In 500 years, what will western music historians say about the 20th century?

You’re making shit up.

when the dust has all settled, and the few survivors of the Ebola epidemic reground and rebuild - the 2 World Wars will be mentioned . . . but only the 60’s will receive much attention, the other decades were forgettable.

sorry, not believing you haven’t heard of Hank Williams. That said, the answer to your question is one word; Menudo!

You’re making shit up.

Whatever.

……the fact you might not have heard of someone means very little.

Actually it means everything. If a musician is to stand the test of time, shouldn’t his music (and name) be recognizable by the masses? I’ve heard of Johnny Cash, but not Hank Williams. Why?

because Cash covered a Nine Inch Nails “Hurt”.

Leo Fender
Les Paul
Donald Leslie
Laurens Hammond
.

It might be useful to look at who people are still listening today. Also think about who has had more of worldwide or at least Western world wide impact. Not sure anyone really cares about country music outside of N. America, whereas The Beatles, Michael Jackson, Pink Floyd and the like were much bigger phenomena.

You’re making shit up.

Actually he’s right. Mozart, for example, was a complete sell out (and that’s not sarcasm).

I don’t know why, but he’s really famous, and definitely a name recognized by the masses. I can’t imagine there’s anyone who knows much about country music who doesn’t at least recognize his name.

I know we are sorta beating up on a tangent here, but I think its important to the greater point. Most people who don’t listen to country don’t know shit about it. I can probably name, off the top of my head, 5-10 country artists, and maybe four modern country songs. From before 1990 I can name Willie Nelson, Kenny Rodgers, and Dolly Parton.

Its gotta be difficult for someone who maybe lives or grew up in an area where people commonly listen to country, but it is almost as if it doesn’t exist in my circle of influence. And keep in mind, its not me being a closed minded idiot. I hang out with musicians. I go to shows. People are constantly sharing videos on my Facebook feed. When I grew up, we were constantly trading tapes and CDs back and forth. Country was never and still is not a part of that.

Having said that, how many people can say that about Michael Jackson? Who can say that about The Beatles?

Garth Brooks is the 16th best selling artist of all time. Taylor Swift is 32nd. Kenny Rodgers is 40th. These are the top 3. Their combined sales is just over half of what The Beatles have sold (or just over half of what Elvis has sold). I’m not saying that country isn’t significant, or that Hank Williams wasn’t a talented influence (at least according to wikipedia), but its a more specific genre that doesn’t have much appeal outside of its fan base. The Beatles, Elvis, and Michael Jackson had a much wider appeal across genres and demographics.

Won’t the planet be a flaming ball of CO2 by then?

No people will just contract malaria in Alaska.

Most people who don’t listen to country don’t know shit about it.

Most Americans don’t know shit about classical music, but that doesn’t prevent Mozart, Bach, Brahms, etc from being notable composers and important influences, especially when you’re talking about what the music historians will write in a few centuries.

Country music, like it or not, has been a significant influence on rock, blues, etc. It has been an important part of the musical development of the US, a country which has played a key role in the 20th and moving into the 21st centuries. It’s not going to be forgotten by music scholars.

Its gotta be difficult for someone who maybe lives or grew up in an area where people commonly listen to country, but it is almost as if it doesn’t exist in my circle of influence. And keep in mind, its not me being a closed minded idiot. I hang out with musicians. I go to shows. People are constantly sharing videos on my Facebook feed. When I grew up, we were constantly trading tapes and CDs back and forth. Country was never and still is not a part of that.

It may not be about you being a closed minded idiot, but it certainly is about you having a relatively small musical influence circle. If you went to a different set of bars with different friends, they probably wouldn’t have heard of lots of the artists you and your friends consider central to whatever you’re making.

Having said that, how many people can say that about Michael Jackson? Who can say that about The Beatles?

Well, you’re talking there about 2 of the top selling artists of all time. There are hundreds of artists who never sold as many records who are still very influential, notable, and important to music. It’s kind of hard to hold those two examples as the standard. It would be like saying there aren’t any important scientists unless they’re as well known as Einstein.

The problem we have today, compared to 500 years ago, is that we have a gazillion specific and distinct genres. It’s much easier to find yourself only listening to a narrow scope of musical influence, and ignoring a lot of other music. Even among country music fans, you could be listening mostly to Bluegrass, honky tonk, hillbilly boogie, folk, gospel, country soul, rockabilly, country rock, country pop, outlaw country, neocountry, truck driving country, alt country, and probably plenty of others.

You asked about who is most notable, and about who was the best. The two aren’t necessarily the same thing.

The most notable (as I mentioned) is easy to figure based on record sales. The best, as they will be defined by music historians, is much more difficult.

Aretha Franklin is way down on the list with 75million. Do you think music historians won’t consider her to be more important than Rhianna? Bob Marley is way down on the list. Don’t you think music historians will consider him more important than Katy Perry?

I’ve never seen him on MTV.

Won’t the planet be a flaming ball of CO2 by then?

Nope, but half the population will gone after ebola is done with us.

Most people who don’t listen to country don’t know shit about it.

Most Americans don’t know shit about classical music, but that doesn’t prevent Mozart, Bach, Brahms, etc from being notable composers and important influences, especially when you’re talking about what the music historians will write in a few centuries.

Country music, like it or not, has been a significant influence on rock, blues, etc. It has been an important part of the musical development of the US, a country which has played a key role in the 20th and moving into the 21st centuries. It’s not going to be forgotten by music scholars.

