#1. Larry Thompson. Former Deputy AG over at Justice. African American, too.
#2. Miguel Estrada: Previously filibustered by Dashcle and the Dems for an Appeals Court slot. Hispanic American, and it’d probably be political suicide for the Dems to try to filibuster him, again, given the strength of the new Hispanic voting bloc.
If the administration was looking solely for quality and experience, I’d say Patrick Higginbotham from the 5th Circuit or Richard Arnold from the 8th or Richard Posner from the 7th. Might be nice to pick someone based solely on judicial experience and sheer intellectual capacity. Unfortunately, all of these guys are old white guys who’ve written way too much to ever pass muster in this political climate.
Kick Clarence Thomas up to Chief Justice. Nominate Estrada to replace Thomas. Watch the Democrats figure out how to filibuster more minorities and lose yet more Senate seats.
Ask a tough question next time. This is a no brainer.
Is Jim Baker of PTL fame available? How about Jimmy Swaggart? Whatever, they are all about as good as Clarence Thomas. No standards anymore, just ideology. We’re screwed.
One may be more secular than the others, but there is no intellectual heft there in either case. It’s well known that Thomas is one of the least active judges. Almost never participates in the verbal questioning and has written few opinions of any import. And he has rarely reached a decision that is any different from Scalia.
We all know that Scalia is a much more substantial judge, even though I disagree with him and think he’s overrated. But Scalia won’t get the nod because, hmm, funny enough, he’s not a minority. Looks like Thomas will ride that affirmative action gravy train a little further before he gets in a position to do away with it.
But Scalia won’t get the nod because, hmm, funny enough, he’s not a minority.
Scalia won’t get the nod because 1. He’s white 2. The Left would fall down dead from a collective and massive stroke 3. He’s too conservative for Bush.
Scalia won’t get the nod because 1. He’s white 2. The Left would fall down dead from a collective and massive stroke 3. He’s too conservative for Bush.
I agree with your first conclusion – and it says something interesting about how the right is now finding affirmative action to be political beneficial.
As for 2 and 3, the left won’t find Thomas much more palatable. He is less despised, but certainly not loved.
Meanwhile, Thomas is arguably more conservative than Scalia. There have been a few cases where Scalia has made unexpected decisions, siding with liberals. Almost without exception, Thomas has voted the way that you’d expect.
Scalia is much more deserving than Thomas. Some may not like his reasoning, but he is an intelligent and well read jurist. Thomas is his lap dog. I think GW will promote the person he has just asked to be AG. Another hispanic, he has argued before the Supreme Court that Texas should not honor international treaties that the US has negotiated and signed. More recently, he has argued that the US is not bound by the Geneva convention. A brilliant, unconventional thinker.
I know you are wrong about the Geneva Convention argument. I am guessing you are wrong about the international treaty argument too. Clarence Thomas is no one’s lap dog.
you are wrong about being wrong! public record dude. A Mexican national was arrested and convicted of murder in Texas. He was never allowed to speak with anyone from the Mexican embassy, despite a treaty between US and Mexico. He went before the Supreme Court and when asked about this, he argued that Texas should not have to comly with international treaties. He is also the one who came up with the argument that detainees were not subject to the Geneva convention. Regardless of what you think about the “rights” of convicted murderers or foreign detainees, the reason we have treaties like these is so that US citizens abroad have some legal protection and that US military personnel may have some protection against abuse if captured. It isn’t a liberal conservative thing, it’s about protecting US citizens.
Gist of it is Gonzales goes to AG to give him a chance to prove himself to Bush’s conservative base (they don’t trust him on the all important abortion issue), plus the AG vetting process will clear the waters on the torture memos. Gonzales will be set up to be Bush’s #2 suggestion for the SC. The first will be a more conservative figure (Wilkinson and Luttig - both from the Fed Appeals Ct in Richmond - mentioned, plus Edith Jones and Larry Thompson) at the beginning of Bush’s second term when his political power is at its peak + a payback to his conservative base for getting him reelected.
I vaguely remember the case about the Mexican murderer. My faint memory says that he never asked to speak to anyone from the embassy. You can’t go through the whole process, lose, and then say oops, I never asserted my rights. That is my recollection anyway. Didn’t Texas prevail on that argument? Even if not, so what? Gonzolas argued the state’s case as instructed. Nothing odd there.
It is axiomatic that terrorists are not subject to the Geneva Convention. It is for uniformed soldiers with clear lines of authority. Slam dunk. Again, he just argued the position as instructed by elected authorities.
President Bush will not nominate anyone to the Supreme Court that does not make his conservative base very happy. He can get away with spending a lot of money on programs most conservatives don’t support as long as he nominates people we think are sound to the Court of Appeals and the Supreme Court. On the other hand, if he nominated someone that really irritated us, it would really hurt him politically. So, he’s not going to nominate anyone that would not be welcomed very warmly at a Federalist Society event. (I have never seen anyone not welcomed very politely at a Federalist Society event, but you just get a different reaction when Judge Bork as opposed to Professor Tribe is introduced).
I think that Justice Thomas would be a great Chief Justice, but I doubt he really wants to go back to the US Senate again, do you? Why put yourself through that?
Justice Scalia would also do a great job as well, but I doubt he wants to add the administrative headaches of being Chief Justice to everything else he does.
Chief Justice Miguel Estrada. That would be ironic wouldn’t it? Great personal story, too. It’s fairly rare (but not unprecedented) to nominate someone without judicial experience to become Chief Justice.
What about Ted Olson? I know he just went back to private practice, but he’s argued there so much it would almost be like going back home. Would almost irritate the left as much as the first three.
I thought that President Reagan should have nominated Judge Posner to the Supreme Court instead of Judge Bork. Judge Posner has irritated conservatives on some issue so he won’t he nominated. He is also too old at this point. It’s too bad; he really should have been a Supreme Court Justice.
I do think it’s a crime that Posner, arguably our greatest living jurist, will never get a nod. I doubt Scalia will be named Chief because he’s too much of a hot head and I keep hearing rumors that he wants to step down. I hope our next Chief does a better job then Rehnquist. This is a hopelessly fractured Court, and I believe it’s the job of the Chief to achieve consensus, especially on issues of national import like, say, the 2000 election.