HydroTail Review

I just picked up the HydroTail from all3sports. The thing is all-carbon, aero, light and works a lot like the x-wing I was previously using that seemed to add a couple of lbs. to my bike. I highly recommend this if anyone is looking to lighten up.

http://www.all3sports.com/product_info.php?products_id=4064

I also noticed a screaming deal on the new '07 all-carbon Kuota K-Factor for $2100. I haven’t seen this bike anywhere else and am considering it. Any thoughts?

http://www.all3sports.com/product_info.php?pName=kuota-kfactor-complete-bike-special-2007

Dax

Both products you listed are phenomenal.

The $2100 K FACTOR will be our best selling bike for the year. This is the only full carbon tri bike I am aware of near the $2000 barrier.

Normann Stadler has always been against the rear mount bottle system, until he tried the Hyrdo Tail. He liked the weight and ergonomics so much that he was ready to buy one for Kona. I ended up getting one from the owner, Andrew, tested it, then surprised Normann with a freebie.

Carbon is here to stay!

any suggestions on the best cages to use for this? I have the profile cages on teh X wing and they work OK… some launching and the bands always seem to snap. The one Dan reviewed sounds like you can only put one cage. Also on All3sports is says you can use the X lab nut… it that the part that allows you to carry CO2 and the inflator?

The 105 components should tell you something. I couldn’t imagine dropping that kind of dough for a bike with bottom-of-the-line Shimano. IMO, Kuoto is trying to appeal to the cost conscience “must have carbon” camp. Carbon frames – especially low end ones – are way over-rated. I haven’t ridden a Kuota but I strongly suggest you test ride before you buy. I rode an “affordable” carbon Giant frame that had less personality than a dead fish.

I tested the system with the plastic PROFILE Kage cages and worked well. Normann used the same set up in KONA.

http://www.profile-design.com/2006_product_pages/hydration/kage.html

The only 105 components on there that might be of concern would be the crankset/BB. I don’t know how decent they are, but that’d be an easy upgrade. Chain gets replaced eventually anyways, I’d have a separate cassette for my race wheels, derailleurs are fine since only the rear really matters…looks like a good deal to me, but I’m holding out for a Kalibur.

That is genious!!! Although it doesn’t appear as if you would be able to do that with the hydrotail as the cage looks like it would mount flush to the carbon??

Before anyone starts running around like a BULL within a Picasso exhibit, I want to add my 2 cents about Shimano 105 and the K FACTOR. I want to make sure the Bull does not trample over these great products.

I will start with the Shimano 105/Dura Ace mix that comes on the K Factor. For the Bulls out there that think they have to have DA or Record to go fast, I want to let you know that is not true. Today’s 105 is much better than Shimano’s DA from a few short years back. IMO, the 2 most important elements within a drive train are the rear derailleur and the shifters. The $2100 K FACTOR is equipped with both of these. I am sure there is someone with weight measurement for DA, ULTEG, and 105. I think that most of us would agree that the small difference in weight can easily be made up by cutting out desert for a week and a half.

Normann Stadler has ridden the K Factor many miles. When asking him if he could go fast on this bike if he did not have a Kalibur, he responder, " I have gone very fast for 150k on the K Factor!" The only thing that makes this bike less appealing than the Kalibur for Normann is the taller head tube. Remember that not everyone can be as low and aero as Normann. I have also ridden the K FACTOR. I have ridden it to a 54 min 40 TT. This bike is built for speed while allowing a little more comfort than the Kalibur.

I never give advice on anything unless I have first hand knowledge of what I am talking about. Never bully around a great bike unless you have tried it!

Paul from Kuota

A nice review from Mr. Demerly!!!
http://www.bikesportmichigan.com/bikes/store06bikes/06-kfactor.shtml

Thanks for the input. I would always test ride any frame before I bought it and I would recommend others do the same. I just saw what looked like a great deal and wanted to let people know about it. For what it’s worth, I have ridden Chorus, Record, Dura Ace, Ultegra and 105 and I have to admit I can’t tell much of a difference. In fact, the bike I ride the most has 105 derailleurs and they have served me well. I think if you have the money to spend on components, then go for it, but I agree, this bike looks like it is for the cost conscious who want the benefits and performance of carbon without dipping into the 401k or the kids’ college funds (and there is certainly a market for that).

Dax

We just got them in too- very cool neat and light setup… we are impressed!
note- these cages we put on it are for our display only!!!

Our edited photo
http://img47.imageshack.us/img47/4713/hydratailky1.jpg

http://img78.imageshack.us/img78/4607/sideci7.jpg

http://img295.imageshack.us/img295/8618/bottomgn9.jpg

http://img47.imageshack.us/img47/5317/rearrq1.jpg

Does it accommodate the P3C seatpost?

I was mounting mine using the other holes on the holder. Can you take a close up picture of the inside mounting area so that I can see how you did yours. I like the angle that yours sits on. Thanks.

Ya it will.

I think any cage will work great. You’re gonna find that one of the great advantages of the HydroTail is that it doesn’t launch bottles like rigid metal systems (i.e. X-Lab) do. I think the carbon material provides enough dampening to prevent bottle slinging.

Yes,
See Slowmans review of the HydroTail. He’s got a picture of a HydroTail mounted on a P3C.

You can put up to 3 cages on at once. I think you misunderstood Slowman.

You can put up to 3 cages on at once


Hadn’t noticed that before----I think that will be my new bottle carrier, then!

I agree, a solid product and worth the investment
.

It’s a good looking holder. I think I’ll have one by the time IMAZ rolls around.

-C

Well, I have one of these and just put it on my Litespeed Saber. I have an Aspide Triathgel saddle and and the fit was great. Very tight and solid, no shaking. I have some very inexpensive metal bottle holders on it as I like to be able to make them tighter when I need to have Gatorade and water bottles back there which are handed out at aid staions (I find the $ carbon cages don’t hold aid station bottles well at all). My spare tubular tire bag fits snuggly between the seat post and holder, I actually have it more attached to the inside on the hydrotain instead of the seat post. So far so good…