HRM Help – are speed, distance and downloading abilities REALLY useful?

My somewhat-reliable Timex HRM (old style) crapped out mid-LSD run on Saturday. Took it to my jeweler neighbour, and he confirmed that indeed it was ready for the garbage.

On the plus side, I have a birthday coming up, and my kind parents (who I don’t think really even understand what a HRM is) have offered to get me one. That being said, I’m not interested in wasting money on bells and whistles that, while nice to have, will not affect my training or performance. So here’s the short list:

-Polar S210

-Polar S410

-Polar 625x (somewhat outside the budget)

-Timex Body Link

Caveats/other info:

-My runs frequently go though tree-shaded areas (likely affecting GPS reception)

-I have a bike computer with cadence

-While I have a PC at work, I have a Mac at home, and I don’t think most of the download software works on a Mac

-I’m training for IMC, my first IM, as well as several other distances this summer

For those who have any of the above, do you find having access to speed and distance REALLY affects your training? I mean sure, it’s nice to know your average speed was X, and you went Y on your LSD run, but the fact is that if I look down and notice I’m traveling a bit slower than usual, but at the top end of my zone 2 – I’m not going to make myself go faster just for the hell of it. My thinking is train to time and zone, not speed. And does downloading the info really help?

Your input is always appreciated. Thank you.

I have the Polar S410. I download to a PC. It uses the #$%#@^% sonic link connection which manages to fail at least 70% of the time. I usually can get the data to download eventually but usually not without much swearing (the cat has learned to leave the room when she hears it chirping).

So I would take the S410 off your list unless downloading doesn’t matter to you. The other thing I dislike about it is that you can only download the most recent workout. You lose all the data for previous workouts except for avg/max HR & elapsed time.

On the positive side, when the downloading works, I like to be able to look at the graphs to see where I was during the workout - especially for races.

For those who have any of the above, do you find having access to speed and distance REALLY affects your training? I mean sure, it’s nice to know your average speed was X, and you went Y on your LSD run, but the fact is that if I look down and notice I’m traveling a bit slower than usual, but at the top end of my zone 2 – I’m not going to make myself go faster just for the hell of it. My thinking is train to time and zone, not speed. And does downloading the info really help?

I think testing is an important part of training. I use the Timex GPS unit every month or so to test my tempo run pace and my long run pace. I do not feel any need to use it on a daily basis. I know how hard to do each run workout based on PE and, to a lesser extent, HR.

HR is so damned variable day to day that I cannot for the life of me imagine what value it might be to download it all the time. There are days when my basic 10-mile endurace run pace is below 150 bpm, and others where it’s closer to 160. I have done flat-out open 5ks at an average HR of 180. A month after one of those, I did a half IM where I averaged 180 over the last 6 miles of the run course. What does that HR data tell me? Nothing, that’s what.

I think the cheapest, simplest HR monitor is perfect. The pace unit from Timex or Garmin is interesting, but not essential. In either case, I don’t see any point in storing the data on a computer.

Now, power files on the bike are another matter. Biking is so much more variable than running that I like to use Cycling Peaks software to make sense of longer rides. I like to examine what I just did so that the next time I go out on the same route, I can adjust to get the most out of the workout.

In my opinion if you are using HR just for the sake of gauging your level of exertion and correlate that with training zones then I think some provision for zone alarms along with a computation of average heart rate and download capabiltiy to some graphing software is useful. Beyond that, assuming the thing has a good stop watch, that is about all I need.

I think in a straight HRM the rest is fluff. Perhaps the one exception to this is the Garmin 301. That gives you all the info you need in a user-friendly (IMO) and compact, digestible package. Five Stars *****. Combine it with motionbased.com for the optimal experience.