So I have read all the data here and I would like to just try and get a straight answer…between Hed 3 and Carbones my question is follows:
Which is the better wheelset for someone who hates the instability of deeper rimmed wheels in any crosswind (translation - not the best bike handler but decent enough for tris) and wants an aero wheel thats good for a course that would range from flat to no hillier than Timberman…
No experience with either but from all I’ve read the H3 is hard to handle in the iwnd. The Carbone should be okay as is any 50mm wheel. Do a search and you’ll find tons about the H3’s.
I can’t speak about the Mavic Cosmics as I have never ridden them. If I use the Jet 50’s as a similar wheel & I had to choose between the 50’s & a H3, I would choose the H3’s in a heart beat.
I ride with a HED3 on the front all of the time. When I get hit with a cross wind, it can give a pretty good twitch, which was a bit unnerving at first.
But after a few hours of riding I got used to it, and it doesn’t bother me at all anymore.
I have an H3, Jet65, Spinergy Tilium and Velocity Spartacus front wheel selection. Initially the Jet65 was pretty hard to handle with a conventional rear rim, and even kind of a handful with my Renn disc. I was reluctant to ride it on windy days, but my method of learning was just to ride it all the time with a Velocity Spartacus rear (30mm) for a few hundred miles. These days the winds need to be in excess of 20mph before I would even think of going to the Tilium from the H3. However, the Tilium (now Stealth SS I think) is a really nice, strong and comfy medium-depth rim. I think mine measured about 45mm but I can’t remember the exact distance right now. I’d get one of those over a massively overpriced Carbone any day if you are concerned about depth and handling.
I love my HED 3s. They do give you notice when there is a crosswind, but I think most people who don’t like them exaggerate the effect. The wheels have been bombproof so far, are aero and look great. Mavic makes some really nice Mtn wheels, but I’ve always found their road wheels to be a little too much flash over function, especially for the price.
I rode the Cosmic Carbones for two seasons (including two races at Timberman) and recently switched to a set of tri-spokes (older pre-HED Specialized model). The only reason I switched is that I got a very good deal on the tri-spokes and was able to sell the Carbones and still pocket several hundred dollars. Both are great wheels that in my experience have proven bombproof. I never had any issue with the Carbones in crosswinds, but have had a few with the tri-spokes. As others have stated, it’s not that bad and just takes getting used to.
You’ll be happy with either wheel, although I think the tri-spokes look better on most bikes (and that matters more than most of us like to admit.) One additional reference point: Simon Lessing won IMLP on Cosmic Carbones, so I gather that they work pretty well on hilly courses.
Sounds to me like a Zipp 404 would be the correct, and fastest choice for what you want to do. The carbone cannot even compete with the aerodynamics of the 404, which is as fast as an H3, and doesn’t have the nasty wind temper. If price is an issue, go with a Flashpoint FP60, which has the same shape as a 404, weighs a little more, but is still a true carbon deep section rim.
Excellent Feedback everyone- and while I appreciate that Lessing rode them at Placid, I wouldnt put my avg 20mph up against anything that man did…but its nice to know that he liked 'em!
Thanks everyone…I think Im going Carbones- yes the tri-spoke looks better but I’m not the bravest cyclist and prefer to avoid crosswind issues period…
One simple solution to the problem of poor handling in crosswind situations is to run a very deep (50mm or so) fork. John Cobb has demonstrated that it significantly decreases the amount of torque applied to the front wheel in a crosswind situations.
Forgive my ignorance…what is the standard depth of a fork? Can you name some deeper forks? I have an Easton- the one that comes with gurus- i need to check size for precise details but it seems pretty deep to me already.
I have ridden both and wouldn’t trade my H3cs for anything in triathlon. Solid and easy to get used to. If it is too windy for H3s then it is too windy for any deeper rim. I found them to be stiffer than the Mavics and 404s that I’ve ridden.
Good choice! I raced on Cosmic Carbons for 2 years and switched to HED3c for sponsoring reasons 2 years ago. I still regret the Carbons, versatile, sturdy wheels with an amazing smooth hub, which gave me lots of inertia.
The HED3c might be more aerodynamic in the lab, but the hubs sucks on the road and the front wheel is difficult to handle in hard cross winds, I had 2 near-crash close calls on them.
Thanks speedy…I will check for specks on my easton…i think im doing the conservative thing and getting the carbones…i can always borrow friends heds 3 or zipps and discs…