HED Misconceptions

H3 Model Overview

The distinctive three-spoke configuration of the H3 has given it more Tour de France top 10 places, in time trial stages, than any other wheel in the last 10 years, with or without stickers! The shape provides uncompromised handling over flat, hilly or exposed time trial courses, in all weather conditions. As a front wheel it exhibits an aerodynamic efficiency second to none. Fitted to the rear, the outstanding stiffness of the structure translates to optimum power transfer under load. All achieved without the handling drawbacks of a full disc. Little wonder it’s such a common sight at professional level competition.

The shape provides uncompromised handling over flat, hilly or exposed time trial courses, in all weather conditions. As a front wheel it exhibits an aerodynamic efficiency second to none

WTF, how can HED make such statements that are untrue, they expose themselves to legal law suits with that statement, the HED 3 does exactly the opposite of what they say, I tried it out today in windy conditions and what I found is this,

  1. The HED 3 front and rear combo are good for no wind conditions but when there is a breath of wind then you will be all over the road, you can even be affected by passing cars or trucks.

  2. Put a disk in the rear and the HED 3 is somewhat more stable but still compromises handling in windy conditions

  3. Take away the HED3 wheels and put on regular 24 spoked stock wheels and there is no problem with handling in the afforementioned wind conditions

I rode Zipp 404’s all last year and never had any problem with the wind, so its Zipps for me this year.

I’ve said this previously today… I love my 404’s. I want a rear disk for races, but for now my Zipps rock!

So… how do you REALLY feel about HED?

I don’t know where you live, but I almost guarantee it’s windier here (2nd highest average windspeed in the US) and I almost never take my H3’s off. I’m not going to say that the H3’s, or any other deep section wheel, are not affected by crosswinds, but it’s more a bike-handling thing than a wheel thing. Lots of people on motorcycles and bikes stiffen up when hit by crosswinds and that causes all kinds of problems… just go with the flow.

And… if you’re really big (guessing by “Heavy D”) there’s a lot of YOU to blow around as well :wink:

Then perhaps you didnt read number 3 where i put on regular training wheels and had NO problem, I speak from real world experience and this is what I discovered, I wanted to like the HED 3 wheels but couldnt, perhaps they are for much lighter riders, that could be, but for me and my actual test conditions I find that they are false advertisement
.

Then perhaps you didnt read number 3 where i put on regular training wheels and had NO problem

Perhaps you didn’t read where I said “I’m not going to say that the H3’s, or any other deep section wheel, are not affected by crosswinds, but it’s more a bike-handling thing than a wheel thing.”

I see you took “bullshit” out of your subject line :wink:
.

Sorry to hear you’re having handling problems. Glad to see you edited the title!

Handling is a result of several things…and it begins with the geometry of the bike. I have no idea what bike you ride, nor the weight balance of it when you are on it, nor your handling skills. I will say that an H3 by itself on the front of a road bike I once had (disc or no disc) was WAY too much steering force to handle…for MY skill level. An H3 on my Yaqui, however, isn’t a problem…at all. I haven’t tried it on my Titan Flex, yet.

The only way I could ride it on my road bike was to imagine I was on rollers…you know how you just sort of look ahead when on rollers, and try to keep your center of gravity over the middle of the rollers, while your bike squirrels around under you until you relax enough that it feels natural and smooth? Neither do I :wink:

Well, just do that when you have the H3 on…and stay far enough away from the white line that you don’t fight it…and let the bike squirrel around a bit. Oh, and KEEP PEDALING! You’ll learn that the bike isn’t going to fly off into the bushes, it’s just going to wiggle a little. OR, you’ll find out that your geometry/handling skills suck, in which case, you’ll be happier with something else…either different geometry, better handling, or a different wheel.

i actually think that the heft of the h3 would support all riders. they are certainly more sturdy then my 404s. so if a clyde can’t ride a pair of h3s, i don’t know what you can ride.

i really don’t see how hed has said anything that would expose them to any sort of lawsuit. in a wind tunnel, they are one of the most areo wheel sets out there. i’m a really light guy and i would expect that i would have more problem on them then a heavy rider ( i do with a disk) and i have had no trouble with their handling in windy race conditions.

your post just seems a little dramatic and over the top.

OOOOPPPPSSS,

Your right, thats what I get for reading too fast, My bad, anyway, to each his own, I tried to make them work but just couldnt, the freaking wind was too brutal and I was all over the place. Its not a handling issue with me, I favor a smooth handling set of wheels so I can concentrate on the race at hand, thats all, I have nothing against HED or anybody, BUT if one makes a claim then back it up.

.

I’ve ridden HED 3 front and back on my P2k for the last three years, and have never had a handling problem. But I am 6/2 and 210 or so, and don’t get blown around easily.

I have ridden hed 3’s almost exclusively for the last 18 months of training for h/im and im distance races. I rode them on a poorly configured tcr and a well set up tcr and now a well set up serotta. I think that I have covered all weather with exception for snow. And I must say that sure you can feel lateral pressure from wind but I would say that and handling issues are rider borne not wheel based.

What does your bike set up look like are you on the hairy edge of the handling envelope?

Are the Hed’s for sale?

pm me if they are.

K

I rode a front disc on the ROAD last year, wow, that was scary

It was like trying to fly a kite while pedalling
.

Let’s be real. If the H3 or any wheel was the best at handling, speed, power, and comfort, there would be no reason to look for another wheel. Nothing would compare. You give up a little handling for more speed, a little comfort for more power, etc…and it all comes with a nice price tag too.

I have only had the chance to ride a nice race wheelset one time, and it was at Ultramax this year. Prior experience was my $139 cool looking Xaro Supergo wheels that I trained and raced on. For the race, I had a Zipp disk in the rear, and a nimble up front and here were my observations. (not a H3 but it falls into your “somewhat more stable” description because there was a disk in the rear). I am sure there were handling concerns, but I was halfway through the race when I realized that I had not been concerned at all with the crosswinds. The real difference was in my time. Obviously, no cars passing me at speed, but then again, what races have cars going by at 60 MPH? That’s what training is for.

If you don’t like the feel of the H3’s, then I have to ask, “are they 700’ s and tubular?” If they are, then how much do you want for them? Honestly, if you don’t like them, ride what you feel most comfortable with. Its your butt in the saddle, not anyone else’s.

http://www.vo2testing.com/vo2testing3_010.htm

go here, the PDF page should work- scroll down to page 6- it shows that a dual tri spoke will actually outperform hed jets in windy conditions based on side force, and almost identical based on axial force. this is the actual data from wind tunnel testing I did in the wind tunnel at MIT. It comes down to how well you can stabalize and control a bike in windy conditions.

I am a feather weight 150 lbs, HED 3 front disc rear and soon to be HED 3 rear. I dont see any problems coming my way so far, are we going to quit bashing these great wheels soon?

Maybe your inability to control your bike with H3s in windy conditions is more a function of your bike setup or handling skills than it is the wheel and the wind. Countless professionals seem to have no trouble using H3s. They’ve riding them for many, many years. You’re pretty bold, taking a reputable and proven manufacturer and product to task on a public message board based on nothing more substantial than the experience you had today, which starkly contrasts the scientific data (read those last two words again, most people find them to be important) available on this and other wheels.

Any change in your bike configuration is going to result in a different experience. Did you really expect that two radically different shaped wheels would feel the same?

Being affected by the wind is what makes them the fastest wheels around. Some people with poor riding skills can’t handle that.