http://www.cyclingnews.com/news/contadors-climbing-credibility-questioned
Great analysis of a problem and rationale explanation deserves noting.
So, props to you Dr. Coggan.
Bob
http://www.cyclingnews.com/news/contadors-climbing-credibility-questioned
Great analysis of a problem and rationale explanation deserves noting.
So, props to you Dr. Coggan.
Bob
“Taking everything into consideration, I’d say that a more reasonable estimate of Contador’s power during that ascent is about 450 W, which would require a sustained VO2 of ‘only’ 80 mL/kg/min. That is still quite high, but not so high that you can definitively state that it can only be achieved via doping.”
from what I’ve read on ST, that would put him about MOP…
from what I’ve read on ST that wouldn’t put you anywhere.
at the top level, V02 max is all over the place and doesn’t correlate much with actual biking times.
humans like to focus on 1 paramter
but sometimes reality involves hundreds.
“Taking everything into consideration, I’d say that a more reasonable estimate of Contador’s power during that ascent is about 450 W, which would require a sustained VO2 of ‘only’ 80 mL/kg/min. That is still quite high, but not so high that you can definitively state that it can only be achieved via doping.”
from what I’ve read on ST, that would put him about MOP…
from what I’ve read on ST that wouldn’t put you anywhere.
at the top level, V02 max is all over the place and doesn’t correlate much with actual biking times.
humans like to focus on 1 paramter
but sometimes reality involves hundreds.
well, while it certainly ‘involves hundreds of parameters’, the combination of aerobic capacity and cycling efficiency give a damn good indicator of one’s performance capabilities.
and weight and aerodynamics and mental toughness and tactics and pacing strategy and so on =)
it would be cool if we could have perfectly calibrated power meters on all these cyclists and debate these kinds of this more accurately, but thats probably impossible.
from what I’ve read on ST that wouldn’t put you anywhere.
at the top level, V02 max is all over the place and doesn’t correlate much with actual biking times.
humans like to focus on 1 paramter
but sometimes reality involves hundreds.
well, while it certainly ‘involves hundreds of parameters’, the combination of aerobic capacity and cycling efficiency give a damn good indicator of one’s performance capabilities.
yeah, that crossed my mind! really, no power meter?? what is this, 2001??
I was all set to argue with Coggan, but looking at CA Sorenson’s power file, I think the 450 calculation is probably correct, +/- 20W, and the vo2 calculation is the same that I came up with, +/- 8 ml/kg/l–so unfortunately I really can’t argue with him.
Note that I was disputing this when someone else suggest 370-410W up this climb, which didn’t make sense to me.
how about the fact that Lemond has never met a fast cyclist he didn’t accuse of using PEDs
what a sory excuse for a sportsman
.
yes, but direct evidence has shown us that he has been more or less correct.
almost everyone fast in the era since him, till now, save armstrong, has been caught red handed with PED usage.
and even armstrong may have been caught red handed via those 1999 epo samples.
i agree he is obessed and won’t shut up.
but i won’t say he is wrong.
how about the fact that Lemond has never met a fast cyclist he didn’t accuse of using PEDs
what a sory excuse for a sportsman
unfortunately I really can’t argue with him.
Don’t feel badly - not many can (successfully, anyway). ![]()
how about the fact that Lemond has never met a fast cyclist he didn’t accuse of using PEDs
what a sory excuse for a sportsman
what about carlos sastre?..oh wait…FAST…hmmm
.
when you can TT within 2mph of sastre I will allow such comments
until then, they are not allowed
=)
what about carlos sastre?..oh wait…FAST…hmmm
.
Good read but I have to say which I have stated before.
“LeMond needs to shut the fuck up and move on in his life”
This guy has no respect for the sport that put him on the map.
LeMond, please shut the hell up and roll over and die.
I think the capital M in his name is for MORON
Here is what kills me…Lemond has invested his money well and ha smore money than God, so he could start his own “clean” cycling team and show the world “how its done right.”
Unfortunately, rather than being part of the problem, most time he’s taking pot-shots from the peanut gallery…
I have no idea who is clean and not but honestly who is to say that LeMond was clean his whole cycling career. That is what bugs me the most. Should we go back in time and start to question all the results that LeMond had and start skewing the numbers to make it look like some of his performances were in question?
I have no idea who is clean and not but honestly who is to say that LeMond was clean his whole cycling career. That is what bugs me the most. Should we go back in time and start to question all the results that LeMond had and start skewing the numbers to make it look like some of his performances were in question?
I found it highly ironic that in that recent sports conference he spoke at (that had the video posted all over the internet), the MC announces him as “the man who still holds the record for the fastest Tour TT speed”, or something like that. So, once GL got up to speak, he spent the first couple of minutes saying “it was downhill, there was a tailwind, etc., etc.” to try to explain how he could have produced such an “outlier” performance, especially on the equipment of the day. He then went on to say further in his speedh that just such outlier performances should be taken as evidence of doping.
As I watched, I just sat there and chuckled “Dude, do you realize what you just said?”
I like GL and all, and have fond memories of watching him race, but I have a feeling that logic isn’t one of his strong points…
As I watched, I just sat there and chuckled “Dude, do you realize what you just said?”
I like GL and all, and have fond memories of watching him race, but I have a feeling that logic isn’t one of his strong points…
He’s not the only one since this is the first time I’ve seen this point made, and to me, it is the elephant in the room. I’m certainly not claiming GL was doped, but his argument using performance as his sole criteria for evidence of doping is essentially a case of pot calling the kettle black.
I just do not like him going out of his way to make a point when the data is flawed or skewed to make it look like someone is up to no good. This just makes him look like a bitter old man that feels the world has past him by. Yes Greg, you will always be the first American to win the Tour de France but I have news for you, someone else has done it better than you.
I used to follow Greg a lot when I was younger and looked up to him. I had my team jerseys and begged my parents to buy me some of the Scott aerobars when I saw him using them for the first time.
In the end I guess I just feel bad for this guy. It is very sad to see where he is now versus where he used to be. SAD!