Is swimming easier when you're fat?

I’m fairly lean and long and for a long time I struggled with “swimming uphill”, i.e. my hips and legs dropping lower than my upper body.

Because of injury, for the last six months I haven’t run or biked and I’ve been working only on my swimming stroke. Because I haven’t been able to run or bike, over that same period I’ve gained 10 - 15 pounds. (The liter of egg nog a day probably had something to do with it as well :wink:

Recently I realized that my swimming has gotten easier and I’m better able to balance my body in the water. It’s almost like before when I swam with a pull buoy… I could swim twice as long as I could without. My question is:

Is my swimming easier and balance better because I’ve been working on my stroke, or because of the 10-15 pounds of fat around my waist (acting as a pull buoy)?

I’m carrying an extra pound or 40, and I firmly believe that balance is much easier for me because of the added bouyancy.

As for running, however…

Tom

If you look at Olympic swimmers they all appear quite lean, but I’ve known some fat swimmers who are very fast. There’s this one woman who is quite heavy. She does the swim portion as part of a team at our local area sprint tris. She’s always one of the first out of the water.

Hi,

More fat adds buoyancy but also means more weight to move over your hands, - harder to pull.

Your head is up if your legs are down. Head position dictates body position. Get your head down. Practice this by looking directly down at the bottom of the pool when you swim: go slower if you have to.

Do you swim and push off the wall in the streamline position? (Hands clasped together above your head with your elbows absolutely locked, arms straight, and head down between your arms in front)?

Yes, fat works the same as a wetsuit.

Lean sinks. Fat floats.

Lean sinks. Fat floats.

That’s not entirely true… muscle is mostly water.

Fat floats well, muscle floats OK, BONE sinks. The worst is to be lean AND bony.

Lean sinks. Fat floats.

That’s not entirely true… muscle is mostly water.

Fat floats well, muscle floats OK, BONE sinks. The worst is to be lean AND bony.

From what I understand, our bodies on average are made up of approximately 60-65 percent water, of which muscle is made up of 70 percent water while fat is only 22 percent. Regarding buoyancy the percent of water is irrelevant, it’s the density of the tissue. Fat is less dense and more buoyant than muscle. (Ever heard of hydrostatic body fat testing?)

So… I know body fat makes you more buoyant… I’m just wondering how much a factor 10-15 extra pounds is. I’m suspecting my fat is helping me more than my stroke work. I’ll guess I’ll see this Summer when I’m a lean, mean, racing machine.

I know one thing for sure, when the water is cold a little (or a lot of) fat is a good thing!

Right. So fat floats, muscle floats OKish, and bone sinks!

Lean sinks. Fat floats.

That’s not entirely true… muscle is mostly water.

Fat floats well, muscle floats OK, BONE sinks. The worst is to be lean AND bony.

Contradicting (and confusing) yourself again?