K-factor thread got me thinking, as far as frames are concerned what is really in the wind while riding. Seems like there are a ton of variables that make any pure testing of various frames unreliable. For example, the down tube is behind a spinning wheel, the headtube is partially hidden by aerobars or brakes and possibly completely by an aerobottle, seattube is behind a water bottle, seat post has spare and inflator or bottles behind it. Seems logical aerobars/basebars would have a greater frontal area than the frame. Further, seems like the most important pieces would be how the fork and seat stay shapes interact with the airflow caused by the wheels. No data to support any of this, anyone know better? I may just be attempting to justify buying an aero basebar to myself as I am stuck in an airport.
the beauty is that wind come from all side´s
and there are statistics on wich angle the wind comes most of the time and at what speed
and this for almost evry place on earth where humans live
.
true, guess on the right course a sail/cover over the front triangle could be fast, kinda like windsurfing
.
One thing I am surprised at is that no one has documented what flow is best when it hits the body. Shoulders, arms, chest,stomach thighs is likely the biggest frontal area of the package, in most cases forming a “cup” against the wind and I haven’t seen any analysis of what we want to happen to the airflow when it hits that cup. If you look at Formula 1 cars, one of the biggest leaps they made in speed was to channel the flow of the air, not only for downforce but for all sorts of bends as the air goes past the body.
Do we riders want the air to exit through our legs and exhaust out under the seat? Or is it faster to have the air to ball up a bit aginst the torso and deflect the main stream of the air around the body? Is Floyd’s “praying mantis” position more aero than using straight bars? I saw an analyticcycling test where regular bends turned out to be more aero than straight. Seems there is a whole lot more to learn in the area of areo dynamics.
One thing I am surprised at is that no one has documented what flow is best when it hits the body.
well this is not true since i always test in 0 till 30 degree in angle of attack so you see what is the best also the force that belong to that aera, it make no sense in only test 0 degree of yaw since in 99 % you ride always in a certain degree of yaw
What does 30 degrees angle of attach translate to?
Would that equal a 20 mph rider in a 10 mph cross (90 degrees) wind?
Ths is what people go to the wind tunnel for. Everyone is different. The wind tunnel optimizes the body position.
Ric
“Is Floyd’s “praying mantis” position more aero than using straight bars? I saw an analyticcycling test where regular bends turned out to be more aero than straight. Seems there is a whole lot more to learn in the area of areo dynamics.”
-
When the aero bars first came out in the late 80’s we all rode them like Floyd is doing now - hands up higher mimicking what the downhill skiers do.
-
Now with the straight or dropped front end, the postioning looks like a giant cup and way LESS aero. I say “Looks” cause I am just basing this on how it looks.
So, question to the aerodynamic engineers, expertes and gurus out there, what is better?
Fleck
The arms themselves do very little from what I’ve heard. What it does do is keep his aerobars within the 75cm or whatever the UCI rule is, and also allows a good “shrug”(narrow shoulders with a low head)
As Cees mentioned, testing only at “o” yaw is a waste of time, especially for Triathletes. We’ve done lot’s of testing to study where the air goes, it changes significantly from rider to rider and men to women especially. Generally I have found that the Landis hand position isn’t quite as fast because it blocks the air from accerlerating from the stomach area and out over the hips. If your in a wind tunnel and are using a smoke wand, you can see that the air that goes into the chest area moves a great deal. It will almost completley dump out the side with the rider leg down so it is constantly moving side to side. This makes it very important to have the right fabric and a tight fabric over the stomach area. A simple rule of thumb for me is to get the point where your Trap muscle come over the ribs to be at least level with your shoulder top. That forms a nice wing that will suck air off the chest area. Shoulder shapes effect hand width on the aero bars, usually, broad square shouldered riders need their hands a little wider than more rounded shouldered riders. Air that hits the front left shoulder can be easily pulled across the back and exit from behind the right knee!! You need to use the air that exists over your hips to keep this from happening.
great post john Cobb!!!
As Cees mentioned, testing only at “o” yaw is a waste of time, especially for Triathletes. We’ve done lot’s of testing to study where the air goes, it changes significantly from rider to rider and men to women especially. Generally I have found that the Landis hand position isn’t quite as fast because it blocks the air from accerlerating from the stomach area and out over the hips. If your in a wind tunnel and are using a smoke wand, you can see that the air that goes into the chest area moves a great deal. It will almost completley dump out the side with the rider leg down so it is constantly moving side to side. This makes it very important to have the right fabric and a tight fabric over the stomach area. A simple rule of thumb for me is to get the point where your Trap muscle come over the ribs to be at least level with your shoulder top. That forms a nice wing that will suck air off the chest area. Shoulder shapes effect hand width on the aero bars, usually, broad square shouldered riders need their hands a little wider than more rounded shouldered riders. Air that hits the front left shoulder can be easily pulled across the back and exit from behind the right knee!! You need to use the air that exists over your hips to keep this from happening.
