Feeling guilty about gaining weight, even if it's all muscle

So… I’m one of those people who lost weight over the holidays. Actually I’ve been losing since October, when I stopped swimming entirely in lieu of focusing a lot more on running. I think I lost a small bit of fat from the running, but mostly I think I lost arm/shoulder/torso muscle. Race weight for me last season was 140 (I’m a 5’9" lady) and I was stunned to get back in the pool (the only time I weigh myself is at the pool) on January 2nd to find out I only weighed 132! Not only that, but swimming intially was REALLY slow and painful, and it’s just starting to improve.

In addition to swimming, I’ve been lifting weights twice a week. And now I think I’m starting to gain weight again (noticing a general pattern upward that I think excludes water-weight fluctuations, etc), and since swimming and lifting is getting easier, I guess I can attribute it to muscle gain.

I’m glad I’m getting stronger, but I’m feeling kind of paranoid about gaining weight. After reading the “last 5 pounds” thread, the obesity thread, and reading all the things about “losing X equals Y gain in speed” … I’m afraid to gain weight, even if it’s all lean muscle. Especially because I believe that stuff is true based on what I’ve experienced. While I lost a lot of swimming speed going from 140 to 132 … my run times improved dramatically. For what it’s worth I’m doing about 8 hours a week of SBR (12 hrs of exercise including cross-training) and I eat SUPER healthy (ZERO junk food/coffee/soda/candy).

Anyone else have the similar issues? Advice?

I think a lot of people are fixated on numbers (ie. the number on a scale). If you feel good and are happy with the way you look, forget the scale.

“Guilt” is an interesting emotion to describe how you’re feeling? What exactly do you feel guilty about? If it is muscle that will improve your performance, that’s a good thing (granted you might see your run times slow a teeny bit).

seconding the advice to not weigh yourself. If you don’t have numbers you can’t obsess about it.

I’ll agree with the others, if you look and feel good then why bother with a number? I personally know I can lose about another 5lbs but everyone else tells me im getting too skinny. I am one of those people that would rather be an extra 5lbs heavier and feel better then be 5 lbs lighter and feel like shit. Your prob swimming slower because you lost some upper body muscle but after about a month you will be getting back and track and you might even find your swimming a bit better than before(this is exactly what happened to me). If you eat healthy like you say you do your body will regulate itself and get down to its desired composition, which will likely be exactly where you should be. BTW how is the running in the cold coming along? Did you run the 15k yesterday, that was COLD!!!

"Advice? "

Throw away the scale.

Without before/after body fat measurements, it’s tough to say precisely what’s happened to you.

Sometimes what’s happened is that once you give your body a chance to really get the glycogen stores 100% loaded, it manifests in weight gain. But it’s usually temporary. And it would be considered lean mass.

I doubt you lost 8 lbs. of muscle. I also think you are discounting just how much extra calorie burn a run focus can create. You may have lost 1 lb-2 lb of upper body muscle, but again without measurements, who can say?. You may have dropped 5 lbs. of fat.

If you are now putting ON weight, it has to be because you are eating more than you need to maintain the low weight, so you must be putting on some fat. Nobody “just” adds muscle. Body builders eat to bulk up, knowing they will also put on fat, and then they do a fat-cutting phase to specifically drop off fat. For some folks, the more they exercise, the “better” the appetite. Some people actually experience suppressed appetite when running a lot.

If you felt good at a race weight of 140, don’t sweat the weight gain.

I keep track of my measurements in about 8 areas as well as my weight. When I do a run focus block, like I just did, I get ultra lean on top (but don’t drop muscle since I keep up the weight training), and I acquire a bit extra muscle (girth) in my legs. When I drop back to normal running, the legs lean out a bit more and the fat seems to go back on top. Go figure. FWIW, you could do this to track how your body changes throughout a season. Mine does, so when things feel “off,” I get out the tape and see where it went (assuming weight is the same).

I typically only swim 3-4 hours a week, but even if I drop off to 2, that alone won’t make a difference in my upper body muscle. I don’t swim enough for it to be a muscle building exercise. Perhaps you do.