I stumbled across this little gem in the Executive Department of the South Carolina constitution:
ARTICLE IV.
******EXECUTIVE DEPARTMENT
SECTION 1. Chief Magistrate.
*The supreme executive authority of this State shall be vested in a Chief Magistrate, who shall be styled “The Governor of the State of South Carolina.” (1972 (57) 3171; 1973 (58) 48.) *
*SECTION 2. Qualifications of Governor. * No person shall be eligible to the office of Governor who denies the existence of the Supreme Being; and who on the date of such election has not attained the age of thirty years; and who shall not have been a citizen of the United States and a citizen and resident of this State for five years next preceding the day of election. No person while Governor shall hold any office or other commission (except in the militia) under the authority of this State, or of any other power. (1972 (57) 3171; 1973 (58) 48.)
ARTICLE VI.
OFFICERS
SECTION 2. Person denying existence of Supreme Being not to hold office.
*No person who denies the existence of the Supreme Being shall hold any office under this Constitution. *
To anyone reading in the DC area - please pass this along to the White House, we’re in need of liberation down here.
thats actually pretty cool. They don’t say what supreme being though and theres your out. Whats the big deal anyways? If they don’t want someone in office that doesn’t believe it a supreme being, and you don’t like it, move. There problem solved.
So professing belief in something unknown and unknowable qualifies you for leadership above those who do not? That’s a fairly absurd qualifier, and I would hope that Believers and Nonbelievers alike would understand why that might be an issue in this country.
What exactly is “cool” about state sponsored discrimination? The big deal is that the smaller the minority group, the less likely the majority is to take action when the protection of civil rights are in question. You don’t have to be an atheist (which I am not) to be offended by such a clause, you only have to be an American who understands the value of freedom of religion, separation of church and state, and the need to protect individual rights from a mob rule mentality. In a democratic republic, it is the duty of the majority to protect the rights of the minority, otherwise we’re no different than a theocracy with an elected leader.
Any constitutional scholars here know how the precedents lie between the Federal and State constitutions?
On its face, the quoted clause does seem to run smack in the face of the First Amendment, but given that it’s a State Constitutional clause and not just a “regular law”, can it be struck down in federal court?
I mean, if somebody filed a federal lawsuit over this, would the SCOTUS say “hmm… bad law. you win.” or would they say Sorry, we don’t like this, but it’s in your constitution… gotta take it up with your state legislature and amend it out…"
Seems like we fought a war over these kinds of issues (federal vs. state’s rights) about 145 years ago or so…
You’re right, it was an interesting read. Thank you.
And the answer to my question(s) would seem to make any attempt to remove these clauses from their respective constitutions at least moot and at best a symbolic gesture. They’re already dead law.
Not saying that the “symbolic gesture” would not be a good idea, just that it would have no actual effect on who could get elected or appointed to office.
And the answer to my question(s) would seem to make any attempt to remove these clauses from their respective constitutions at least moot and at best a symbolic gesture. They’re already dead law.
Not saying that the “symbolic gesture” would not be a good idea, just that it would have no actual effect on who could get elected or appointed to office.
Neither changing the constitutions nor winning a victory in the SCOTUS would have any actual effect on who gets elected anyway. There will never be an admittedly atheistic governor in any of the states in question, period. But that’s not really the point. You would think that the flag-waving Americans who reside in these states and claim to love liberty and freedom would support removing blatant discrimination from their constitution that clearly violates the first amendment, specifically when it would have no practical rerpocussions.
The problem is, people will never go out of their way to right a wrong if they feel they will not benefit from it personally and immediately. It’s much easier to remain comfortable in the silent majority, right or wrong. And there’s not a politician alive in this state who will draw attention to it if he values his job.
The problem is, people will never go out of their way to right a wrong if they feel they will not benefit from it personally and immediately. It’s much easier to remain comfortable in the silent majority, right or wrong. And there’s not a politician alive in this state who will draw attention to it if he values his job.
Not arguing your other points. Changing those lines would be amendments I would vote for… unless I was a politician…
I see the problem as:
A) 99% of the population have no idea those clauses even exist…
B) Most of the folks wouldn’t understand the moot-ness of the clauses even if they were shown them…
C) The Religious Right would do a bang-up job of saying any amendment to clean up this little bit of dust is a forcible attempt by the ACLU to drive God out of America, ensuring the failure of any amendment and the political suicide of any proponent.
D) This wrong has already been righted… by the First and Fourteenth Amendments, according to the SCOTUS.
Now, like I said, I’d vote for amendments to change these - if I lived in the requisite state. But I can appreciate the practical reality that that’s not going to happen. One could look at this as a case of the checks-and-balances system actually working - with the SCOTUS righting an actual wrong that just ain’t going to get fixed in the real political world.
Good points. I guess I just find it a bit disturbing that we would (and did) vote to change the definition of marriage as to prevent same-sex couples from marrying, yet let something so obviously incongruent with American values exist unchallenged at the state level.
I don’t know how this would proceed through the legal process, but you would think that if part of the state’s constitution would be ruled unconstitutional at the federal level, then the process of eliminating the offending clause would not be subject to the same proceedural constraints as a standard amendment.