wow, that sucks. Did you still pay him full price? My guy was the exact opposite. sorry to hear about that.
I have been FIST fitted and Serotta fitted (on a Specialized). I think its all about the person fiting you and your repor with them. You have to be clear about what you want and what you are comfortable with.
Cid Jr. from IOS fitted me to my new Cervelo One and took great care at the IMFL expo. He is a great rider and really cares about people and their bikes. My serotta fitter is Paul Levine, who I think is really great and he is local for me. Just my $.02. Hope this helps.