This won’t solve the OP problem, but for those with high HR spikes at the beginning of runs, I find that it’s always technical shirts + static electricity build up. I take a fabric softener sheet and rub the inside and outside of my shirt and the HR strap right before I go to remove the static cling. Voila. no more HR spikes with the straps. Bonus: you can pretty much re-use the fabric softener sheet forever.
I’ve just gone through my fifth Garmin Premium Soft Strap. Each time, Garmin will send a replacement with instructions on how to “maintain” it. Each time, the strap works perfectly for about three months and then the HR Spikes start coming. That’s the tell tell sign that it’s going bad. Changed batteries, etc. Not the issue. The strap sensors and/or unit just don’t last very long, especially if you’re prone to sweating. I have since gone back to my hard strap for daily use and will use the soft strap for racing since it is more lightweight and comfortable.
I’ve just gone through my fifth Garmin Premium Soft Strap. Each time, Garmin will send a replacement with instructions on how to “maintain” it. Each time, the strap works perfectly for about three months and then the HR Spikes start coming. That’s the tell tell sign that it’s going bad. Changed batteries, etc. Not the issue. The strap sensors and/or unit just don’t last very long, especially if you’re prone to sweating. I have since gone back to my hard strap for daily use and will use the soft strap for racing since it is more lightweight and comfortable.
Although it hasn’t been out for a super long time, I really like the Wahoo Tickr. The wrote their own firmware so you don’t get those high HR spikes when you have a bad connection. It also seems to pick up my HR pretty well.
I’ve just gone through my fifth Garmin Premium Soft Strap. Each time, Garmin will send a replacement with instructions on how to “maintain” it. Each time, the strap works perfectly for about three months and then the HR Spikes start coming. That’s the tell tell sign that it’s going bad. Changed batteries, etc. Not the issue. The strap sensors and/or unit just don’t last very long, especially if you’re prone to sweating. I have since gone back to my hard strap for daily use and will use the soft strap for racing since it is more lightweight and comfortable.
Yeah…spikes are not a sign that the battery is dying. I too will try changing the battery, sometimes to no avail.
My troubleshooting/diagnosis/treatment for the straps is:
HR dropouts early in the workout - bad conduction - use gel
HR dropouts late in (or throughout) the workout - bad battery - replace battery
HR dropouts late in the workout /w new battery - bad transmitter pod - new pod (if possible, otherwise all new strap)
HR spikes - static - use different shirt or dryer sheet (dryer sheet works for me with running, but any loose fit cycling jerseys will give static no matter what I try)
After a couple of months though the thing was incredibly in consistent tracking HR. It was completely unreliable. Reporting heart rates all over the place. Dropping out after a couple miles on a run and then miraculously coming back
You do not say on your post whether you are cleaning the soft strap, but the fact that it went inconsistent after a couple of months would typically indicate a failure to clean. All that salt and stuff builds up in the fabric and causes shorts (this is why the hard strap doesn’t have this problem – no fabric in which salt can build up). First remove the module (it is water proof, but why put it through the unnecessary torture. Then, the washing instructions are on the strap (either hand wash or machine wash, depending on strap) – do not put in dryer. Garmin recommends every 7 uses, but that seems overkill to me.
I’m the OP: I thoroughly rinse strap after each use and hang dry. Never run it through washing machine though.
Yeah…spikes are not a sign that the battery is dying. I too will try changing the battery, sometimes to no avail.
My troubleshooting/diagnosis/treatment for the straps is:
HR dropouts early in the workout - bad conduction - use gel
HR dropouts late in (or throughout) the workout - bad battery - replace battery
HR dropouts late in the workout /w new battery - bad transmitter pod - new pod (if possible, otherwise all new strap)
HR spikes - static - use different shirt or dryer sheet (dryer sheet works for me with running, but any loose fit cycling jerseys will give static no matter what I try)
I always had problem with the HR dropping late into the workout. I purchased a whole new strap and monitor and still got the same result. From what I understand, sweat actually helps conduct the signal better. However, have you guys ever experienced where too much sweat or water actually causes the drop in HR?
The old soft “premium” strap sucks, ditch it. The hard strap worked for me for a couple years and I went back to it after the soft strap started to do the exact same thing you are experiencing. The hard strap was still working just fine (over 5 years of use) when I got the new HRM Run strap with my Fenix 2, looks like this:
https://buy.garmin.com/en-US/US/shop-by-accessories/fitness-sensors/hrm-run-/prod133715.html
This one has been rock solid for 6ish months now, way longer than any of the previous model soft straps lasted. It provides some extra functionality though and isn’t worth the money if you don’t have a compatible device. It does look like the “new” strap is available now:
My old premium strap did not have that conductive material weaved through it and I have a feeling that is what is fixing the issue.
This is a pic of my current HRM strap. My wife’s looks a bit different, it’s still a soft strap but has a weave or something in it (like steelerguy’s link above). I’m thinking of switching strap brand to compare performance. I’ll report back my results. It can’t be the battery, from what I’ve read, because a dying battery can’t pick itself back up like my plot shows.

That’s the crappy one for sure.
Yeah…spikes are not a sign that the battery is dying. I too will try changing the battery, sometimes to no avail.
My troubleshooting/diagnosis/treatment for the straps is:
HR dropouts early in the workout - bad conduction - use gel
HR dropouts late in (or throughout) the workout - bad battery - replace battery
HR dropouts late in the workout /w new battery - bad transmitter pod - new pod (if possible, otherwise all new strap)
HR spikes - static - use different shirt or dryer sheet (dryer sheet works for me with running, but any loose fit cycling jerseys will give static no matter what I try)
I always had problem with the HR dropping late into the workout. I purchased a whole new strap and monitor and still got the same result. From what I understand, sweat actually helps conduct the signal better. However, have you guys ever experienced where too much sweat or water actually causes the drop in HR?
Interesting…I did a trainer ride where I was sweating buckets and did start to get drop outs. I thought the strap was done, but it has been fine otherwise. I could imagine that if someone sweats that much all the time that they would have consistent problems.