the current round of talks between israel and the palestinians? do you think bush alone was the only person that could predict that if terrorism against israel trailed off there would be changes in the israeli-palestinian relations?

I am not lying or engaging in revisionist history. This is what some guy named vitus asked me nearly one year ago now.

We went there because Hussein was a bad guy who was a threat. I’ll grant that premise for the sake of argument.

Note that the premise I was granting for the sake of argument was that Hussein was actually a threat that warranted going to war over. Which was, in truth, the reason provided for the war. The rest of the question I was asking about a year ago was related to what we were *still doing *in Iraq, now that the stated reason for invading no longer existed. Which sort of proves the point, I think.

You’re engaging in the same thing now after the fact that war supporters engaged in at the time- throw a dozen justifications into the mix, and hope one sticks. The reason for the war continues to evolve, which is amazing. First we had terrorism, except that turned out to be a lie, then we had WMDs, except that turned out to be a lie, now we have freedom and democracy for the Iraqis for our retroactive reason for going to war. I wonder what the reason will be when that project doesn’t pan out.

Much work remains, but it is pretty clear how things are going to sort out.

Really? Clue me in- how’s it going to turn out, and when can we expect the results?