Are all you defenders of Guantanamo and waterboarding comfortable with the practice and its legality knowing that an American soldier is now a captive of the Taliban and can only expect to be treated as well as we treat our prisoners?
If the Taliban limit their “Torture” to waterboarding I’m OK with that. If it where my son I’d much rather him be water boarded than broken bones, hands cut off, eyes poked out, dipped in acid etc.
I would hope that we don’t treat all “Prisoners” equally either. Capturing an infantry man is very different than capturing a upper level officer. The officers should expect to be tortured, not so much for the low level guys.
~Matt
I would expect no less than that. You really think that he will be treated any better than Daniel Pearl?
You have no ground to stand on here cheif. I only wish we would have really tortured these terrorsits before Obama came in and is the most pathetic idiot since Jimmy Carter on International Policy.
Burn in hell you evil mean ignorant jerk. Why did god give you no soul you may ask? He knew you were devil spawn from the instant the sperm hit the egg.
He will be a lucky man if all he experiences is waterboarding.
Burn in hell you evil mean ignorant jerk.
Considering my stance on many subjects including the existence of god…well isn’t that a given? In fact when I happen into a church I occasionally burst into flames.
~Matt
**Are all you defenders of Guantanamo and waterboarding comfortable with the practice and its legality knowing that an American soldier is now a captive of the Taliban and can only expect to be treated as well as we treat our prisoners? **
#1. I wasn’t aware the Taliban is a signatory to the Geneva Conventions. Besides their being a terrorist group, what nation are they heading up?
#2. As soon as they think that soldier is of no use to them, they’re going to cut his head off. On video, which will soon make its way to the Internet.
You don’t know anything about the circumstances of this young private’s capture or how he ended up in their hands. As to this question of Gitmo and waterboarding? Absolutely, I’m comfortable with it. What does one have to do with the other? You think if we stopped detaining enemy combatants and terrorists at Gitmo and never again waterboarded a whole three detainees that people like the Taliban or Jemaah Islamiyah would stop their struggle against Western culture and ideology?
You really need to read up on Sayed Qutb, the belief system of a Talib and what J.I. believes in and advocates. Maybe also learn a little about *taqqiyah *and and the more radical strains of Islam before trying for a “teachable moment.”
T.
We’ll all be relieved if he’s treated no worse than the most “abused” gitmo prisoner.
"Are all you defenders of Guantanamo and waterboarding comfortable with the practice and its legality knowing that an American soldier is now a captive of the Taliban and can only expect to be treated as well as we treat our prisoners? "
You’re a funny guy. If our captured Soldiers could only be expected to be treated as well as we treat our prisoners, and not the way the Taliban usually treats their prisoners, we’d be in good shape.
If you think the Taliban limits their techniques based on what is accepted by the American public, you’re kidding yourself.
It is sad when the Atheist in the room is the only one that believes in “do unto others”
.
- I would hope that we don’t treat all “Prisoners” equally either. Capturing an infantry man is very different than capturing a upper level officer. The officers should expect to be tortured, not so much for the low level guys.*
I don’t think Senator McCain (et al) would necessarily agree.
Oh I don’t believe in “Do unto others”…I just realize that most people do ![]()
~Matt
.
I don’t think Senator McCain (et al) would necessarily agree.
They can disagree all they want but what the point of even interogating some guy that spent the last 2 years in some ditch? You interogate the officers, intergation for many means torturing them.
~Matt
It is sad when the Atheist in the room is the only one that believes in “do unto others”
The atheist in the room would be the first person to have his throat cut by a Talib
Atheists rank up there with pagans in their belief system. The fact this fellow is nominally Christian (at least, the Taliban believe that), and therefore someone mentioned in the Book (the Qur’an) might actually buy him a little consideration before they of course cut off his head when they have no more use for him.
T.
One has nothing to do with other, and that’s exactly the point. Just because the Taliban treats our people worse doesn’t justify the American government torturing people too.
Just because the Taliban treats our people worse doesn’t justify the American government torturing people too.
Finally some common sense.
I’m always amazed at how many can justify things because “the Taliban would do it” instead of saying it is not American policy to torture prisoners because we stand for something more.
America will never win the hearts and minds of the world if they do resort to the things they accuse others of doing. They have a long history of abiding by the rules of war and the Geneva convention and if the Taliban and terrorists succeed in taking that away, they really will win in the long run.
We will never win the “hearts and minds” of the Taliban…
Jeez, what the fark are you thinking.
One has nothing to do with other, and that’s exactly the point. Just because the Taliban treats our people worse doesn’t justify the American government torturing people too.
I’m amazed that a technique which was in the Army FM for interrogation and which more than a few people in government have said was legal at the time is now something that more than a few hysterical lefties feel has made us a nation on a par with the Taliban or more than a few fascist Islamist groups.
It’s not permitted anymore. Bravo. It was also an effective technique, and I recall reading a semi-admission from two WaPo reporters the other day that hey…maybe it really did work on Abu Zubaida, who was one of three AQ types to experience it down in Gitmo, a place which even those Chinese Muslim Uighurs say was a paradise in comparison to local conditions in Afghanistan and elsewhere.
The Constitution’s not meant to be a suicide pact, by the way. And it certainly isn’t meant to be applied to enemy combatants, none of whom wore the uniform of another national army and who were part of a group dedicated to the eradication of the U.S. by any means possible.
High-minded “we’re better’n that” rhetoric is great here in the LR and in the halls of academia. Unfortunately, the barbarians we’re being asked to give everything to will, of course, take what we’re giving, thank us politely, and then boil us in oil anyway.
T.
Why doesn’t Obama just go talk to them and get him back?
and then boil us in oil anyway.
That would be worse than waterboarding too.
~Matt