Its gotta be difficult for someone who maybe lives or grew up in an area where people commonly listen to country, but it is almost as if it doesn’t exist in my circle of influence. And keep in mind, its not me being a closed minded idiot. I hang out with musicians. I go to shows. People are constantly sharing videos on my Facebook feed. When I grew up, we were constantly trading tapes and CDs back and forth. Country was never and still is not a part of that.

It may not be about you being a closed minded idiot, but it certainly is about you having a relatively small musical influence circle. If you went to a different set of bars with different friends, they probably wouldn’t have heard of lots of the artists you and your friends consider central to whatever you’re making.

Having said that, how many people can say that about Michael Jackson? Who can say that about The Beatles?

Well, you’re talking there about 2 of the top selling artists of all time. There are hundreds of artists who never sold as many records who are still very influential, notable, and important to music. It’s kind of hard to hold those two examples as the standard. It would be like saying there aren’t any important scientists unless they’re as well known as Einstein.

The problem we have today, compared to 500 years ago, is that we have a gazillion specific and distinct genres. It’s much easier to find yourself only listening to a narrow scope of musical influence, and ignoring a lot of other music. Even among country music fans, you could be listening mostly to Bluegrass, honky tonk, hillbilly boogie, folk, gospel, country soul, rockabilly, country rock, country pop, outlaw country, neocountry, truck driving country, alt country, and probably plenty of others.

You asked about who is most notable, and about who was the best. The two aren’t necessarily the same thing.

The most notable (as I mentioned) is easy to figure based on record sales. The best, as they will be defined by music historians, is much more difficult.

**Aretha Franklin is way down on the list with 75million. Do you think music historians won’t consider her to be more important than Rhianna? Bob Marley is way down on the list. Don’t you think music historians will consider him more important than Katy Perry?

Agree, I don’t think album sales has anything to do with how influential an artist is. JJ Cale was very influential and will always be remembered for writing After Midnight, The Breeze and Cocaine. I believe in 500 years those who specialize in music history will look at influences as well as album sales.

American Music alone from the 20th century:

Don Ellis
Stan Kenton
Don Sebesky
Aaron Copland
George Gershwin
Leonard Bernstein
John Adams
Samuel Barber
John Williams
Stephen Sondheim

Just naming a few off the top of my head without even getting into rock or pop. Definitely a century were an American identity was forged!

Paul Mccartney!

If I was ranking the all-around best musician of the 20th century it would be him. Not sure what you criteria for the most notable “artists” is, but I think one has to differentiate between those who were mostly just singers and those who are more singer-songwriters and/or also instrument-playing musicians.

In terms of chart success, which is more easy to measure and also artistic talent and expression I think he’s by far the best. He wrote 32 Billboard #1’s and also has 24 U.K. #1’s.

Great range in terms of style in both singing and instrumentation. Take for example Helter Skelter (First-ever heavy metal song), Maybe I’m Amazed, Martha My Dear, Lady Madonna, Yesterday, or even Say Say Say and Ebony and Ivory his two duets with Michael Jackson and Stevie Wonder respectively which were both the biggest ever hits for those two artists on the Billboard charts and all of which he wrote himself. And beyond that he’s also branched out in classical music and electronic music. Plus he plays essentially every traditional rock instrument including bass, guitar, keyboards, piano and drums. Ranked the #11 best singer of all time by Rolling Stone and #3 bass player in a reader poll on there.

His song Yesterday is the most-covered song of all time. Mull of Kintyre was one of the most successful songs in the U.K. ever. He’s in his 70s and his most recent album went to #3 in the U.S. and U.K. charts. He’s also received countless awards including 18 Grammys and been knighted for services to music. In my opinion there’s no argument that anyone has been better than Paul.

It may not be about you being a closed minded idiot, but it certainly is about you having a relatively small musical influence circle. If you went to a different set of bars with different friends, they probably wouldn’t have heard of lots of the artists you and your friends consider central to whatever you’re making.

You are really stretching to try and make a point.

You think there are music bars where the crowds go, “Michael Jackson? The Beatles? Elvis? What are you talking about? I’ve never heard of these guys?”

Oh sure, they may never have heard of Ronnie James Dio, or Rob Halford, or Johhny Ramone, but then I again, I never argued that these guys would be bigger or more notable than The Beatles or Michael Jackson.

It may not be about you being a closed minded idiot, but it certainly is about you having a relatively small musical influence circle. If you went to a different set of bars with different friends, they probably wouldn’t have heard of lots of the artists you and your friends consider central to whatever you’re making.

You are really stretching to try and make a point.

You think there are music bars where the crowds go, “Michael Jackson? The Beatles? Elvis? What are you talking about? I’ve never heard of these guys?”

Oh sure, they may never have heard of Ronnie James Dio, or Rob Halford, or Johhny Ramone, but then I again, I never argued that these guys would be bigger or more notable than The Beatles or Michael Jackson.

http://media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m520z0XJyZ1rquf2k.gif

It may not be about you being a closed minded idiot, but it certainly is about you having a relatively small musical influence circle. If you went to a different set of bars with different friends, they probably wouldn’t have heard of lots of the artists you and your friends consider central to whatever you’re making.

You are really stretching to try and make a point.

You think there are music bars where the crowds go, “Michael Jackson? The Beatles? Elvis? What are you talking about? I’ve never heard of these guys?”

Oh sure, they may never have heard of Ronnie James Dio, or Rob Halford, or Johhny Ramone, but then I again, I never argued that these guys would be bigger or more notable than The Beatles or Michael Jackson.

Nobody has argued that Hank Williams is bigger or more notable than The Beatles or Michael Jackson either, so I don’t know what you’re yammering on about now.