Thank you for the response, John. A couple of questions come to mind: Has anyone every determined a “typical” yaw for a tri tt course? It seems that any wind angle is offset pretty quickly by a turn in the road, almost to the point of having so many yaw angles in a single course to make testing for one almost useless. What assumption do you make for that? So the traps level with the shoulders (i.e. a straight “top wing” minus the head) helps pull the air stream up and over the body? And the best way to direct air is up and over, vs. around? It would seem that one of the biggest issue in aero is actually what happens behind your body to allow the air to get past you faster, perhaps even more than the frontal area, if air flows from left shoulder across back to right knee. Is there much we can do about that, given the rule against fairings? Maybe keep your water bottles in your back pockets?
Maybe every RD should provide this by having a test rider ride the course with a wind gage on their helmet and record the data. He could tell us on an “average” day the apparent wind was at 30 degrees for 60% of the time and 45 degrees 15% of the time, etc. Then you tune your position and gear to optimize those average numbers. Either than or just say f*&% it and pedal harder…
dust
.
true, guess on the right course a sail/cover over the front triangle could be fast, kinda like windsurfing
Trimble tried this in the early 1990s - it didn’t work.
true, guess on the right course a sail/cover over the front triangle could be fast, kinda like windsurfing
Except that while sailing the sail is backed off some from the line of travel.
Victor
I guess that I should have used the
to indicate that I was kidding
.
John is spot on with his assessment here, the one thing I would have to add is that there are always exceptions to the rule and really the only way to know is to test personally, of the dozen athlete testing sessions I’ve been involved in over the past few years, there has been at least one person at every test that just seemed to blow all of the standard positioning thoughts out of the water. Floyd is a great example, I was in the tunnel with him last February intent on getting rid of his crazy position, and had been at MIT a few months earlier with a couple of athletes and found the landis positon to be terrible with every one of them, then low and behold after about 4 hours the fastest position for Floyd by far…almost exactly what he had. We made a modified pad setup out of PVC pipe so that his arms were basically touching at the elbows and it got even faster. The next day we tried all of the same things with Santiago Botero and he was markedly slower with his arms angled up every time. I think why this worked for Floyd is taht he has pretty wide hips and very large hands combined with narrow shoulders, so I think that with his arms slightly wider or horizontal we were getting lots of flow across the front of the body. Botero also fit the broad shoulder suggestion John Had, we widened him up about 2cm and he want about 3-4% faster.
Key things that seem to not have exception, are removing all clothing wrinkles and and folds, and keeping the aero helmet sealed to the back of the rider. I don’t think I’ve ever seen somebody exhibit lower drag with a gap between helmet and back…but then I’m sure that probably works for somebody.
To answer Reggies questionk, you can calculate your own wind angles by using the inverse tangent of (windspeed/rider speed). So for 14.5mph wind and 25mph rider speed, the max possible wind angle is 30deg. For 10mph wind and 25mph rider speed it becomes 21.8deg and so on. These angles are the max possible wind angle, so figuring that wind distribution will follow a bell curve shape between 0 and max angle you can determine wind angle probability, the bell curve model is a great generalizer except in some conditions like Kona where the course is out and back and the winds are generally consitently from one direction, but that condition is even easier to assign probability to. We focus most all our efforts and angles between 10 and 20 degrees, which second priority on angles between 5 and 10. Cees is right in talking about 0 degrees, there is generally a less than 1% probability of 0 degree wind unless you are indoors so studying or optimizing on that condition is probably a waste of time and money, unless you are racing indoors of course.
sorry for my ignorance but can you explain this?
“A simple rule of thumb for me is to get the point where your Trap muscle come over the ribs to be at least level with your shoulder top. That forms a nice wing that will suck air off the chest area.”
thanks
. Cees is right in talking about 0 degrees, there is generally a less than 1% probability of 0 degree wind unless you are indoors so studying or optimizing on that condition is probably a waste of time and money, unless you are racing indoors of course. well even indoors you hardly get any o yaw this becuase there is always a wind turbelance indoors, at least that are our measurements **** ****